From: Grant <ema...@gm...> - 2010-07-16 05:38:41
|
>>> I love cdrdao and I've been using it to rip CDs for a long time. >>> Recently I ran across 2 CDs that it has a problem ripping. Both are >>> The Beatles remastered Enhanced CDs "Please Please Me" and "With The >>> Beatles". cdrdao seems to have a problem detecting the end point of >>> the last audio track. I've attached the output of the read-cd >>> command. After splitting according to cdrdao's toc, the 14th track >>> includes about a minute of silence on the end followed by another >>> minute of a buzzing noise. Another annoyance is the fact that the >>> non-audio data portion of the Enhanced CD ends up being split and >>> encoded to flac as track 15 based on cdrdao's toc. >>> >>> - Grant >> >> I should mention that rubyripper creates the cuesheet correctly. I'd >> really like to stick with cdrdao though. >> >> - Grant > > This problem is actually documented here: > > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enhanced_CD > > "Sometimes computer CD-ripping programs (particularly cdparanoia) have > problems ripping some enhanced CDs, especially those that have the > data in a separate session after the audio section. These CDs have the > data 11,400 sectors (2m32s) after the audio, but some CD rippers may > try to rip this blank section with the last track; the end result is > that the ripper stalls during the last track, or simply reports > errors." > > - Grant I should also mention that it works correctly in rubyripper, and actually works in cdrdao maybe 10% of the time so it's inconsistent in cdrdao. - Grant |