Re: [Tikiwiki-devel] edit/remove perm on comment/post

[bertrand G. <ber...@to...>]

Hi
Sylvie Greverend wrote:

>I am lost (and tw also sometimes) with the edit/remove perm for a
>comment/post.
>
>To edit a comment on a page/blog, you need:
>- to be admin
>- or to have tiki_p_edit_comments
>- or to be the author
>To edit a forum post, you need:
>- to be an admin
>- or to be the forum admin
>- or to have tiki_p_edit_comments
>- or to be the author
>
>some points can be discussed:
>- can we edit a post/comment if somebody else has done a comment/post about
>your comment/post?
>- can we edit only if there is no direct reply to your comment/post (but
>sometimes users don't reply at the good level)?
>- for a forum is it tiki_p_edit_comments or
>(tiki_p_post_forum/tiki_p_post_forum_topic)? There is no
>tiki_p_edit_post_forum....
>
>To delete a comment, you need
>- to be an admin
>- to have tiki_p_remove_comments
>To delete a forum topic
>- to be an admin
>- to have tiki_p_remove_comments
>To delete a forum post
>- to be an admin
>- to have tiki_p_remove_comments
>
>Some same points can be applied + can we delete if we are the author?
>
>If nobody has objections the behaviour will be applied on tw
>thanks
>sylvie
>  
>
I imagine you went thru all the stuff <sighs>

I read here "to be admin" the same as "have tiki_p_xxx_comments" in each 
cases.
in the sense an admin knows what s?he does, a user with such delegations 
too.

For the "private" posts and the comments to them, the same schema should 
apply on a "local" base, if a user is trusted to administer h(er|is) 
private comments, why not ?
If it's a problem, you should not trust h(er|im)

Keep it the most simple possible.
Courage !
Hope we get a 1.9.2 very soon
-- 
bertrand "toggg" Gugger