4.0.1 Open discussion lists broken
Brought to you by:
skazat
Menu
▾
▴
#653 4.0.1 Open discussion lists broken
Open discussion lists (accepting mail from someone who is not on the list) seems to be broken in 4.0.1 (worked OK in 3.x). I've set "Allow_Open_Discussion_List" to 1 in the plugin itself, in my external .dada_config and in Config.pm and checked that it shows as enabled in Plugins/Discussion Lists/View All Plugin Configurations.
There is no failure message in the usage logs or error logs - a message sent to the list just silently disappears. But if I click the Manually Check and Send Waiting Messages button in dada bridge (before the cron job runs and the message disappears) I can see it fails due to being not_from_list_member and not_from_authorized_subscriber. It seems to be 100% reproducible.
This is essential functionality for me because committee members often send to the list from work addresses I don't know about. They've stopped using the list because it "never works".
Thanks for the report - I'll look into it. We are transitioning to the new issue tracker here:
http://github.com/justingit/dada-mail/issues
So if you don't see a reply from me here (or this silently goes away), find the issue over there.
Here's the repost of your report:
http://github.com/justingit/dada-mail/issues/#issue/13
Can you paste exactly what gets printed when you manually run Dada Bridge on a message?
Here's the full error message:
Currently, 0 mass mailout(s) running or queued.
That's below our limit (1).
Checking awaiting messages:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
List: managers
Logging into POP3 server: mail.eplusaudits.com
POP3 Login succeeded.
Message count: 1
Message Size: 3354
Message is from: 'phil@mckerracher.net'
* From address is NOT from list owner address
Moderation disabled...
Discussion List Support enabled...
* Message is NOT from a subscriber.
Authorized Senders List enabled...
* Message is NOT from an Authorized Sender!
SpamAssassin check disabled...
Message did not pass verification - handling issues...
Error delivering message! Reasons:
msg_not_from_subscriber
msg_not_from_list_owner
Saving message at: '/hsphere/local/home/philmck/.data/dada_eplus/.tmp/dada_bridge_received_msgs-managers.mbox'
Saved.
The limit has been reached of the amount of messages to be looked at for this execution
Removing message from server...
Disconnecting from POP3 server
Waiting 5 seconds before removal check...
Logging into POP3 server: mail.eplusaudits.com
POP3 Login succeeded.
Message count: 0
Here's the plugin config:
Allow_Manual_Run
1
Allow_Open_Discussion_List
1
Check_List_Owner_Return_Path_Header
1
Check_Multiple_Return_Path_Headers
0
Enable_POP3_File_Locking
1
Manual_Run_Passcode
Max_Size_Of_Any_Message
2621440
MessagesAtOnce
1
Plugin_Name
Dada Bridge
Plugin_URL
http://www.eplusaudits.com/mail/plugins/dada_bridge.pl
Room_For_One_More_Check
1
Soft_Max_Size_Of_Any_Message
1048576
Thanks for the info, I'll go through it ;)
I've yet to even be able to exactly recreate your problem, but turning off Authorized Senders seems to make a big difference in making this work - *kind* of makes sense, since Authorized Senders aren't really used if its an open discussion list.
Here's what I get, if authorized senders is not on:
Currently, 0 mass mailout(s) running or queued.
That's below our limit (2).
Checking awaiting messages:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
List: test
Logging into POP3 server: test.com
POP3 Login succeeded.
Message count: 1
Message Size: 1001
Message is from: 'test@example.com'
* From address is NOT from list owner address
Moderation disabled...
Discussion List Support enabled...
* Message is NOT from a subscriber.
Postings from non-subscribers is enabled...
Authorized Senders List disabled...
SpamAssassin check disabled...
Processing Message...
Message being delivered!
Message Details:
--------------------------------------------------
Subject: [] Blah!
Finished Processing Message.
Saving message at: '/home/blah/.dada_files-dada_mail/.tmp/dada_bridge_received_msgs-test.mbox'
Saved.
The limit has been reached of the amount of messages to be looked at for this execution
Removing message from server...
Disconnecting from POP3 server
Waiting 5 seconds before removal check...
Logging into POP3 server: dadamailproject.com
POP3 Login succeeded.
Message count: 0
Hmm, kind of makes sense but didn't help:
Checking awaiting messages:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
List: managers
Logging into POP3 server: mail.eplusaudits.com
POP3 Login succeeded.
Message count: 1
Message Size: 3492
Message is from: 'phil@mckerracher.net'
* From address is NOT from list owner address
Moderation disabled...
Discussion List Support enabled...
* Message is NOT from a subscriber.
Authorized Senders List disabled...
SpamAssassin check disabled...
Message did not pass verification - handling issues...
Error delivering message! Reasons:
msg_not_from_subscriber
msg_not_from_list_owner
Saving message at: '/hsphere/local/home/philmck/.data/dada_eplus/.tmp/dada_bridge_received_msgs-managers.mbox'
Saved....
I've tried a clean install and that didn't help either. There must be some "magic" combination of settings I haven't hit on yet.
This seems to have been fixed in 4.0.2. Many thanks!
I've purchased Pro Dada (again, but hopefully for the last time!).