Menu

#401 Strip signature from replies

mh-e-6.1
open
nobody
None
5
2013-02-23
2002-10-31
Bill Wohler
No

The signature should be stripped from replies.

Specifically, anything following the string "CRLF--
CRLF" should be stripped.

The user can turn this behavior off by setting the
defcustom mh-reply-strip-signature-flag to nil
(default: t).

Ideally, the documentation (for
mh-reply-strip-signature-flag or mh-reply depending on
where it makes the most sense and the manual) should
cite an authorative source for doing this. The closest
we have so far include:

Usenet FAQ for signatures:
URL: http://www.faqs.org/faqs/usenet/signature-faq/

RFC 1855 does not actually specify the use of "\n-- \n"
just that the
signature should be no more than four lines.
URL: http://www.cis.ohio-state.edu/cgi-bin/rfc/rfc1855.html

The rocky-horror newsgroup charter specifies a
'standard signature
delimiter of "\n-- \n" ...
URL: http://www.rockynewsgroup.org/GetArticle/27636.html

A complaint about the standard format versus Microsoft
Outlook is here:
URL: http://www.okinfoweb.com/moe/bugs/bugs_047.htm

p.s. I cannot take credit for Peter's idea ;-). Thanks
to Mark for the references.

Discussion

  • Jeffrey Honig

    Jeffrey Honig - 2002-10-31

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=96862

    Given the references I can't say that this is a ``standard''
    more like
    a BCP (Best Current Practice).

    When striping the signature, we probably have to be MIME
    aware. If the signature is in the first text part we should
    only strip to the end of the part. Should we scan other
    text parts or assume it is in the first? Maybe look in the
    first and last?

     
  • Bill Wohler

    Bill Wohler - 2006-06-22
    • status: open --> open-accepted
     
  • Bill Wohler

    Bill Wohler - 2013-02-23
    • labels: General -->
     
  • Bill Wohler

    Bill Wohler - 2013-02-23

    Ticket moved from /p/mh-e/feature-requests/42/

     
  • Bill Wohler

    Bill Wohler - 2013-02-23
    • Status: open-accepted --> open
     

Log in to post a comment.