Menu

#739 Opening a proved proof - prune the proof

3.1
closed-invalid
nobody
None
2
2015-05-19
2015-02-24
Luis Diaz
No

In rodin 3.1, sometimes, when a proved proof if re-opened the proof is pruned

Discussion

  • Laurent Voisin

    Laurent Voisin - 2015-03-04
    • status: open --> closed-works-for-me
     
  • Laurent Voisin

    Laurent Voisin - 2015-03-04

    Dear Luiz, thank you very much for having taken the time to report this problem.

    However, I think that this is a normal behavior. It happens when your proof is no longer compatible with the proof obligation (e.g., the first applied rule references a goal which is different from the current one).

    However, until you save the new proof, your old proof is still there on the hard-disk and you can inspect it using the proof skeleton view. You even can copy parts of the old proof tree with copy/paste into the new proof.

    If I have misunderstood you, do not hesitate to reopen this bug and give more details.

     
  • Luis Diaz

    Luis Diaz - 2015-03-06

    Hello Lauren,

    I will describe the scenario where it happen.
    Being in the proving perspective, finish a proof (green face), press save, and in this moment the proof is prune.

    There is not any change in the model that can cause the invalidation of the proof. it is simply when save the proof.

    bets regards

     
  • Laurent Voisin

    Laurent Voisin - 2015-03-06
    • status: closed-works-for-me --> pending
     
  • Laurent Voisin

    Laurent Voisin - 2015-03-06

    Dear Luis,

    your scenario denotes really a bug.

    Could you please attach a Rodin project archive to this ticket and indicate a proof obligation that exhibits this behavior, so that we can investigate it ?

    Cheers,
    Laurent.

     
  • Laurent Voisin

    Laurent Voisin - 2015-05-19

    This is indeed a bug, but without additional input, we have no way to reproduce it, nor fix it.

     
  • Laurent Voisin

    Laurent Voisin - 2015-05-19
    • status: pending --> closed-invalid
     

Log in to post a comment.