RE: [phpBT-dev] Questionable Feature Requests

[Mufasa <mu...@co...>]

IMHO....

I would close these:

RFE #486191 - can't see a need for this--already has an ID
RFE #529972 - can't see a need for this either; bug numbers do not need to
be natural (aka mean something other than an identifier)
RFE #536452 - already has a 'number' aka ID, even though it is not editable.
If someone wants to track it with a number they can always put it in the
name
RFE #622590 - nothing wrong with this one really, but it isn't that
necessary. You can always just make a generic component and version if you
don't want them assigned to a specific one


I would leave these open:

RFE #595189 - Eventually, when reporting gets fuller featured, it would be
nice to see how many versions a bug spanned, etc. It is not a high priority
bug probably, but I'd leave this one open.
REF #975055 - Where copying and modifying might not be a big deal, I think
referencing old bugs formally (automatic linkage) for abstract reasons
(followups, reference to similar problems, tracking of repeated problems
with a system/user, and many others I'm sure...) is a good idea.


 
Jon Adams
FireTiger.net (http://www.firetiger.net)




-----Original Message-----
From: php...@li...
[mailto:php...@li...] On Behalf Of Ulf Erikson
Sent: Thursday, October 06, 2005 10:35 AM
To: php...@li...
Subject: [phpBT-dev] Questionable Feature Requests

Hoi,

I have found some Feature Requests where I am wondering whether anyone
but the reporter would find it useful.. Would it be okay to close any or
these?

 * RFE #486191 - unique bug ID (serial #)
     Each bug should have a unique serial number (which is really a
     counter). I think that is what we have? but maybe the request is
     that it should be editable?

 * RFE #529972 - Optional per-project numbering 
     Each project should start counting from bug #1. But what will
     happen when you move bugs from one project to another?

 * RFE #536452 - Project number  
     Each project should have an editable number besides a name.

 * RFE #595189 - Bug with multiple versions 
     Ability to mark a bug as existing in several versions without
     filing multiple bug reports.

 * RFE #622590 - Can not add new bug 
     Request to be able to work without component and version.

 * REF #975055 - Feature Req: Duplicate Bug  
     Request to be able to create new bugs by cloning and modifying old
     bugs.



-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.Net email is sponsored by:
Power Architecture Resource Center: Free content, downloads, discussions,
and more. http://solutions.newsforge.com/ibmarch.tmpl
_______________________________________________
phpbt-dev mailing list
php...@li...
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/phpbt-dev