Menu

#57 IsTremulant at the rank level

Audio
invalid
nobody
None
1
2015-11-30
2015-11-30
No

When I have different wav files for sound with tremulant and without it, I should create two ranks for the same stop and set Pipe999IsTremulant=1 and Pipe999IsTremulant=0 for the all pipes. It would be more convinient to specify the whole rank as Tremulant and Not Tremulant. But the setting IsTremulant is invalid now.

Discussion

  • Lars Palo

    Lars Palo - 2015-11-30

    When I have different wav files for sound with tremulant and without it, I should create two ranks for the same stop and set Pipe999IsTremulant=1 and Pipe999IsTremulant=0 for the all pipes. It would be more convinient to specify the whole rank as Tremulant and Not Tremulant. But the setting IsTremulant is invalid now.

    From the organ modeling point of view I think that what you're doing is wrong. The tremulant should affect the same pipe that without the tremulant still belongs to the same rank, not another rank! Technically, the tremmed sample and the un-tremmed one really is the same pipe sounding.

     
  • Martin Koegler

    Martin Koegler - 2015-11-30
    • status: open --> invalid
     
  • Martin Koegler

    Martin Koegler - 2015-11-30

    Two ranks is HW style.

    GO requires, that you put the tremmed and non-tremmed samples into one pipe and annotate each sample file with IsTremulant accordingly. There are already a few samplesets using this.

     
MongoDB Logo MongoDB