#257 Missing Biological Qualifier

[Sarah Keating]

There is a new Biological Qualifier 'hasTaxon' listed on the qualifier site http://www.ebi.ac.uk/miriam/main/qualifiers/ that is not mentioned in our Table 8 on Page 91 of the L3V1 spec.

Presumably this qualifier did not exist when the spec was produced but L3V2 needs to remember to add it.

[Lucian Smith]

This hadn't had the l3v1 tag, so it was missed in my initial sweep. Unfortunately, even thought it's straightforward, it can't quite be classified as a typo, so you all need to vote on it; I think it has conformance implications.

[Michael Hucka]

I accept this issue as valid, and the proposed solution.

[Nicolas Le Novère]

I accept this issue as valid, and the proposed solution.

[Dagmar Waltemath]

I accept this issue as valid, and the proposed solution.

[Brett Olivier]

I agree with the proposed change, and it should be done.

[Frank Bergmann]

Could we not add this Taxon in another Release of L3V1? Sort of as a 'missed' element to be listed? As such it could be easily added via an Errata, and would not need to wait for a new version.

I accept this issue as valid.

[Michael Hucka]

It could be done that way too.

[Brett Olivier]

+1 for doing this as soon as possible. Other people are probably more diligent than me but when implementing MIRIAM support I automatically used their list of qualifiers ... assuming they were valid in SBML as well.

[Lucian Smith]

Enough editors have agreed that we should do this; changing it to 'accepted'.

[Lucian Smith]

Added L2v4 to this issue, and added it to SVN for both. This change will be incorporated into the forthcoming L2v5 and L3v2 specifications.