Re: [mailinglists] Re: [Shorewall-users] Solution: H323, Gnomemeeting, Netmeeting

[Joshua B. <sy...@co...>]

Ingo Lantschner wrote:
> On Sun, 5 Sep 2004 21:45:24 +0200, Joel HATSCH <ho...@jo...>
> wrote:
>
>> If I understand it right, this setup works for sound, but what about
>> video ? IMHO this is the real issue with DNAT'ing.
> Yes you are right, it works for sound. Video not tested yet - did not
> know, that this is the bigger problem ...
> Regards, Ingo.

Yes, I knew video was a problem but in your initial email you made it sound as 
though you got Gnome meeting to work. Gnome meeting isn't working (IMO) if you 
can't get video to work.  I can use Yahoo IM to tunnel voip if I want audio 
with allot less overhead. Gnome Meeting like Net Meeting is meant for web 
video. So announcing to a firewalling list that you got Gnome meeting to work 
was misleading IMO. Gnome Meeting isn't working when you can only get audio to 
work in one direction..  or even both directions but no Video... Video is the 
main idea behind these programs..

Joshua Banks