I see a few problems with privacy even when the names
and data of living persons are hidden.
Firstly, with all the dates of the recently deceased along
with the places, one could track down a person through
deduction.
Secondly, if one clicks on Marriage for a deceased man,
for example, his spouse's name comes up, thus exposing
her maiden name and address.
Thirdly, blocking out a whole living family with the
exception of a recently deceased child and giving a date
and place rather defeats the whole purpose.
What I would like to see is a practice followed by
organizations such as the Ontario Genealogical Society,
which many serious working genealogists adhere to:
1) as of this 2004, no people shown with births after
1909,
2) no people shown with marriages after 1924, and
3) no people shown with deaths after 1934.
Simply hiding certain facts or names of living people
does not go far enough.
Logged In: YES
user_id=634811
Do you have a link to any documents on the web that mention
birth age of 95, 80 years for marriage and 70 years for
death records as a standard for privacy? Is it used by
anyone other than the Ontario Genealogical Society?
I found :
http://www.rootsweb.com/~canon/resources-vits.html and other
Ontarion sources for the formula but nothing in other
places. Is Ontarion the only place that has Privacy rules? I
know Poland will release B/M/D records that are 100 years old.
Logged In: YES
user_id=300048
Attached is the privacy file that I mentioned in the forums,
just replace the gedcom.ged_priv.php file in the index
directory with this file for each gedcom with this file.
--John
Logged In: YES
user_id=300048
Sorry, I forgot to mention some more directions. You can
specify the age at which the privacy settings will take affect
by setting the "Age at which to assume a person is dead".
The default for this value is $MAX_ALIVE_AGE = 120.
The attached privacy file will hide people who were born less
than $MAX_ALIVE_AGE years ago, who were married less that
$MAX_ALIVE_AGE-15 years ago, and who died less than
$MAX_ALIVE_AGE-25 years ago.
--John
Logged In: YES
user_id=975275
Manitoba Vital Statistics supplies data on births over 100
years, marriages over 80 years and deaths over 70 years. So
this is similar to the OGS limits.
Thanks for the custom privacy file. It should be fairly easy to
tweak any of these settings now.
Loren
Logged In: YES
user_id=300048
As this is not going to be included in the main project, I am
going to move it to the patches section where others can
find it easier if they want.
--John
Logged In: YES
user_id=300048
Privacy By Year module updated on 26 Apr 2004.
--John
Logged In: YES
user_id=1136753
I am very excited about this enhancement on privacy and
feel that it would be added as an option to the standard
privacy settings...
With that, I replaced my ...ged_priv.php file with this one and
it appeared not to work. Not only did the people not
disappear that I thought would, the names of the living
showed up even with that option turned off.
Unfortunately I do not know enough about PHP to have
determined the issue. Let me know if there would be more
helpful.
Thanks,
Phil
Logged In: YES
user_id=300048
Hi Phil,
The 3.2 beta version includes this as a standard privacy
option. It is not the default option, but it is easy to flip the
switch in the privacy settings. My reccommendation to you
would be to use v3.2.
I don't know that this patch will work in version 3.1 and as it
has been included in v3.2, I will close this patch.
--John