[Quickfix-users] Rejected execution report: tag not required in dictionary but still reported as missing

[Francis G. <fr...@at...>]

QF seems to be rejecting an execution report because it doesn't have tag 58,
but the FIX42.xml dictionary lists the tag as not required.  Any idea why
this report is rejected?  I'm sure there's a simple explanation but I can't
see it.

This is from a ThreadedSocketInitiator client, and the FIX server is run
locally.

 FIX42.xml definition:
<message name="ExecutionReport" msgtype="8" msgcat="app">
<field name="Text" required="N"/>

Sending Order-Single (BUY 2 ES Mar05 at market):
8=FIX.4.2
9=187
35=D
34=159
49=FIXUSER
52=20050513-15:17:56.421
56=TEST
1=1

11=13/05/2005.23
21=1
38=2
40=1
47=0
48=ES0120050300000032320035
54=1
55=ES

59=0
60=20050513-15:17:56
167=FUT
204=0
207=SIM
10=024


Receiving Execution Reports:
8=FIX.4.2
9=00343
35=8
49=TTEST
56=FIXUSER
50=SIMTRADER
34=3743
52=20050513-
15:17:56.437
55=ES
48=ES0120050300000032320035
167=FUT
207=SIM
1=1
440=SIM
1
1=13/05/2005.23
37=0H0000022009
17=0H0000022009:1
58=GW:Order sent to
exchange
198=1005264
204=0
151=2
14=0
54=1
40=1
77=O
59=0
47=0
150=0
20=0
39
=0
442=1
38=2
6=0
200=200503
60=20050513-15:17:56.437
10=036


This one doesn't have a tag 58, should be no problem:
8=FIX.4.2
9=00324
35=8
49=TTEST
56=FIXUSER
50=SIMTRADER
34=3744
52=20050513-
15:17:56.437
55=ES
48=ES0120050300000032320035
167=FUT
207=SIM
1=1
440=SIM
1
1=13/05/2005.23
37=0H0000022009
17=2791
198=1005264
204=0
32=2
151=0
14=2
54
=1
40=1
77=O
59=0
47=0
150=2
20=0
39=2
442=1
38=2
31=112925
6=112925
200=200
503
60=20050513-15:17:56.437
10=027


Sending Reject:
8=FIX.4.2
9=108
35=3
34=160
49=FIXUSER
52=20050513-15:17:57.983
56=TEST
45=3
744
58=Required tag missing
371=58
372=8
373=1
10=115

 
Thanks,

Francis