From: Zaheer M. <zah...@me...> - 2009-03-25 22:48:20
|
On Wed, Mar 25, 2009 at 9:24 PM, Felipe Contreras <fel...@gm...> wrote: > On Wed, Mar 25, 2009 at 12:20 PM, Edward Hervey <bi...@gm...> wrote: >> >>> I'll interpret that as "I don't care", so I went ahead and made the >>> modifications. >> >> ?? I would rather interpret the following as "I don't care about >> GStreamer": > > What? From your response one would think that 'not caring' about > .gitignore was a bad thing. It's not, some people care, some people > don't. He doesn't, I do... there's nothing inherently wrong with that. > > And now you throw a bunch of stuff that's completely unrelated: > >> * Removing usage of common submodule > > So? What is the impact? > > I'm thinking on adding a script that updates the files I copied from > 'common' and firing it before making a release. How would that be any > different from the current situation? > >> * Doing whitespace fixes after that and then suggesting those changes >> go into common (you could have done it in common from the start) > > I have suggested ways to improve 'common' and those were ignored. > > I don't see why I should put high in my priority list whitespace > cleanups for something I don't think should even exist (common). > >> * Removing the gst-indent pre-commit > > The only thing that script is doing is ensuring the current code has > two code-styles. Two code-styles = bad. > >> * Not using the gstreamer indentation style (there's a REASON we use >> it : it allows much faster reviewing of all gstreamer modules by other >> GStreamer developers). > > There has been plenty of time to improve gst-openmax, including the > code-style, and I've never seen any interest in doing that on any > mailing list. > > Now, the same day you proposed to update the code-style in our > internal (Nokia) IRC, I came up with a plan to do that without > disturbing anyone and I made it public on the gst-openmax mailing > list. > > I'm executing that plan, and sent some patches for reviewing. > > I'm also a busy person, and could spend my time doing some other more > productive stuff, and even though I'm doing exactly I said I would, > apparently that's not good enough for you. > >> Should we remove gst-openmax from git.freedesktop.org ? > > Is that a threat? Well I'm going to seriously consider that as I > haven't seen any benefit from being on the 'GStreamer' umbrella at > all. If anything, it's the other way around, GStreamer has benefited > because in the embedded community vendors provide OpenMAX IL > components, not GStreamer. > > -- > Felipe Contreras > This all has blown out of proportion. Felipe, Tim and Edward should go on irc and discuss the problems with gitignore, code style, common etc. there and come up with a conclusion and learn to be able to talk rationally between each other. Zaheer |