Re: [Rosegarden-devel] [Rosegarden-bugs] SF.net SVN: rosegarden:[10938] trunk/rosegarden

[Vladimir S. <vla...@gm...>]

Julie S wrote:
> Hello All,
> 
> I saw this commit log note:,
> 
>> First step to add warning icons on notation staff headers
>> to show
>> information on clef and key iconsistencies
>> - Icons added, but popup is still to implement.
> 
> A warning into the header is fine.  A descriptive tip when hovering over the warning is fine.
> 
> Can we avoid using a popup?  Is it really necessary?  I don't see the use of this unless there is a decision to be made.  If the only option presented is an button "ok" then there is no decision to be made.
> 
> If RG needs user input, then it is acceptable.  Otherwise the warning icon in the header should be enough to let the user know to fix the problem.

More then valid view point. I agree 100%. Popup windows are to be
avoided my any mean!

Vlada

P.S. Some popups are actually good when used with caution. An example
would bek3b (burning application) notification popup. Since it's rarely
used, it really draws attention.

> Sincerely,
> Julie S.