[Vxl-maintainers] Compile problem

[Brendan M. <bre...@gm...>]

G'day Maintainers,

I'm having a bit of trouble getting a successful compilation with the
latest trunk (no errors on the dashboard). Compilation is fine on my
mac, but not on a 64 bit linux machine. My guess is that it is
something to do with static template members, but after a bit of
hacking, I was unable to resolve the problem. So I'm hoping someone
else has come across it. It seems almost certain that it has something
to do with the setup on the machine. Here is the issue:

uname -a
Linux 2.6.31.9-174.fc12.x86_64 #1 SMP Mon Dec 21 05:33:33 UTC 2009
x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux
gcc --version
gcc (GCC) 4.4.2 20091027 (Red Hat 4.4.2-7)

Error:
/usr/bin/c++   -fPIC   -fPIC
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_driver.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_distance.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_closest_point.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_conic.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_homg.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_polygon.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_convex.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_polygon_scan_iterator.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_triangle_scan_iterator.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_ellipse_scan_iterator.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_window_scan_iterator.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_area.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_clip.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_h_matrix_1d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_h_matrix_2d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_h_matrix_3d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_fit_lines_2d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_fit_conics_2d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_p_matrix.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_convex_hull_2d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_sphere.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_line_3d_2_points.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_line_segment_3d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_orient_box_3d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_fit_plane_3d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_intersection.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_rotation_3d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_triangle_3d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_triangle_3d_line_intersection.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_rtree.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_ellipsoid.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_infinite_line_3d.o
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_ray_3d.o  -o vgl_test_all -rdynamic
../../../lib/libvgl_algo.a ../../../lib/libvgl.a
../../../lib/libtestlib.a ../../../lib/libvnl_algo.a
../../../lib/libnetlib.a ../../../lib/libv3p_netlib.a
../../../lib/libvnl.a ../../../lib/libvcl.a -lm
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o: In function
`vgl_point_3d<int>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<int> const&) const':
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIiEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<int>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<int>
const&) const]+0x34): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIiEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<int>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<int>
const&) const]+0x59): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIiEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<int>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<int>
const&) const]+0x7f): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIiEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<int>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<int>
const&) const]+0xa1): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIiEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<int>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<int>
const&) const]+0xc3): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o:test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIiEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<int>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<int>
const&) const]+0xe5): more undefined references to
`vgl_tolerance<int>::position' follow
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o: In function
`vgl_point_3d<double>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<double> const&) const':
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIdEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<double>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<double>
const&) const]+0x3a): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIdEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<double>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<double>
const&) const]+0x76): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIdEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<double>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<double>
const&) const]+0xaf): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIdEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<double>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<double>
const&) const]+0xec): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIdEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<double>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<double>
const&) const]+0x121): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o:test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIdEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<double>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<double>
const&) const]+0x15a): more undefined references to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position' follow
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o: In function
`vgl_point_3d<float>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<float> const&) const':
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIfEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<float>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<float>
const&) const]+0x3a): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIfEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<float>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<float>
const&) const]+0x75): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIfEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<float>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<float>
const&) const]+0xad): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIfEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<float>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<float>
const&) const]+0xe9): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIfEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<float>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<float>
const&) const]+0x11d): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o:test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._ZNK12vgl_point_3dIfEeqERKS0_[vgl_point_3d<float>::operator==(vgl_point_3d<float>
const&) const]+0x155): more undefined references to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position' follow
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o: In function `bool
vgl_lineseg_test_point<double>(vgl_point_2d<double> const&,
vgl_line_segment_2d<double> const&)':
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._Z22vgl_lineseg_test_pointIdEbRK12vgl_point_2dIT_ERK19vgl_line_segment_2dIS1_E[bool
vgl_lineseg_test_point<double>(vgl_point_2d<double> const&,
vgl_line_segment_2d<double> const&)]+0x1fa): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_cartesian.o: In function `bool
coplanar<double>(vgl_point_3d<double> const&, vgl_point_3d<double>
const&, vgl_point_3d<double> const&, vgl_point_3d<double> const&)':
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._Z8coplanarIdEbRK12vgl_point_3dIT_ES4_S4_S4_[bool
coplanar<double>(vgl_point_3d<double> const&, vgl_point_3d<double>
const&, vgl_point_3d<double> const&, vgl_point_3d<double>
const&)]+0x6f3): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::point_3d_coplanarity'
test_cartesian.cxx:(.text._Z8coplanarIdEbRK12vgl_point_3dIT_ES4_S4_S4_[bool
coplanar<double>(vgl_point_3d<double> const&, vgl_point_3d<double>
const&, vgl_point_3d<double> const&, vgl_point_3d<double>
const&)]+0x70a): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::point_3d_coplanarity'
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_rotation_3d.o: In function
`vgl_rotation_3d<double>::vgl_rotation_3d(vnl_vector_fixed<double, 3u>
const&, vnl_vector_fixed<double, 3u> const&)':
test_rotation_3d.cxx:(.text._ZN15vgl_rotation_3dIdEC1ERK16vnl_vector_fixedIdLj3EES4_[vgl_rotation_3d<double>::vgl_rotation_3d(vnl_vector_fixed<double,
3u> const&, vnl_vector_fixed<double, 3u> const&)]+0x14a): undefined
reference to `vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_rotation_3d.o: In function
`vgl_rotation_3d<vnl_rational>::vgl_rotation_3d(vnl_vector_fixed<vnl_rational,
3u> const&, vnl_vector_fixed<vnl_rational, 3u> const&)':
test_rotation_3d.cxx:(.text._ZN15vgl_rotation_3dI12vnl_rationalEC1ERK16vnl_vector_fixedIS0_Lj3EES5_[vgl_rotation_3d<vnl_rational>::vgl_rotation_3d(vnl_vector_fixed<vnl_rational,
3u> const&, vnl_vector_fixed<vnl_rational, 3u> const&)]+0x250):
undefined reference to `vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/test_rotation_3d.o: In function
`vgl_rotation_3d<float>::vgl_rotation_3d(vnl_vector_fixed<float, 3u>
const&, vnl_vector_fixed<float, 3u> const&)':
test_rotation_3d.cxx:(.text._ZN15vgl_rotation_3dIfEC1ERK16vnl_vector_fixedIfLj3EES4_[vgl_rotation_3d<float>::vgl_rotation_3d(vnl_vector_fixed<float,
3u> const&, vnl_vector_fixed<float, 3u> const&)]+0x15a): undefined
reference to `vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_vector_3d+float-.o): In function
`vgl_vector_3d<float> orthogonal_vectors<float>(vgl_vector_3d<float>
const&, double)':
vgl_vector_3d+float-.cxx:(.text._Z18orthogonal_vectorsIfE13vgl_vector_3dIT_ERKS2_d[vgl_vector_3d<float>
orthogonal_vectors<float>(vgl_vector_3d<float> const&, double)]+0xa7):
undefined reference to `vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_polygon+double-.o): In function `void
vgl_selfintersections<double>(vgl_polygon<double> const&,
std::vector<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int>,
std::allocator<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int> > >&,
std::vector<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int>,
std::allocator<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int> > >&,
std::vector<vgl_point_2d<double>, std::allocator<vgl_point_2d<double>
> >&)':
vgl_polygon+double-.cxx:(.text._Z21vgl_selfintersectionsIdEvRK11vgl_polygonIT_ERSt6vectorISt4pairIjjESaIS7_EESA_RS5_I12vgl_point_2dIS1_ESaISC_EE[void
vgl_selfintersections<double>(vgl_polygon<double> const&,
std::vector<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int>,
std::allocator<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int> > >&,
std::vector<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int>,
std::allocator<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int> > >&,
std::vector<vgl_point_2d<double>, std::allocator<vgl_point_2d<double>
> >&)]+0x2d): undefined reference to `vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_vector_3d+int-.o): In function
`vgl_vector_3d<int> orthogonal_vectors<int>(vgl_vector_3d<int> const&,
double)':
vgl_vector_3d+int-.cxx:(.text._Z18orthogonal_vectorsIiE13vgl_vector_3dIT_ERKS2_d[vgl_vector_3d<int>
orthogonal_vectors<int>(vgl_vector_3d<int> const&, double)]+0xa8):
undefined reference to `vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_polygon+float-.o): In function `void
vgl_selfintersections<float>(vgl_polygon<float> const&,
std::vector<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int>,
std::allocator<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int> > >&,
std::vector<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int>,
std::allocator<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int> > >&,
std::vector<vgl_point_2d<float>, std::allocator<vgl_point_2d<float> >
>&)':
vgl_polygon+float-.cxx:(.text._Z21vgl_selfintersectionsIfEvRK11vgl_polygonIT_ERSt6vectorISt4pairIjjESaIS7_EESA_RS5_I12vgl_point_2dIS1_ESaISC_EE[void
vgl_selfintersections<float>(vgl_polygon<float> const&,
std::vector<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int>,
std::allocator<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int> > >&,
std::vector<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int>,
std::allocator<std::pair<unsigned int, unsigned int> > >&,
std::vector<vgl_point_2d<float>, std::allocator<vgl_point_2d<float> >
>&)]+0x2d): undefined reference to `vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points+double-.o): In
function `vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points<double>::force_point2_infinite()
const':
vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points+double-.cxx:(.text._ZNK25vgl_homg_line_3d_2_pointsIdE21force_point2_infiniteEv[vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points<double>::force_point2_infinite()
const]+0xf): undefined reference to `vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_intersection+float-.o): In function `bool
vgl_intersection<float>(vgl_line_2d<float> const&, vgl_line_2d<float>
const&, vgl_point_2d<float>&)':
vgl_intersection+float-.cxx:(.text._Z16vgl_intersectionIfEbRK11vgl_line_2dIT_ES4_R12vgl_point_2dIS1_E[bool
vgl_intersection<float>(vgl_line_2d<float> const&, vgl_line_2d<float>
const&, vgl_point_2d<float>&)]+0xa4): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_intersection+float-.o): In function `bool
vgl_lineseg_test_point<float>(vgl_point_2d<float> const&,
vgl_line_segment_2d<float> const&)':
vgl_intersection+float-.cxx:(.text._Z22vgl_lineseg_test_pointIfEbRK12vgl_point_2dIT_ERK19vgl_line_segment_2dIS1_E[bool
vgl_lineseg_test_point<float>(vgl_point_2d<float> const&,
vgl_line_segment_2d<float> const&)]+0x1b0): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_intersection+float-.o): In function `bool
coplanar<float>(vgl_point_3d<float> const&, vgl_point_3d<float>
const&, vgl_point_3d<float> const&, vgl_point_3d<float> const&)':
vgl_intersection+float-.cxx:(.text._Z8coplanarIfEbRK12vgl_point_3dIT_ES4_S4_S4_[bool
coplanar<float>(vgl_point_3d<float> const&, vgl_point_3d<float>
const&, vgl_point_3d<float> const&, vgl_point_3d<float>
const&)]+0x6b7): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::point_3d_coplanarity'
vgl_intersection+float-.cxx:(.text._Z8coplanarIfEbRK12vgl_point_3dIT_ES4_S4_S4_[bool
coplanar<float>(vgl_point_3d<float> const&, vgl_point_3d<float>
const&, vgl_point_3d<float> const&, vgl_point_3d<float>
const&)]+0x6cd): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::point_3d_coplanarity'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_ray_3d+double-.o): In function
`vgl_ray_3d<double>::contains(vgl_point_3d<double> const&) const':
vgl_ray_3d+double-.cxx:(.text._ZNK10vgl_ray_3dIdE8containsERK12vgl_point_3dIdE[vgl_ray_3d<double>::contains(vgl_point_3d<double>
const&) const]+0x52): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
vgl_ray_3d+double-.cxx:(.text._ZNK10vgl_ray_3dIdE8containsERK12vgl_point_3dIdE[vgl_ray_3d<double>::contains(vgl_point_3d<double>
const&) const]+0xa7): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points+float-.o): In function
`vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points<float>::force_point2_infinite() const':
vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points+float-.cxx:(.text._ZNK25vgl_homg_line_3d_2_pointsIfE21force_point2_infiniteEv[vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points<float>::force_point2_infinite()
const]+0xf): undefined reference to `vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_vector_3d+double-.o): In function
`vgl_vector_3d<double>
orthogonal_vectors<double>(vgl_vector_3d<double> const&, double)':
vgl_vector_3d+double-.cxx:(.text._Z18orthogonal_vectorsIdE13vgl_vector_3dIT_ERKS2_d[vgl_vector_3d<double>
orthogonal_vectors<double>(vgl_vector_3d<double> const&,
double)]+0xab): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_ray_3d+float-.o): In function
`vgl_ray_3d<float>::contains(vgl_point_3d<float> const&) const':
vgl_ray_3d+float-.cxx:(.text._ZNK10vgl_ray_3dIfE8containsERK12vgl_point_3dIfE[vgl_ray_3d<float>::contains(vgl_point_3d<float>
const&) const]+0x90): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
vgl_ray_3d+float-.cxx:(.text._ZNK10vgl_ray_3dIfE8containsERK12vgl_point_3dIfE[vgl_ray_3d<float>::contains(vgl_point_3d<float>
const&) const]+0xff): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<float>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_intersection+double-.o): In function `bool
vgl_intersection<double>(vgl_line_2d<double> const&,
vgl_line_2d<double> const&, vgl_point_2d<double>&)':
vgl_intersection+double-.cxx:(.text._Z16vgl_intersectionIdEbRK11vgl_line_2dIT_ES4_R12vgl_point_2dIS1_E[bool
vgl_intersection<double>(vgl_line_2d<double> const&,
vgl_line_2d<double> const&, vgl_point_2d<double>&)]+0xa4): undefined
reference to `vgl_tolerance<double>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_ray_3d+int-.o): In function
`vgl_ray_3d<int>::contains(vgl_point_3d<int> const&) const':
vgl_ray_3d+int-.cxx:(.text._ZNK10vgl_ray_3dIiE8containsERK12vgl_point_3dIiE[vgl_ray_3d<int>::contains(vgl_point_3d<int>
const&) const]+0x80): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
vgl_ray_3d+int-.cxx:(.text._ZNK10vgl_ray_3dIiE8containsERK12vgl_point_3dIiE[vgl_ray_3d<int>::contains(vgl_point_3d<int>
const&) const]+0xdc): undefined reference to
`vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
../../../lib/libvgl.a(vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points+int-.o): In function
`vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points<int>::force_point2_infinite() const':
vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points+int-.cxx:(.text._ZNK25vgl_homg_line_3d_2_pointsIiE21force_point2_infiniteEv[vgl_homg_line_3d_2_points<int>::force_point2_infinite()
const]+0x10): undefined reference to `vgl_tolerance<int>::position'
collect2: ld returned 1 exit status
make[2]: *** [core/vgl/tests/vgl_test_all] Error 1
make[2]: Leaving directory `/home/cshome/m/mccane/vxl/bin'
make[1]: *** [core/vgl/tests/CMakeFiles/vgl_test_all.dir/all] Error 2
make[1]: Leaving directory `/home/cshome/m/mccane/vxl/bin'
make: *** [all] Error 2


The only thing that I could see that was different in the compile
command on my mac versus the linux box is the -rdynamic. However,
manually removing it had no effect (I could not discover how to remove
it via cmake since it didn't seem to be referenced anywhere).

I have attached the CMakeCache.txt file if that helps.

Any ideas?
-- 
Cheers,

Brendan

PS. had a quick look at the mail archives but couldn't find anything.
Does anyone know how to search a specific archive, because I'm damned
if I can figure it out (e.g. searching for "unsigned int" from the
vxl-maintainers page returns a few hits from other sourceforge pages).