Menu

#622 Can't record Ogg Theora videos

v2.4.x
closed-fixed
None
FFMPEG
2018-05-18
2015-03-08
No

I am using VICE 2.4.18, rev 29455M compiled with --enable-static-ffmpeg and --enable-gnomeui. This version of VICE can be used to record a video using the "Save media file…" command of the "Snapshot" menu. However, video recording does not work at all when the container format is set to "ogg" (which automatically selects the Theora and FLAC codecs). With this setting, trying to record a video produces the error dialog "Couldn't write screenshot to /tmp/foo.ogg' with driverFFMPEG'." and the following message on the text console:

FFMPEG: Driver: ogg, ac: 86028, vc: 31
ffmpegdrv: Cannot find suitable video codec
Screenshot: Error - Saving failed...

Discussion

  • gpz

    gpz - 2015-03-17

    confirmed

     
  • Querino

    Querino - 2015-03-20

    same in windows, but it works if i use some other precompiled ffmpeg dlls.

     
  • Andreas Matthies

    The internal ffmpeg libs don't contain the needed ogg/theora libs yet, so this is "by design". Will try to hide containers/codecs in the GUI that are not supported.

     
  • Andreas Matthies

    • status: open --> pending-fixed
     
  • Andreas Matthies

    Fixed in r29569 which implements dynamic determination of the supported formats and codecs.

     
  • Querino

    Querino - 2015-04-06

    this is a nice solution, and it works. :)

    however, i wonder why there is only FLAC/Theora if ogg is selected? shouldn't there be at least also vorbis?

    also matroska supports a lot more codecs than the ones offered in VICE.

     
  • Andreas Matthies

    Please make a suggestion for the codecs you want in matroska Container, then I can test and add them.

     
  • gpz

    gpz - 2018-05-18
    • status: pending-fixed --> closed-fixed
    • Port: GTK -->
     

Log in to post a comment.