Re: [uml-devel] [PATCH] Locking user-mode kernel RAM into host physical RAM

[Matthew B. <ma...@by...>]

=2D----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

On Monday 08 December 2003 19:01, Jeff Dike wrote:
> As far as I'm concerned, this is papering over the symptoms rather than
> fixing a real problem.
>
> If you're really not overselling memory, then the host should not be
> swapping. If it is, then that's the problem.

Hi Jeff, I don't think this is true.  The 2.4 kernel does appear to swap ou=
t=20
applications when (e.g.) a large file copy is underway, and the 2.6 kernel=
=20
has been tweaked to get around this problem:

http://kerneltrap.org/node/view/1044

We've not had enough time to try 2.6 on a production server as a host kerne=
l,=20
but I'd be interested if you did know a way of tweaking a 2.4 host kernel t=
o=20
guarantee RAM-locked pages to user-mode kernels; Matt Ayres mentioned "some=
=20
interactivity and vm patches", could you elaborate on that please Matt?  Fo=
r=20
various reasons, we use a Redhat 2.4.20 kernel which I believe has had its=
=20
memory management fiddled with.

I like the sound of the more dynamic memory arrangement and manager daemon =
for=20
UMLs, sounds like a good way to squeeze more customers onto a host machine.=
 =20
But if for the moment the only thing it should do is to keep the host from=
=20
swapping, I know from a few our customers that mlocking has given more=20
predictable behaviour from guest kernels, especially if the host load spike=
s=20
for a few minutes.  That's my only argument as to why it should be included=
:=20
mlocked kernels behave more predictably in a hosting environment!  But=20
obviously I'm biased; if I can get the same effect without the patch on a 2=
=2E4=20
host kernel I'd agree it's moot.

=2D --=20
Matthew Bloch                             Bytemark Hosting
                                  tel. +44 (0) 8707 455026
                        http://www.bytemark-hosting.co.uk/
          Dedicated Linux hosts from 15ukp ($26) per month
=2D----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.3 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQE/1Pn5T2rVDg8aLXQRAuMmAJ9BXfBodQcUX2AMPUfHdrKAtKTSMgCcCBc1
MI6K3OJQUdG1uqvzKq8MOMw=3D
=3DZip4
=2D----END PGP SIGNATURE-----