I believe that `id` has always been special for WFS data sets (along with
`name`) as the GML spec specifies them so they are automagically removed
from any features that are returned
Ian
On Sun, 11 Feb 2024 at 07:59, Peter Smythe <gs...@sm...> wrote:
> My observations and recommendation:
>
> `id` appears to be interpreted as an internal keyword for FeatureID and
> not a property/attribute/column name. Many datasets will use `id` as a
> column name and might get tripped up by this.
>
> Example, using the topp:states layer in the default data:
>
>
> http://localhost:8080/geoserver/ows?service=WFS&version=1.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=topp:states&outputFormat=json
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/0-DE7TyxLeudnucGi_GhZ8EVe5mqd1I_0MkqidJH9RwOukdAho13sAsNRae6xJc8KSvMsLinyvsBcpx2J9S5WBGzdRV3B5vPxPtlSRkoZRhI6aM5zQMAsD1qimINCQdU6IlGG56siKEHcs2LNA27c4UIPVtrP6PaOei1TKu_YVbWnv63PlDKj76IUsfXghaAVebLJmGnK8Nz8aZf9nZa5ZfARkJAM6jPKeFQ6Lj6sOF8144Ng97EO-sdCROYlqQh637zlFoOt-s5kc_9CiycdRHU-_7Mq0mkXuaHpQFofdHUSGiZAHa4AmlpdnNWs4mbU6crzuaB39r7B0TMHBuUbM6-noqBii5t22sSueUJvXDwO3Q3FQMfe6UC6fId4nU7pqWAuwf9bcheWXKaH7LjaCzm5a55YBWZ2JA5ZwNGLWYgYJETb2gYRjKex9pVjK5ZuR_TnCfrRekAdHq09izern1Ndv3_tMp6DA>
>
> [image: image.png]
>
> Here, `id` is the FeatureID = `states.49` and thus
> http://localhost:8080/geoserver/ows?service=WFS&version=1.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=topp:states&outputFormat=json&cql_filter=id+IN+('states.49
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/NO0b6xrHfaTvabJ6mKU1NGgKqjCybVN1vpKP6trKlPO1KNQ-TrYC1vb5otvQUrDMwyrH-n2GlSOHwnINwjEuqNZckrqdoWjQCKVhyt8sQT2UrPuazZ2Jy5ICAU6BSyYtdc1RtLkGH3754xifLhka6cSvce-l6d-Z_suMeh16whLUcDSok8IQD4aFQ8rkXUK6ymceBqc-8DXU-mEmYb_H-1eaQKbRl-In-SkyqatCyLKEZU0NfwQ5LPz31OuZP_18XYa3pqKjMLOuwSfvtv6js14ijJsSPEbXjKqPi4ejgE3vZgks_AvVUZMl5qar4eB_qch_WUmvWdkMJRl17DWZKqcBuRu8CoPcLMUmL3lgoqSqu0e4HEOKs6PtTRR0G-gkqJZLmCiD1A6ADizGWR7V5kMWcA4fcKVzSQPmRgWLzeaWVxEcHC6Xql1Y5jPRQ1rVnw5SNxCXTKWWi5nPxCK6iDDqXnd8G5aAoWjUi6qPLsNEhaMrRA8qKg3eVvAYPORTUmExTdDaGwhYmuAd8Bl3in0wcFdAV_e1fuc_fVSX>')
> will return this one result.
>
> However, if we customise the attributes and change attribute `STATE_NAME`
> to `id`, simulating a non-index database column called `id`:
>
> [image: image.png]
>
> then
> http://localhost:8080/geoserver/ows?service=WFS&version=1.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=topp:states&outputFormat=json&cql_filter=id+IN+('Washington
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/s66c-QwpjdEvMZZLKDCqh3Vt6zVkG1jYJKJnUHqukOKrxSB2DUsjuVE6MDWD5W2RvEAcUrNP5k5bUTIeyFQFpd5aSS8w0g76SE9y8lToZZh_NRs-ykKTZg-CQrzjXb9QsNvKX_6gNa4-pkH6sYVyypeW1JSfBgqT7lXTPzNvnD9WYNk9hn235a4Wy3uJUPvB2vQJi8oqAkLWTawuMG-C10HmQc30kHgGbYUZ9l2UvFuY6dxBoM_I6KrLN49EIJvaQP4llXwrsIFsandAYYkNC7WztYpn1Q1MQZVvCJRE7bsxZRW5JSWjUhJ7DTg2nqtm8-4DWdYTwPOTzFo6f41BN6dDO2NZQmZGhtVZMZuju-lT1kZwXMa2oJnmgl_0jMMVw3d-KveIRCzOdFpVabkNZehtJfMk5alSHe-1GIC6F0ZxDKQw7Znl6sSjyGk43xcighQ-K6q3dkjjSUD0TpiCip_VTV1e9nq4yU-PrXPuzFxpaxEYMAfGfup4rtNwgPPbuH9blUbbk8jjnzW-Qk2ce9HNHm1zQeWfOvUr0u_e3w>')
> will not match the record, as `id` is being used as the FeatureID. In
> order to use the *column* `id`, we need to put it in double quotes:
>
>
> http://localhost:8080/geoserver/ows?service=WFS&version=1.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=topp:states&outputFormat=json&cql_filter=
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/zrrtG6I3Y4bwSGD6YZKAoUs6k82cMdV2TOuGq6-OA-uLAKTR0zqkukdQVJHsE-IZd2Uoor6oAB-vWPMNU6d2bkUbLBmkBhwcfedB6XpUe7RCkB77qr7gQbkDtMuLR_JYhKQHIAD_S1QMgAQr15OCi6xm6MExLDIIofq0_y4tCDIIHQmsztds5wFuaojxvLBRBl6bp8EeFmNvXMtseX8lGwcMVsNEJxT4WfbcvrJeduedPPPTEyl9Y90T5aSCOkv7yGma7bk3c451Uxl7c7HDzzSk2lQxgnZ46AkXDZc8UOfqMEhEYcTjMZa5UBWUIB4B2mFqoMzHvz9JbcnAIeoresWT7dT5zieXgDQp-9a31koHq5Jp2wv6k0BbT7AXWH4vjYOkNYiTVTmDwZyngBnnd7wQWmgzaYREiIB0PFo1Gen9HL9XNHTQbXgLftfehHWlmcF9Br_ODMNGibUsadYMWCez3U7KY_drzTwr5clohV-ebEI3nMPkexFKD_tZ7Ic>"id"+IN+('Washington'),
> and this then works, as per the
> https://gis.stackexchange.com/questions/373005/geoserver-wms-cql-filter-id-xxx-works-but-id-in-xxx-does-not
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/NsaepbDBaqwRbaYvtHCE-_fT8TCs4q3QDXbfMFdlsfofY8rWqs2K3vBzXgU6HPDGDgPLVakclcYSeTtFh7X4lMimnlCwLvXQoDh5ISw3jyJsuI_ki_dflxhgyjLxhRXKPXNnQZ8hXYVeNtH4znctai16Ad3p0JgId2MWr1mabpVysl_sg_cWV1JKzcU_iKvZuCK5ORs23frIi-Ht0PD-tG2pM5w6S3ULqvNCR84mD4ODCa1rVOrLTZCV-Q6TSLhS4_NKdGJcDodKFT0MmKg55HjFn8YnMse0qLnkPx1ABk7RovvUn0Qrij4AJGY5rebxZ84kXvXoSdu_aI4DEqettddxh6vNsp_FJ6L04xuj6Ov1q_BrzoE4O0h4xyXuFGvCZd2_b5W189MnV1YirTg>
> recommendation.
>
> Simply using the IN(filter) format:
> http://localhost:8080/geoserver/ows?service=WFS&version=1.0.0&request=GetFeature&typeNames=topp:states&outputFormat=json&cql_filter=IN+('Washington')
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/9Ct27NMLVDoOMP2aXz1OptYfdM-MkbtOzhZxXpg4Xw2ANQz8o2Al8vBI1iMCATWiqCSMXKJU1J02LbTw3YBqsAstkf7LZsYcMPGSsxRn0JXFaslvgcu6sJCwiEAwhHgB2yn9ktiAy3EnNmYxFL26-UOKv54kplQBzp53ZLfZXpwAktFUgIO7Tz_Nk5RWXTe__zNR2YF9cBVhGUg0Tv8Mdai7z4HGyEV-OfWlVluo-R7sfdskk6nOJXkTNyHn51T_W9z25J2-J7NAwWvcDw8kWffIolnStZ7UcFTiomFXIKm9RJ7YfZNsj1a6iCStUpHyxJWtbRh9ZHwlNqgU8kTzw68b_f5gARmch4eBE6Qh87zsx79Ts6ITOkzJP37W54B5ZIU15Ih7Wb_TPWxqU_fOWZPGex6MTyb57ZZpDXnzC8wfunzpnwqQ3asb2utoiYfmJXEPKINwN9h6AYCxLnXdd1gJzGa3jDN9IpcTplp2xXWlYcazoowYkPzxIVLjE8KD7BNuYlqnOrd_Oks_FO1M59Zv5zIjPd0XJJ4ZXVXrDDvtoMXrokU>,
> implies the FeatureID `id` and does not return any data.
>
>
> The XML equivalent:
> http://localhost:8080/geoserver/wfs?request=GetFeature&version=1.0.0&typeName=topp:states&outputFormat=json&FILTER=%3CFilter%20xmlns%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.opengis.net%2Fogc%22%3E%3CPropertyIsEqualTo%3E%3CPropertyName%3Eid%3C%2FPropertyName%3E%3CLiteral%3EWashington%3C%2FLiteral%3E%3C%2FPropertyIsEqualTo%3E%3C%2FFilter%3E
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/5KFQMiTHKU777adJyF5FdiJc4aYTc6TS97oRvf9iAxzIUBMCNf85_qgUL4u2O7sEULwzhcq5MG7uH8AYrzGVNOMldwbYgaiERNu8htFsVtrJcPRxi08rH5KAGKp9EfhBYYvqXKJLZIHJ_P96snQfYazfsK9DRQcHwP0sc_G-kQrgV8m7pKrwLAMhGpAofcoq6LWHtrHpuCdkmsG5hVSgUfFYxaI01Rj7SYDCXtXGYomCOuaHt6X_q9q--cLhvd4LdYrWv_jFvZbFPaBqr_XRgsqLExqmEZI7jvBh8Y_mvn0ZJ6siSLVdwUtHYf2ywbxYXR6Tc8J2eK7q7k1hARhvcflBOGVKS4yaLmb5MfgMDVx1Oc20knmX_ao3enFmElWRPxMs7z6Y_4aOJrA11deV5hnYAccz6HWSrR3f7XIWlbJEdZoe9uUFzjm7cxsvdDLvt4IZYB75QnjKOVCAQcQAueeml5PF8BnHBy3kiDajjG3FF4lGwMp2Yeg30ifZDwc3pQlOlLB18NvooEPkQ_OhmDG1jYYb3R_qAhVvKT2sbXYrakKlLbEchW5Ixckr_X-K2gMbSBGEvqtBBE6aW587zKmKQJw_ibzEhsaok81R_10esUDQDomPtsUbyUJLd1I85LAWpb-jnmTIHj_y-gfidWxIFNXjyIrRn3Sp9J9wiosXp0toURFqV4qSU6YVqr_6q-DDO9CCxcF08LJHW73ZeogTcH2sbosEcMKF_PpVOpZDX962lxdT4LJncs4wrTHt_g54hOy2dGzq5WcFlOOCCdESUVJZFoCpujhDGraQcuzpMfLjZxrrQWY2mA>
> (which encodes this filter, for those of us who can't easily URL-decode in
> our heads:
> <Filter xmlns="http://www.opengis.net/ogc
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/cQkT9J4mHW8Kdn-XX_vGdivqGdA-mwYa9VAD49d-KMJkXyTivu3qhbGzEu0Z6H_7W14DNoLYog_0lD4mo1F95OFYe6xtWzjRLTu8pjg4En7EURhn3L9uJdqAzu8-Iao-zijeAZldZt3SThC3u9SI591uu0ZOUp8-dwKof3c_9URDM9FxopbTJPn0TcqlnkdlX2IpLs-TK-lPU_08XFc_9RPK2-71RTPB3_cpBIUT--rO99NwHpOrmDaeHlpqZa2yG1M4KV4KCJETbNR8RbRn25nOMtxZU_4KwA>
> ">
> <PropertyIsEqualTo>
> <PropertyName>id</PropertyName>
> <Literal>Washington</Literal>
> </PropertyIsEqualTo>
> </Filter>
> )
> does correctly use the attribute `id`, as expected, and not the FeatureID
> `id`.
>
> According to the both
> https://docs.geoserver.org/latest/en/user/filter/ecql_reference.html
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/2XhlCOGQuXN3CYCv6i2V1pDzupPSRXdEMwnBR5QIDEWFd-EPpKWGgRt2SSK--F7AW-p5yj4PGL3Og7tfbQvzq-CpJub9y_G7W8c5zHsLoee2OpnPawr6bm77Ta2csgqLop_63nEP2l4to809akQJNfXgh_eB1Gu2jekNejU_98-Cr1nNJ0t3eIlYhe6snaytxnGyq03eONqJX2-2l7cp19v6vgjMThUopOUKQ2wYtjjnWodonv4P-nix5MIGKkZ3hrO8Dn2YZPCyV72VOsGWk--9737Q4nS_qFJj4rogfS8eWvmk00MTCRLr7uPr2dJESEGnVlphGnKsp0_v7QsAQMo_lG3Oza_BiqOn>
> and
> https://docs.geoserver.org/latest/en/user/tutorials/cql/cql_tutorial.html
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/rCSP7iTy_hgLkyQPhDcijOqAboai1I5K9xzWwplBLSCgnb9queJPcqKybSULbk9WW5ZWJNswjklhLkK9xf6PERAcc80UXKvm3CqXmUhbGc5fNkc-jnBCkLyDqSChKZtz3OQASff4TlLnpT6UjdFkJN-Co9SF1euxWddAw5AzgflYCu_R8czqRRIyP4hqhuQleziM3q90RdSqTL3yeEL--UiPIh4vrEG9oSH8v7w1pWLp0SZwrOH8J9s3xMvEzl8vfY4qMo5UICFj9GnlPXRfgK0JeNU3Z3ubehNCWCRDX4cwjFLAVaDa3fgHbiCGhoKglyPElVdscpRqQgH0ysZwUjpaQcZ8DWESGjRuAVZaW0if-w>,
>
>
> [image: image.png]
> and
> [image: image.png]
> it appears as though we should be able to filter on attribute `id` =
> Washington rather than FeatureID `id` = states.49
>
> If this is a bug (developers?), I wonder how many systems will break when
> it is fixed, or whether the best way forward is to simply document that an
> attribute `id` is special and needs to be quoted thus: "id". Let me know
> to fix the documentation.
>
> Peter
>
> GeoServer PSC
> AWS Solutions Architect
> https://github.com/petersmythe
> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/aRem_WHLXTzUhXUNwYbKbm1h1d3RPwswXQxXiylBYViDkUvI19TKvQWaz4dN2AX_ItCw2ESujzYOFbDmyZU8qrZcR0Qyh5ljCqu26xr-IG1Y-8oF-_2ljQLoQRNxCXGt-bRDcRC71tTvAtpdBlGeNqWns9_s0gsvXkqVoVKbvxYXO3BsrVYXOhrkjfqlmcZbQDD6mZMeb6F0QUHCLAeblv4yOva3akBeSZd_n8raXfayICuyzZxSy7sgqH0dGifYkkhUbUmsxrtz9TFTO-Lw-JbJaCkuKN6amNO2I-8>
>
> On Sat, 10 Feb 2024 at 21:35, Jody Garnett <jod...@gm...> wrote:
>
>> Huh, I wonder if that is even supported …
>>
>> The FeatureID check is done different by WFS, and does not always
>> integrate well with functions and so on. There is a configuration option to
>> both use primary keys to generate FeatureID and also make available as an
>> attribute for use with functions.
>>
>> Are you comfortable trying the same request with an XML query? …to see if
>> it is a problem with the data store, or if it is a problem with CQL
>> constructing a query …
>>
>> Reading
>> https://docs.geoserver.org/main/en/user/filter/ecql_reference.html
>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/Gg7Et39_60SaAmSH6kelaUtkt1g48FWCVkMFF4fHjKFQ_K3TDSeuJllqMGFtSLd8Z92d-_a2uDiaGwTG4IKsA3pfTmwF1FaeipvwwZ3UbZnh1I0FCrdkG44gDzG7YN3nrepJIEICNBWKb9_Q8YvQknZ7RQjSh964TZ-EJpuzIL9GBJtFP1nn7qLI7hkLOsZYRBjZO649RkJoBns3aFYAFRhmkT3Mq7E5mCVGz2d_SE0r3F44QZeuAnCo6EVv-ACYKGK1xWDnzk_a3jXQudlgnHjmNXoJ2cmU5hSK47L10Eq8ffC4vv84Sw2N8EVRk3EHT77xv1B-NbU7oZqEO7Y6Qi5YIr8Q7pyW_w> you
>> may wish to try:
>>
>> in('R403139')
>>
>> Assuming R403139 is a feature identifier.
>>
>> --
>> Jody Garnett
>>
>>
>> On Sat, Feb 10, 2024 at 6:16 AM <wam...@po...> wrote:
>>
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> i'm trying to use a cql_filter on a feature but something is strange.
>>>
>>> cql_filter: "id = 'R403139'" is working fine. i'll get only this
>>> feature.
>>>
>>> but "id in('R403139')" does not give any result (without error
>>> messages).
>>>
>>> i need a list, because later on there more features will be dynanical
>>> selected. e.g. "id in('R403139', 'R1719140')"
>>>
>>> What am i doing wrong?
>>>
>>> btw: i may add geoserver log file if needed.
>>> --
>>> My projects:
>>>
>>> OSM Boundaries Map (*) - not completed
>>> OSM Software Watchlist
>>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/dTEd2x7zFnSvq2aaJS-GjVXvaEeC8QQEaUaXpFbGB3hjrn-tfOWYeHYxlBhcvu1nASz9jT6NRLvmCsMv9f_KQXLjeEYeAMP9yvHB4iwBn2LEkeRIjzi024ILT9TZGJ63HckpqCfZQMVTQHcFS1bzXQwiWM8_1OKwpXDAjSbA4MS2NB9z1sb5AtZq-ZFAbOM_hveq74YSQo3hsd2i4d3qI_iQEMUBirYhu0bAN5O07jzOAyZSCOlwnbTCRr9ZDGdG2YRzMzuaoFwS4HfRgLNesstr3NrpVJn4IkzJXzHdLL5M5yuC3T7lE1F9WQP8ndeMUp-uzg>
>>> OSM Emergency Map
>>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/huUb8a-1gpyJumX3kQR1r18RxLGDMix1rEKLCSNBTp9WRHavstSnCjI8-YwYi4UmHlQ9pCYLQ8VBt83JIQ2k9G2eo2HWkGibwiElrvKMmoXClcx7dYwnndSmulikLYiveMWoOR9D3nxTP_DvIUGa-Mlb3LxQXSL0EqHRm3H6lssPGhaGuWwH2AWSlqeRQWj3DgFBkiOIFsOaXseN_rm0686m7GNdeARtc17ylJ777iSKQfVSz8VtwatjW2tuoVPe-TpaAh_WDtohFFxwb5Q8bsYuM0yZ_t6sx6upKyG4F47hGPKuh6wBQMad4pU>
>>> (*)
>>> OSM Healthcare Map
>>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/JZh63A1FTXj8bfUECBYPBqd7Aimj1N-Py5hsYwB0qYmPr-aDXi-DT43So-YK9RWDWFImAMCJwjZVBSGKJytwowBfgaaoHE0Xyi3vHj7m2pR2GhxARljJyXgLPgh1RZBWC63k6UQSjMk_pygvUG5kz2HpyLjuOEw9QDc35is_LYOxFKBCGFwyq1oarojHJsrENGOcJqBdEb_vYQ_MKZqDu6K2b4WGnBOs2V01yAvtQ726BPrqjm-Lmb5VHEyHaZMcLxOnOJX4Iy2ACau8TZhPuyu2RlyNfHmcCMSsoPc5ZnmB6JEO7D7FfWDQr6VP>
>>> (*)
>>> OSM Postcode Map
>>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/IPRdVYa5D7tAoTVF33R5Lo6youkJvzyzuwSoPWV2Bv9oYweNl1HKwk_cgUtSp0PK2vei-LCLC2tdFnSDShWzkOyBCptIUGjHZgUByIcAuW6jIefc1ZVTZLxKMC_fwo6qYvcSDBJ193bQjN_VffhLblIzFMAYiPRntTPm7Pqm69Q4udM7cU6ddcB0kDeTINQJfL3SllyNf9oVdilr0zBvDWGSlsCzcVNwv9ZDYkHfAt0D8R2eaYnrru83CBwhzU02S9BDM2njNMeBXU_8ebZQBdxrJR2zqRRHi6_z89PjIhv2_0gnlCZXLSqpr4Q> (Germany)
>>>
>>>
>>> *) Europe
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Geoserver-users mailing list
>>>
>>> Please make sure you read the following two resources before posting to
>>> this list:
>>> - Earning your support instead of buying it, but Ian Turton:
>>> http://www.ianturton.com/talks/foss4g.html#/
>>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/A8CkADfEmuLFcXdHS_lc_CoXkEPL-NshhPOhhw2QJKVuktfuwD0ovHbJVzw3dB9Ojb09P_GlapyOrQ_wq3mM0dsBTNrrhMtb64tL3evANhD3rS-ulz3_LCQqya6HJ_UBpNC9yvt8lnz_lv5Gb1FmTo-3DjBURb4wa1Ft5B3pfUP0F0tF6H315TCin-c9uwC1YTVO-EPMqYVA9fo_SQXtLEnJ2ayLB4JUYEcUNZZ0ZRnPn26sX2E5hJ0v66-YbZqoa2X-u94ZwecRwLaR9riJ1FxX23FIvKCEtaLevg-XGlVH-xH6CK3Ca-eykSkkEQoNaQ>
>>> - The GeoServer user list posting guidelines:
>>> http://geoserver.org/comm/userlist-guidelines.html
>>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/XkR8EGcUzu-sc8QKJRp_i45mmxJrPkoodKEsySOViiT98p6BKCO0dqE5c3SMUTHx6KLd0hCope2w7hmtfgQah_LHKc1IZft7cE2_mP0cVy4EfuLEwWzq2XfyGBX8eiLvlgIE1VIl53Nf7M7HIGrA-hp2dqd44zk5MI70Zw1DZcxKDBMufxotf9gBZgt63yzbx5BBoP1hbVjBnYp38sbYMloqM7AQ9ScXxxRCHYyxwKGMvRCFbeb_WErzFDsDOzFUN6oPE8iuKdvPpb0sZkgbtEFkvbCbH2YDh0-nagjKpKEYQUX7oWdw27pzBYdayH5CQRkn>
>>>
>>> If you want to request a feature or an improvement, also see this:
>>> https://github.com/geoserver/geoserver/wiki/Successfully-requesting-and-integrating-new-features-and-improvements-in-GeoServer
>>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/wJWCRfg9hVCWVXTpR9YcSPjMcq3et_9opiaHHdQc91VqDaXoFESvSsbiyHhDNiw6s-td7VgsQQFplRC8CGKsgDZ-CULvcTi3_CEO5K6dwF4zhfwcJuss8M_V7G2K6_Wnh4cv_Km9pENiRnRZfGLeAmCwfKwAu2QPlj3mgXt7N_HvYvo4ce5vCt4-a6q5ejHkQQp-k9E0mVdBOTd05kl0lNn1itvwTPdxQVM41_QBTk7epU9bqmL1A5emMJEgCbIkbSKTnYHFSfcQeqI6hMktRtuXjCYSDSKFQRR4oWkV1BUTIHlwdvE1wFfj1h8qBRqtJxRZfjnL6p7RSO0VE1y-6JutVZXGD9YmxsCxBA4mL1sFsfZRq6BO98ilsShrdocYcXf90J6rKFyC4FgFh8jhzqmgCk3hAM4cFoI32U4J6ismduY>
>>>
>>>
>>> Geo...@li...
>>> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/geoserver-users
>>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/9jTGd709fuBDPY2xilI2RGE7HahVA2m5-ubdHo7KQfG_kMdckS8BCuq-mDLWeGQT3u82N-KHlb5Iw7fD5BL0Y6j-gZH-99sTPmd9i0gOg35qIkGOttDGa9b_fJfaVjYbUQB2O2dDL8q_f_B5Vh474WuDtb-RxIEucvTTrsZxiCdK3AGtVehSmijUjdt-dmmjqpAwk7R-4zfCNLq1IidcWK1r9HRAnjDelhUgSm1rCbvYMIuzv6ottFoAtbZgotzDkKM6buFM_3wRpNLqRPH1fvwC0vu7GESoZOMvkhWg1hpNJPWMHuWpqW2pIWdSQbdNEycTVSGSsM7lo3PPW8At>
>>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Geoserver-users mailing list
>>
>> Please make sure you read the following two resources before posting to
>> this list:
>> - Earning your support instead of buying it, but Ian Turton:
>> http://www.ianturton.com/talks/foss4g.html#/
>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/3UmbCk-viFUGBkweup_c1XKGMARPbLDy60gntBuwN5k_GjIu3IGPTSVKd8tdXco0_56B88c3gT9p-Oe9zM6pBwx0VUptBYlk5uAyXTqYz8cdLqy4h7rw_1TclOPv5bbGN2aIIqOjMDButDSkL7iKaKhGBAGANCCfipJCNHTlZvTOKfCZKA738bH2A5OMJyrvTGO3RNUigrju2EuaL300whUdmKMgbEcs97CaTS3MVBpDFgVZy2x4v_j-hrypWztB55UvDhBrADl-mRgq-Prtm7B0u4tlqZtkbivdVnFsO39_uX_VVZb31ymhgyMHdJgjTw>
>> - The GeoServer user list posting guidelines:
>> http://geoserver.org/comm/userlist-guidelines.html
>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/JJe3OHb50gwN2tHH0Gex7IAz9j7Lq_evjvvPrzaqCYCK4Rd6ls2F3xMtZmj8ILA5Cp0m133rlbUnnlmJaJokzW6VF2jMOss5chjNHE7GeGKGDyT8d0VCCO8j1P1N6E4x16_QGyU8lez2r0Dm6HPWqVYRzQfypG3ylCT7_iv9o5z86QsjWNS3ST5tbofn0oqxkk541FPvC0kU7A7Pxq51KZHAKo6I_j3GR4SRMUGk0aZH09sYVi8Jyn0GQF3hQ5lq3sF7pNqmY-cTfEgbPt7OoHLaA4XLV6MO0lythdnK9T3mMQzaNNnVa0_2CnhvaGnTQdIm>
>>
>> If you want to request a feature or an improvement, also see this:
>> https://github.com/geoserver/geoserver/wiki/Successfully-requesting-and-integrating-new-features-and-improvements-in-GeoServer
>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/odGTLbJ8Gjr62v-MxgL2Jg_3RXaAUdHE7sO0eLAZGeyhfrgxlFBRzWzTnMnn-VgzBnc8hiMZ3KS3B6mNCcJCj-ZuB8oS7EWPuzA21afDS5mwIHSEVGRLnjZAMTlwBVqkgKLboYO9oK9imCPsJvkcDUa0XKc_T4SAxHcwyz4vjrJ1TtqcarL2qW0VSmuBLJmXKfUzlUl8Yy7KSvxC45v8tE7vxF5ruagn7A283hdlM6eu1lnvp2dOM3UWYfNhUBUIRXbAie5a9W107v1g6j3cEvCpU_XcGtWfBx1MgVEnzGForoqygX450MQkgQcL4UF7h7WlKq39wZbvas9Lv5EmX3-mFQaPmXPTGM7UX60tCIC1Z762RGQldmW89ChA9vOXZMwiwXyCz4yYIcJuwUJtKgDMKvze-uqmRGu-qfXOZrWNfzY>
>>
>>
>> Geo...@li...
>> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/geoserver-users
>> <https://fdfdfha.r.bh.d.sendibt3.com/tr/cl/K-Kytzot7habuUMGNaMhnDbx3QFT3w8Y03bhAnf3wDeksDv_qhrBnNRtLxnefzGeWOHToxYe4ZlWkeswMctL53h3KwS7SrZ0tTXUOe5W9xm84bEctA5W0-TM9BveKLvTn3V4IqblGMPEb3qcyOU0A0s3oBdF5gb4NopztJ-XlFRit0UpH4M4h8HHqwcGuY0eJK1rwByFM_q8z9gWfsbXspNNE-0k-F3Vthd9VxIRf18xGy9-Oapf3olfo6MmVy-JpK_pFZ1mBgCOzJOmz7CKP8U_rNjHzX4z_XBTUhL5JPh5hHCGbsX_q3NEps9N41O3tSQIPJ_FTrecLBTRmqVs>
>>
> _______________________________________________
> Geoserver-devel mailing list
> Geo...@li...
> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/geoserver-devel
>
--
Ian Turton
|
