Menu

#109 Take&make+Isardam stalemate

v4.37
closed-fixed
5
2012-12-19
2012-04-07
Anonymous
No

Position: White Sg6 Kg1 Black Bg8 Kh8 Bg7 Rh7 is checkmate in Take&MakeChess but stalemate in Take&MakeChess Isardam.
Also I think that position White Pa7 Pb5 Pd5 Kg1 Black Ba8 Kb8 Rc8 Bd8 Qb7 Bc7 Sd7 Pe7 Pb6 Pd6 Take&MakeChess Isardam
should be a stalemate, but Popeye says that this is chekmate.

Discussion

  • Thomas Maeder

    Thomas Maeder - 2012-04-11
    • labels: --> solving behavior
    • milestone: --> v4.37
     
  • Thomas Maeder

    Thomas Maeder - 2012-04-11

    Trying to understand the intent of the report:

    begin
    pieces White Sf4 Black Bg8 Kh8 Bg7 Rh7
    stip =1
    condition take isardam
    option nowk
    end

    produces the solution

    1.Sf4-g6 = !

    (has done so since <=4.37), which clearly isn't a solution.

    And

    begin
    pieces White Pa6 Pb5 Pd5 Kg1
    Black Ba8 Kb8 Rc8 Bd8 Qb7 Bc7 Sd7 Pe7 Pb6 Pd6
    stip #1
    condition isardam
    end

    produces the solution

    1.a6-a7 # !

    (has done so since <=4.37), which clearly isn't a solution.

    Looks like a bug in the implementation of Take&Make

     
  • Thomas Maeder

    Thomas Maeder - 2012-12-19
    • assigned_to: nobody --> thomasmaeder
    • status: open --> closed-fixed
     

Anonymous
Anonymous

Add attachments
Cancel





MongoDB Logo MongoDB