Menu ▾ ▴

#375 Security Questions and Answers

open
nobody
5
6 days ago
2007-02-21
Anonymous
No

A number of web sites, especially financial related, are now requiring that you specify at least three (3) security questions and answers in addition to a password. It would be nice if I could store that information within this application also--other than just in the notes; ideally, at least the answers should be protected/hidden like you do the password field.

Discussion

  • Nobody/Anonymous

    Logged In: NO

    I am interested in this feature as well!

    marie.f.russo AT gmail.com

     
  • Thomas Waldmann

    Thomas Waldmann - 2013-08-29

    i think this FR can be closed. the notes now are hidden by default. also I think the notes are good enough for such stuff as you rarely need it.

    in fact, if you still can access the notes, you also should still have your password and thus not need the security questions (at least not for password recovery).

     
    • hhaake

      hhaake - 2014-02-07

      I am a huge fan of this feature, but taking it a step further. I look up the answer to the security questions every time I log into a financial site or others requiring more than just username and password. This is due to the use random answers to security questions to prevent social engineering.

      It would be nice to have somethign in the menu that lets me copy the answer to the question straight into the clipboard without opening the notes.

       

      Last edit: hhaake 2014-02-07
  • Dmitry Erastov

    Dmitry Erastov - 6 days ago

    Unfortunately in 2026 security questions are still a thing, mandatory for some financial websites and utilities and used as a 2nd factor during the normal login flow[1]. Following best practices, I treat them as passwords and store them as sensitive custom fields, so they can be copied using the right-click menu. The main inconvenience is in generating them. Let's say I'm setting up a new account that requires me to choose secret questions as part of the sign-up flow:

    1. After creating a new entry with a password I save and close the entry.
    2. Then press Ctrl-A to open a new entry dialog and generate a password (the random secret answer), copy it, and close the dialog without saving.
    3. Go back to the main entry, create a new custom field and paste the generated value, save and close.
    4. Repeat this 2 more times (or however many the website requires).

    One enhancement that comes to mind is having a "generate random value" button in the edit custom field dialog. For simplicity it could use the same policy as the main entry.
    A step that's a bit more controversial is to have up to 3 "secret question" fields per entry that are treated as 1st class citizens - e.g. added to the dragbar and located at the 1st level of the right-click menu. Additional questions could be added as custom fields. This option was proposed in other issues, but the main pushback was that different systems require a different number of these "additional passwords".

    Not sure how many people share the same misfortune of having to deal with secret questions.

    [1] (sigh) I wish those providers would just follow the NIST 800-63 guidelines, namely

    Verifiers and CSPs SHALL NOT prompt subscribers to use knowledge-based authentication (KBA) (e.g., “What was the name of your first pet?”) or security questions when choosing passwords.

    [2] Related issues:

     

    Last edit: Dmitry Erastov 6 days ago

Log in to post a comment.