Menu
▾
▴
Re: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code problem - results
|
From: Vulcan A. <vu...@st...> - 2006-02-19 16:52:27
|
<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN">
<HTML><HEAD><TITLE></TITLE>
<META http-equiv=3DContent-Type content=3D"text/html; charset=3DISO-8859-1"=
>
<STYLE type=3Dtext/css>
<!--=20
.message {background: white; font-size:9pt; font-family:'Arial';}
.message p { margin-top: 0em; margin-bottom: 0em; }
-->
</STYLE>
</HEAD>
<BODY class=3D'message' bgColor=3D#ffffff>
The new code made no difference. I have attached 2 files, one with the out=
put from 2.101 and the other from 2.97. It is still interesting to note th=
at 2.97 has some retries for that particular address only (at least consist=
ently).<br /><br />I moved the X10 address to B16 and E16 to see if this pr=
oblem is somehow related to the 16 unit code, but it's not, those units cod=
es worked OK with the other house codes.<br /><br />Since this is happening=
only on C16 in my config, I am going to move on by changing the unit code =
to something else. I'll keep a device on C16 for test purposes to see if t=
his can worked out.<br /><br />Peter<br /> <br /> <br /><blockquote style=
=3D"PADDING-RIGHT: 0px; PADDING-LEFT: 5px; MARGIN-LEFT: 5px; BORDER-LEFT: #=
5167c6 2px solid; MARGIN-RIGHT: 0px"><div style=3D"FONT: 10pt arial">----- =
Original Message -----</div><div style=3D"BACKGROUND: #e4e4e4; FONT: 10pt a=
rial; font-color: black"><b>From:</b> David Norwood <a href=3D"mailto:dnorw=
oo...@ya..."><dno...@ya...></a></div><div style=3D"FONT: 10=
pt arial"><b>To:</b> John Dunlop <a href=3D"mailto:jo...@du..."><=
jo...@du...></a></div><div style=3D"FONT: 10pt arial"><b>Date:</b=
> Sunday, February 19 2006 12:42 AM</div><div style=3D"FONT: 10pt arial"><b=
>Subject:</b> Re: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code problem - results</div>Your =
log output looks very strange. It's as if there is no cm11 connected. <br =
/>You may have a different problem. I would like to hear from vulcan before=
I <br />continue. <br /> <br />The only file you should have to copy from=
2.95 is CM11.pm. Let me know if <br />that works. <br /> <br />David <br =
/> <br />----- Original Message ----- <br />From: "John Dunlop" =
<jo...@du...> <br />To: "David Norwood" <dnorwood=
2...@ya...> <br />Cc: "Vulcan Automation" <vulcan@starcast=
le.ca> <br />Sent: Saturday, February 18, 2006 8:43 AM <br />Subject: Re=
: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code problem - results <br /> <br /> <br />> D=
avid, thanks very much for the work on this. I have attached my log <br />&=
gt; file. As you can see it looks like the problem is on receiving data fro=
m <br />> the CM11 - I also am not getting any information back from mot=
ion <br />> sensors as well as not being able to issue commands. <br />&=
gt; <br />> For now I am happy enough rolling back to 2.95 - can you tel=
l me which <br />> modules and libraries are involved in x10 commands - =
I would like to try <br />> swapping the .95 version into .101 and see w=
hat I can get working. <br />> <br />> I should also add that this is=
running on SuSE 9.3. <br />> <br />> Thanks again <br />> <br />&=
gt; <br />> David Norwood was kind enough to write on 02/18/2006 01:52 A=
M: <br />> <br />>> I removed all the goto's from the send subrout=
ine and tested it as <br />>> much as I could. Please give this a try=
and reply with log output <br />>> even if it works. Thanks. <br />&=
gt;> <br />>> David <br />>> <br />>> <br />>> -=
---- Original Message ----- <br />>> *From:* Vulcan Automation <ma=
ilto:vu...@st...> <br />>> *To:* misterhouse-users@lists.=
sourceforge.net <br />>> <mailto:mis...@li...urcefor=
ge.net> <br />>> *Sent:* Friday, February 17, 2006 6:32 PM <br />&=
gt;> *Subject:* Re: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code problem - results <br /=
>>> <br />>> Sorry for taking so long to reply. <br />>> =
<br />>> The problem with cm11.pm is that the RETRY label is used in =
a <br />>> number of places in the code so it is not possible to drop=
that <br />>> piece of code in without the module blowing up. <br />=
>> <br />>> ----- Original Message ----- <br />>> *From:*=
David Norwood <dno...@ya...> <br />>> <mailto:dnorwo=
od...@ya...%3E> <br />>> *To:* <mis...@li...urc=
eforge.net> <br />>> <mailto:mis...@li...urceforg=
e.net%3E> <br />>> *Date:* Tuesday, February 14 2006 12:46 AM <br =
/>>> *Subject:* Re: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code problem - results <b=
r />>> I think the problem is that your CM11 takes several tries to <=
br />>> send the C16 (CG) unit command, and retries have been broken =
<br />>> since 2.100. Tim's problem is different. Here is the bad cod=
e: <br />>> <br />>> my $retry_cnt =3D 0; <br />>> RETRY:=
<br />>> print "CM11 send: ", unpack('H*', $data_snd), &qu=
ot;\n" if $DEBUG; <br />>> <br />>> print "Bad cm11 d=
ata send transmission\n" unless <br />>> length($data_snd) =3D=
=3D $serial_port->write($data_snd); <br />>> <br />>> <br />=
>> <br />>> <br />>> # checksum might be the power fail f=
lag (0xa5) <br />>> <br />>> my $data_rcv; <br />>> goto =
RETRY unless $data_rcv =3D &read($serial_port, 0, <br />>> ($chec=
ksum =3D=3D 0xa5)) or $retry_cnt++ < 32; <br />>> # Note: Skip the=
power fail check, because we the <br />>> I was taught not to use GO=
TO, so here is my version without it: <br />>> <br />>> my ($da=
ta_rcv, $retry_cnt); <br />>> until ($data_rcv or $retry_cnt++ > 3=
2) { <br />>> print "CM11 send: ", unpack('H*', $data_snd),=
" try: <br />>> $retry_cnt\n" if $DEBUG; <br />>> pr=
int "Bad cm11 data send transmission\n" unless <br />>> len=
gth($data_snd) =3D=3D $serial_port->write($data_snd); <br />>> <br=
/>>> <br />>> <br />>> <br />>> $data_rcv =3D &=
;read($serial_port, 0, ($checksum =3D=3D 0xa5)); <br />>> } <br />>=
;> <br />>> # Note: Skip the power fail check if the checksum is t=
he power <br />>> fail flag (0xa5) <br />>> Replace this code i=
n CM11. pm and give it a try. <br />>> David <br />>> <br />>=
;> ----- Original Message ----- <br />>> *From:* Vulcan Automation=
<mailto:vu...@st...> <br />>> *To:* misterhouse-users=
@lists.sourceforge.net <br />>> <mailto:mis...@li...=
urceforge.net> <br />>> *Sent:* Monday, February 13, 2006 6:49 PM =
<br />>> *Subject:* Re: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code problem - result=
s <br />>> <br />>> Actually Vulcan was my first attempt at aut=
omation, <br />>> therefore the email name. <br />>> <br />>=
> Following here are some successful transmits from 2.97: <br />>>=
<br />>> <br />>> CM11 data=3D85 hex=3D55 <br />>> CM11 =
done <br />>> X10: interface=3Dcm11 isfunc=3D1 save_unit=3DXCG data=
=3DXCK <br />>> CM11 send data=3DCK <br />>> CM11 dim=3D0 heade=
r=3D00000110 hb=3D0010 cb=3D0011 bd=3D0x06,0x23 <br />>> checksum=3D0=
x29 <br />>> CM11 send: 0623 <br />>> .. <br />>> CM11 da=
ta=3D41 hex=3D29 <br />>> CM11 ack <br />>> .......... <br />&g=
t;> CM11 data=3D85 hex=3D55 <br />>> CM11 done <br />>> X10:=
interface=3Dcm11 isfunc=3D0 save_unit=3DXOE data=3DXOE <br />>> CM11=
send data=3DOE <br />>> CM11 dim=3D0 header=3D00000100 hb=3D0100 cb=
=3D1000 bd=3D0x04,0x48 <br />>> checksum=3D0x4c <br />>> CM11 s=
end: 0448 <br />>> .. <br />>> CM1 1 data=3D76 hex=3D4c <br />&=
gt;> CM11 ack <br />>> .......... <br />>> <br />>> He=
re is an unsuccesul one: <br />>> <br />>> X10: interface=3Dcm1=
1 isfunc=3D0 save_unit=3DXCG data=3DXCG <br />>> CM11 send data=3DCG =
<br />>> CM11 dim=3D0 header=3D00000100 hb=3D0010 cb=3D1100 bd=3D0x04=
,0x2c <br />>> checksum=3D0x30 <br />>> CM11 send: 042c <br />&=
gt;> ..............................No data received from cm11 <br />>=
> Bad checksum in cm11 send: cs1=3D48 cs2=3D. Will retry <br />>> =
CM11 send: 042c <br />>> ..............................No data receiv=
ed from cm11 <br />>> Bad checksum in cm11 send: cs1=3D48 cs2=3D. Wil=
l retry <br />>> CM11 send: 042c <br />>> .....................=
.........No data received from cm11 <br />>> Bad checksum in cm11 sen=
d: cs1=3D48 cs2=3D. Will retry <br />>> CM11 send: 042c <br />>>=
; ..............................No data received from cm11 <br />>> B=
ad checksum in cm11 send: cs1=3D48 cs2=3D. Will retry <br />>> CM11 a=
ck <br />>> .......... <br />>> CM11 data=3D85 hex=3D55 <br />&=
gt;> CM11 done <br />>> X10: interface=3Dcm11 isfunc=3D1 save_unit=
=3DXCG data=3DXCJ <br />>> CM11 send data=3DCJ <br />>> CM11 di=
m=3D0 header=3D00000110 hb=3D0010 cb=3D0010 bd=3D0x06,0x22 <br />>> c=
hecksum=3D0x28 <br />>> CM11 send: 0622 <br />>> .. <br />>&=
gt; CM11 data=3D40 hex=3D28 <br />>> CM11 ack <br />>> ........=
.. <br />>> CM11 data=3D85 hex=3D55 <br />>> CM11 done <br />&g=
t;> <br />>> Notice that 2.97 retries 4 times then 'gets through',=
the <br />>> interesting part is that it is unit code '16' again (on=
<br />>> house code C). Another post (Tim Sailer) is having <br />&g=
t;> problems with unit code 16 with a house code of A (this is <br />>=
;> unit AG unless I read it wrong). <br />>> <br />>> Never =
noticed the retry issue in 2.97 because the action <br />>> was alway=
s completed. Also this is the only unit I have on <br />>> '16'. I am=
going to switch a unit over to see if I can <br />>> reproduce this =
on another house code. Will get back with <br />>> results. <br />>=
;> <br />>> ----- Original Message ----- <br />>> *From:* Da=
vid Norwood <dno...@ya...> <br />>> <mailto:dnorwood2=
@yahoo.com> <br />>> *To:* <mis...@li...urceforge=
.net> <br />>> <mailto:mis...@li...&=
gt; <br />>> *Date:* Sunday, February 12 2006 09:39 PM <br />>>=
*Subject:* Re: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code problem - <br />>> resul=
ts <br />>> I can't see why it's looping forever. It should give <br =
/>>> up after 32 tries. Would change the print statement a <br />>=
> few lines up to this: <br />>> print "CM11 send: ", un=
pack('H*', $data_snd), ", <br />>> retry: $retry_cnt\n" if =
$DEBUG; <br />>> <br />>> This will show us if the retry count =
is incrementing. <br />>> There were major changes to this section of=
code in <br />>> 2.100 by David Mark. David, can you through us a bo=
ne <br />>> here? I'm flying blind here since I don't even have a <br=
/>>> CM11. <br />>> <br />>> Vulcan (Mr. Vulcan?), would=
you post the log entries <br />>> from a successful transmission in =
2.97? I'm interested <br />>> to see if it's retrying. <br />>>=
<br />>> David <br />>> <br />>> <br />>> ----- Or=
iginal Message ----- <br />>> *From:* Vulcan Automation <br />>>=
; <mailto:vu...@st...> <br />>> *To:* misterhouse-user=
s...@li... <br />>> <mailto:misterhouse-users@lists.s=
ourceforge.net> <br />>> *Sent:* Sunday, February 12, 2006 1:45 PM=
<br />>> *Subject:* Re: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code <br />>> =
problem - results <br />>> <br />>> When I use the changed piec=
e of code with the <br />>> parens the code loops forever when I try =
to issue <br />>> an X10 command. The message indicates that the <br =
/>>> code is having problems communicating with the cm11a. <br />>=
> <br />>> When I roll back to version 2.97 the same <br />>>=
; equipment works OK. <br />>> <br />>> <br />>> ----- Or=
iginal Message ----- <br />>> *From:* Neil Cherry <ncherry@comcast=
.net> <br />>> <mailto:nc...@co...%3E> <br />>>=
; *To:* <br />>> <mis...@li...> <br =
/>>> <br />>> <mailto:mis...@li...urceforge.n=
et%3E> <br />>> *Date:* Saturday, February 11 2006 07:07 PM <br />=
>> *Subject:* Re: [mh] cm11.pm - Possible code <br />>> problem=
<br />>> Peter W wrote: <br />>> > Made the change and rcvd=
teh follwing <br />>> compile error: <br />>> > <br />>&=
gt; > Can't modify not in scalar assignment at <br />>> ../lib/sit=
e/ControlX10/CM11.pm <br />>> > line 350 <br />>> > , nea=
r ") and" <br />>> <br />>> Give this a try (I hate i=
t when programmers <br />>> don't add parens): <br />>> <br />&=
gt;> goto RETRY if(! ($data_rcv =3D <br />>> &read($serial_por=
t, 0, <br />>> ($checksum =3D=3D 0xa5))) and ($retry_cnt++ < 32));=
<br />>> <br />>> I'm not sure if that will help, note the use=
r <br />>> of double equals <br />>> with $checksum <br />>&=
gt; <br />>> -- <br />>> Linux Home Automation Neil Cherry <br=
/>>> nc...@li... <br />>> http://www.linuxha.com/ Main=
site <br />>> http://linuxha.blogspot.com/ My HA Blog <br />>>=
http://home.comcast.net/~ncherry/ Backup site <br />>> <br />>>=
; <br />>> ------------------------------------------------------- <b=
r />>> <br />>> This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc. =
<br />>> Do you grep through log files <br />>> for problems? S=
top! Download the new AJAX <br />>> search engine that makes <br />&g=
t;> searching your log files as easy as surfing <br />>> the web. =
DOWNLOAD SPLUNK! <br />>> <br />>> http://sel.as-us.falkag.net=
/sel?cmd=3Dlnk&kid=3D103432&bid=3D230486&dat=3D121642 <br />>=
;> <br />>> <br />>> ______________________________________=
__________________ <br />>> <br />>> To unsubscribe from this l=
ist, go to: <br />>> http://sourceforge.net/mail/?group_id=3D1365 <br=
/>>> <br />>> <br />>> <br />>> -- <br />>>=
No virus found in this incoming message. <br />>> Checked by AVG Fre=
e Edition. <br />>> Version: 7.1.375 / Virus Database: <br />>>=
267.15.6/257 - Release Date: 2/10/2006 <br />>> <br />>> -----=
-------------------------------------------------- <br />>> This SF.n=
et email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc. Do <br />>> you grep through lo=
g files for problems? Stop! <br />>> Download the new AJAX search eng=
ine that makes <br />>> searching your log files as easy as surfing t=
he <br />>> web. DOWNLOAD SPLUNK! <br />>> <br />>> http=
://sel.as-us.falkag.net/sel?cmd=3Dk&kid=103432&bid#0486&dat=121=
642 <br />>> <br />>> ________________________________________=
________________ <br />>> To unsubscribe from this list, go to: <br /=
>>> http://sourceforge.net/mail/?group_id=1365 <br />>> <br />&=
gt;> ------------------------------------------------------- <br />>&=
gt; This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc. Do you grep <br />>&g=
t; through log files for problems? Stop! Download the new <br />>> AJ=
AX search engine that makes searching your log files as <br />>> easy=
as surfing the web. DOWNLOAD SPLUNK! <br />>> <br />>> http:/=
/sel.as-us.falkag.net/sel?cmd=3Dk&kid=103432&bid#0486&dat=12164=
2 <br />>> ________________________________________________________ <=
br />>> To unsubscribe from this list, go to: <br />>> http://s=
ourceforge.net/mail/?group_id=1365 <br />>> <br />>> ----------=
--------------------------------------------- This <br />>> SF.net em=
ail is sponsored by: Splunk Inc. Do you grep through log <br />>> fil=
es for problems? Stop! Download the new AJAX search engine that <br />>&=
gt; makes searching your log files as easy as surfing the web. <br />>&g=
t; DOWNLOAD SPLUNK! <br />>> http://sel.as-us.falkag.net/sel?cmd=3Dk&=
amp;kid=103432&bid#0486&dat=121642 <br />>> _________________=
_______________________________________ To <br />>> unsubscribe from =
this list, go to: <br />>> http://sourceforge.net/mail/?group_id=1365=
<br />>> <br />> <br />> <br />> -- <br />> John M. Dun=
lop <br />> <br />> Home Phone :301-217-0028 <br />> Mobile Phone =
:703-627-3796 <br />> <br />> www.dunlopweb.net <br />> <br />>=
<br /> <br /> <br />------------------------------------------------------=
-------------------------- <br /> <br /> <br />> X10: interface=3Dcm11 i=
sfunc=3D0 save_unit=3DXA4 data=3DXA4 <br />> CM11 send data=3DA4 <br />&=
gt; CM11 dim=3D0 header=3D00000100 hb=3D0110 cb=3D1010 bd=3D0x04,0x6a check=
sum=3D0x6e <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 1 <br />> ...................=
...........................................................................=
......No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try=
: 2 <br />> ............................................................=
........................................No <br />> data received from c=
m11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 3 <br />> ..........................=
..........................................................................N=
o <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 4 <br=
/>> ...................................................................=
.................................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br=
/>> CM11 send: 046a try: 5 <br />> .................................=
...................................................................No <br =
/>> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 6 <br />>=
..........................................................................=
..........................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />>=
CM11 send: 046a try: 7 <br />> ........................................=
............................................................No <br />> =
data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 8 <br />> ......=
...........................................................................=
...................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 s=
end: 046a try: 9 <br />> ...............................................=
.....................................................No <br />> data re=
ceived from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 10 <br />> ............=
...........................................................................=
.............No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0=
46a try: 11 <br />> ....................................................=
................................................No <br />> data receive=
d from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 12 <br />> .................=
...........................................................................=
........No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a t=
ry: 13 <br />> .........................................................=
...........................................No <br />> data received fro=
m cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 14 <br />> ......................=
...........................................................................=
...No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 1=
5 <br />> ..............................................................=
......................................No <br />> data received from cm1=
1 <br />> CM11 send: 046a try: 16 <br />> ...........................=
.........................................................................No=
<br />> data received from cm11 <br />> cm11 send failed <br />>=
X10: interface=3Dcm11 isfunc=3D1 save_unit=3DXA4 data=3DXAJ <br />> CM1=
1 send data=3DAJ <br />> CM11 dim=3D0 header=3D00000110 hb=3D0110 cb=3D0=
010 bd=3D0x06,0x62 checksum=3D0x68 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 1 <br />=
> ......................................................................=
..............................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />=
> CM11 send: 0662 try: 2 <br />> ....................................=
................................................................No <br />&=
gt; data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 3 <br />> ..=
...........................................................................=
.......................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM=
11 send: 0662 try: 4 <br />> ...........................................=
.........................................................No <br />> dat=
a received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 5 <br />> .........=
...........................................................................=
................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send=
: 0662 try: 6 <br />> ..................................................=
..................................................No <br />> data recei=
ved from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 7 <br />> ................=
...........................................................................=
.........No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 =
try: 8 <br />> .........................................................=
...........................................No <br />> data received fro=
m cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 9 <br />> .......................=
...........................................................................=
..No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 10=
<br />> ...............................................................=
.....................................No <br />> data received from cm11=
<br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 11 <br />> ............................=
........................................................................No =
<br />> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 12 <br =
/>> ....................................................................=
................................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br =
/>> CM11 send: 0662 try: 13 <br />> .................................=
...................................................................No <br =
/>> data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 14 <br />>=
; .........................................................................=
...........................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />>=
; CM11 send: 0662 try: 15 <br />> ......................................=
..............................................................No <br />>=
; data received from cm11 <br />> CM11 send: 0662 try: 16 <br />> ...=
...........................................................................=
......................No <br />> data received from cm11 <br />> cm1=
1 send failed <br />> Exit flag set in sig_handler <br />> Exiting pr=
ogram: normal <br />> 02/18/06 11:35:23 AM: Saving object states ... don=
e <br />> Bye Bye <br />> <br /> <br /> <br /> <br />-- <br />No vi=
rus found in this incoming message. <br />Checked by AVG Free Edition. <br =
/>Version: 7.1.375 / Virus Database: 267.15.11/264 - Release Date: 2/17/200=
6 <br /></blockquote>
</BODY></HTML> |