--- old+++ new@@ -1 +1 @@- Couldn't the Identifier template be merged with the Name template ? e.g. one be a part of the other. Or at least "related to" each other?+Couldn't the Identifier template be merged with the Name template ? e.g. one be a part of the other. Or at least "related to" each other?
status: open-remind --> open-accepted
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
CCB call 2013-04-29
Partially Accepted
The separates represent different concepts.
The templates should be updated to relate to each other and clarify the difference between them.
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
A) Identification Template
The Identification template describes how to represent the identification of an object. Each object that can be identified inherits from IdentifiableObject and inherits the attribute identifications which references the Identification object that holds the identification string.
B) Name Template
The Name template describes how to represent a the name of an object.
Proposed
A) Identification Template
The Identification template describes how to represent the identification of an object. An identifier uniquely identifies a given item over an identifier context, for example, a part number is unique for the organization making the part.
Each object that can be identified inherits from IdentifiableObject and inherits the attribute identifications which references the Identification object that holds the identification string.
B) Name Template
The Name template describes how to represent the name of an object. A name is cue to a user to help identify or classify the object, but may not be unique and may change with the language used. For example, "Noddy" is the name of a character in a children's story in England, but who is called "Oui Oui" in France.
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
The Identification template describes how to represent the identification of an object. An identifier, of a particular type, uniquely identifies the object within a given identifier context. For example, a part number is unique for the organization making the part.
NOTE A Name template is also provided. This is used to represent the name of an object, where a name is cue to a user to help identify or classify the object. The name may not be unique and may change with the language used. Hence should not be used as an identifier.
And name to:
The Name template describes how to represent a name of an object. A name is cue to a user to help identify or classify the object, but may not be unique and may change with the language used. For example, "Noddy" is the name of a character in a children's story in England, but who is called "Oui Oui" in France.
NOTE A unique identifier of an object is represented by the Identifier template.
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
I, as expressed earlier, also think that the 'name' and 'identifier' template should be merged.
A 'name' is an identifier. Just as well as a name could be different in different languages, the 'part identifier' could be different in different organisations for the same part. It's only how the context is defined that determine if the identifier/name is unique or not.
The suggested resolution should be to merge the two templates and not only to modify the text.
Regards,
Mats Nilsson
Systems Engineer, Information Architect
FMV - Swedish Defence Materiel Administration
SE-115 88 Stockholm, Sweden
Tel: +46 8 782 47 24 Mobile:+46 70 267 47 24
E-mail: mats.nilsson@fmv.semats.nilsson@fmv.se
Web: www.fmv.sehttp://www.fmv.se
Från: Rob Bodington [mailto:robbod@users.sf.net]
Skickat: den 3 maj 2013 09:57
Till: [plcslib:plcs-templates]
Ämne: [plcslib:plcs-templates] #327 OASIS:Identifier - merge with Name template
Diff:
CCB call 2013-04-29
Partially Accepted
The separates represent different concepts.
The templates should be updated to relate to each other and clarify the difference between them.
Comment from Sean Barker:
Originals
A) Identification Template
The Identification template describes how to represent the identification of an object. Each object that can be identified inherits from IdentifiableObject and inherits the attribute identifications which references the Identification object that holds the identification string.
B) Name Template
The Name template describes how to represent a the name of an object.
Proposed
A) Identification Template
The Identification template describes how to represent the identification of an object. An identifier uniquely identifies a given item over an identifier context, for example, a part number is unique for the organization making the part.
Each object that can be identified inherits from IdentifiableObject and inherits the attribute identifications which references the Identification object that holds the identification string.
B) Name Template
The Name template describes how to represent the name of an object. A name is cue to a user to help identify or classify the object, but may not be unique and may change with the language used. For example, "Noddy" is the name of a character in a children's story in England, but who is called "Oui Oui" in France.
I propose to change the identifier text to
And name to:
/cvsroot/plcslib/plcslib/data/contexts/OASIS/templates/Name/template.xml,v <-- template.xml
new revision: 1.9; previous revision: 1.8
done
Checking in data/contexts/OASIS/templates/Identification/template.xml;
/cvsroot/plcslib/plcslib/data/contexts/OASIS/templates/Identification/template.xml,v <-- template.xml
new revision: 1.13; previous revision: 1.12
done
All,
I, as expressed earlier, also think that the 'name' and 'identifier' template should be merged.
A 'name' is an identifier. Just as well as a name could be different in different languages, the 'part identifier' could be different in different organisations for the same part. It's only how the context is defined that determine if the identifier/name is unique or not.
The suggested resolution should be to merge the two templates and not only to modify the text.
Regards,
Mats Nilsson
Systems Engineer, Information Architect
FMV - Swedish Defence Materiel Administration
SE-115 88 Stockholm, Sweden
Tel: +46 8 782 47 24 Mobile:+46 70 267 47 24
E-mail: mats.nilsson@fmv.semats.nilsson@fmv.se
Web: www.fmv.sehttp://www.fmv.se
Från: Rob Bodington [mailto:robbod@users.sf.net]
Skickat: den 3 maj 2013 09:57
Till: [plcslib:plcs-templates]
Ämne: [plcslib:plcs-templates] #327 OASIS:Identifier - merge with Name template
[plcs-templates:#327]http://sourceforge.net/p/plcslib/plcs-templates/327/ OASIS:Identifier - merge with Name template
Status: pending-accepted
Created: Mon Apr 29, 2013 06:51 AM UTC by Rob Bodington
Last Updated: Fri May 03, 2013 07:55 AM UTC
Owner: nobody
Couldn't the Identifier template be merged with the Name template ? e.g. one be a part of the other. Or at least "related to" each other?
Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in https://sourceforge.net/p/plcslib/plcs-templates/327/
To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/
Related
PLCS templates:
#327