[Fink-devel] flat namespaces redux

[Benjamin R. <be...@oc...>]

So the discussion came up on the fink irc channel again about libtool 
and namespaces.  I recall being rejected in wanting to add support for 
linker namespaces in libtool in the thread following this post:

   http://www.mail-archive.com/li...@gn.../msg03042.html

...but looking at the archives, I don't see a post following my 
--namespace= proposal, so I have no idea where we left off.  =)

As more stuff gets ported to OSX and they interact with each other, 
having things build with flat namespaces is becoming more and more of 
an issue.  The problem is not necessarily that libtool needs to 
natively understand darwin library namespaces, but that it currently 
*forces* flat, which can cause weird and dangerous bugs in built 
libraries, and isn't the default linking behavior for the platform.

In F J Franklin's post here:

   http://www.mail-archive.com/li...@gn.../msg03058.html

He suggested changing it to "-multiply_defined suppress prebind", which 
seems to be the solution, if libtool doesn't want to support specifying 
the namespace on the libtool command-line.

This would make libtool default to making twolevel libraries (which is 
darwin's linker default, in fact), but you could still pass 
"-flat_namespace -undefined suppress" to the command-line if you have a 
poorly behaving app.

Does that seem like a workable solution?