Re: [Ngspice-devel] Failure to link ngnutmeg on Mac OS X

[Steven B. <ste...@di...>]

Holger,

Thanks. I'm just beginning to understand / come to the same conclusions.

I've fixed up imp.c locally as that's simple to see how to avoid  
numparams, but I'm stuck with measure.c as I'm not sure what  
do_measure() is doing, and therefore it's not easy to workout a fix  
that's not going to screw something else up.

I'm here as I was getting warning with linking of ngnutmeg on Mac OS  
X that seemed related to numparam.  I've now moved to Umbuntu in an  
attempt to understand the Mac problems, and hit several others along  
the way.

I've push a couple fixes in the CVS. One broke compile on Umbuntu,  
so  I feel I'm making some sort of progress, but I'm no closer to my  
original problem.

I'll go back to a configuration with --enable-numparams, for now.  
Although if anyone can explain what do_measure() is doing I'll  have  
a go at fixing it.

Regards,
Steven


On 15 Dec 2007, at 16:24, Holger Vogt wrote:

> Steven,
>
> you should add --enable-numparam to ./configure which then set  
> NUMPARAMS
> to 1 in config.h. This will add numpaif.h (see line 52 in inp.c).
> Somehow the code is mixed up in that it will not link without  
> NUMPARAMS
> enabled. Part of the code is embraced in #ifdef NUMPARAMS ...  
> #endif in
> inp.c, e.g. line 456, part of the code not (e.g. inp.c, line 103).
>
> Regards
>
> Holger
>
>
> Steven Borley schrieb:
>> Paolo, and other developers,
>>
>> Still no luck with this, and it might not be just a Mac problem.
>>
>> I tried on Ubuntu with...
>>
>> cvs update
>> ./autogen.sh
>> ./configure --enable-experimental --disable-debug --enable- 
>> maintainer-
>> mode
>> make
>>
>> this gives...
>>
>> gcc -Wall -o ngspice conf.o ngspice.o spice.o spicelib/devices/dev.o
>> frontend/libfte.a frontend/plotting/libplotting.a spicelib/devices/
>> asrc/libasrc.a spicelib/devices/bjt/libbjt.a spicelib/devices/bjt2/
>> libbjt2.a spicelib/devices/bsim1/libbsim1.a spicelib/devices/bsim2/
>> libbsim2.a spicelib/devices/bsim3/libbsim3.a spicelib/devices/ 
>> bsim3v0/
>> libbsim3v0.a spicelib/devices/bsim3v1/libbsim3v1.a spicelib/devices/
>> bsim3v1s/libbsim3v1s.a spicelib/devices/bsim3v1a/libbsim3v1a.a
>> spicelib/devices/bsim3v32/libbsim3v32.a spicelib/devices/bsim4/
>> libbsim4.a spicelib/devices/bsim4v2/libbsim4v2.a spicelib/devices/
>> bsim4v3/libbsim4v3.a spicelib/devices/bsim4v4/libbsim4v4.a spicelib/
>> devices/bsim4v5/libbsim4v5.a spicelib/devices/cap/libcap.a spicelib/
>> devices/bsim3soi/libbsim3soi.a spicelib/devices/bsim3soi_pd/
>> libbsim3soipd.a spicelib/devices/bsim3soi_fd/libbsim3soifd.a  
>> spicelib/
>> devices/bsim3soi_dd/libbsim3soidd.a spicelib/devices/cccs/libcccs.a
>> spicelib/devices/ccvs/libccvs.a spicelib/devices/cpl/libcpl.a
>> spicelib/devices/csw/libcsw.a spicelib/devices/dio/libdio.a spicelib/
>> devices/ind/libind.a spicelib/devices/isrc/libisrc.a spicelib/ 
>> devices/
>> hfet1/libhfet.a spicelib/devices/hfet2/libhfet2.a spicelib/devices/
>> hisim/libhisim.a spicelib/devices/jfet/libjfet.a spicelib/devices/
>> jfet2/libjfet2.a spicelib/devices/ltra/libltra.a spicelib/devices/ 
>> mes/
>> libmes.a spicelib/devices/mesa/libmesa.a spicelib/devices/mos1/
>> libmos1.a spicelib/devices/mos2/libmos2.a spicelib/devices/mos3/
>> libmos3.a spicelib/devices/mos6/libmos6.a spicelib/devices/mos9/
>> libmos9.a spicelib/devices/res/libres.a spicelib/devices/soi3/
>> libsoi3.a spicelib/devices/sw/libsw.a spicelib/devices/txl/libtxl.a
>> spicelib/devices/tra/libtra.a spicelib/devices/urc/liburc.a spicelib/
>> devices/vbic/libvbic.a spicelib/devices/vccs/libvccs.a spicelib/
>> devices/vcvs/libvcvs.a spicelib/devices/vsrc/libvsrc.a spicelib/
>> analysis/libckt.a spicelib/devices/libdev.a frontend/parser/
>> libparser.a frontend/help/libhlp.a spicelib/parser/libinp.a maths/
>> deriv/libderiv.a maths/cmaths/libcmaths.a maths/poly/libpoly.a maths/
>> ni/libni.a maths/sparse/libsparse.a misc/libmisc.a -lm -lXaw -lXmu -
>> lXt -lXext -lX11 -lSM -lICE
>> frontend/libfte.a(inp.o): In function `com_listing':
>> inp.c:(.text+0xf0): undefined reference to `nupa_list_params'
>> frontend/libfte.a(measure.o): In function `do_measure':
>> measure.c:(.text+0x2377): undefined reference to `nupa_add_param'
>> measure.c:(.text+0x24c1): undefined reference to `nupa_add_param'
>> measure.c:(.text+0x28db): undefined reference to `nupa_eval'
>> measure.c:(.text+0x29b8): undefined reference to `nupa_add_param'
>> collect2: ld returned 1 exit status
>>
>> I get the same link error on Mac OS X.
>>
>> Help would be appreciated, but I'll continue to look myself.  Just
>> keep you all informed in case you can spot what I'm missing.
>>
>> Regards,
>> Steven
>>
>
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 
> ---
> SF.Net email is sponsored by:
> Check out the new SourceForge.net Marketplace.
> It's the best place to buy or sell services
> for just about anything Open Source.
> http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;164216239;13503038;w?http://sf.net/ 
> marketplace
> _______________________________________________
> Ngspice-devel mailing list
> Ngs...@li...
> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/ngspice-devel