Menu ▾ ▴

#11 [BUG] Link too just copies text, not an actual text flow link?

open
nobody
bug (6)
3 days ago
5 days ago
Anonymous
No

Originally created by: IcedQuinn
Originally owned by: rmellis

Expected behavior

Linking two text boxes with the Link tool should have those boxes share text, but spill content from one to the next. Changing the size of a box should re-flow text between the boxes. Instead, it seems text is simply cut and pasted from the source box to the destination box one-time.

At least, in Scribus, InDesign, and DesignCraft thats how linking text works. Google searches suggest Publisher does the same, but I can't test that.

Screenshots or Screen Recordings

Sample Document (.opub)

Environment (please complete the following information):

  • OS: [e.g. Windows 11, macOS Sonoma, Ubuntu 22.04]
  • Platform/Installation Method: [e.g. Windows Portable .exe, macOS App, Linux .AppImage, or Web Browser]
  • Browser (if using the web version): [e.g. Chrome, Firefox, Safari]

Additional context

Related

Tickets: #11

Discussion

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 5 days ago
     
  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 4 days ago

    Originally posted by: rmellis

    Hi @IcedQuinn, thanks for opening this issue and pointing this out!
    You were completely right: previously, the Link tool only performed a one-time text split rather than creating a true continuous text flow chain like Scribus, InDesign, or Publisher.

    We have just shipped v5.21.0 on openpublisher.app, which upgrades linked text boxes into a live, bidirectional text flow engine.

    What's new in v5.21.0:

    • Live Continuous Reflow: Linked text boxes now stay dynamically connected. Typing, pasting, or resizing any box in a chain automatically spills overflowing text forward into the next frame or pulls it back up when space opens up.

    • Visual Chain Indicators: Selecting a linked text box now displays numbered order badges (#1, #2, etc.) and teal directional connector arrows so you can see the flow order at a glance, along with a red ... indicator if the final box in the chain still has overflowing text.

    • Rich Formatting & Placeholder Cleanup: Bold, italics, colors, headings, lists, and spellcheck highlights now flow seamlessly across frames. Linking into a new box also automatically clears the default "Click to edit text" placeholder.
    • Easier Controls & Persistence: You can now link or unlink boxes anytime via the Text Box Format Ribbon or the right-click context menu (and deleting a middle box automatically heals the chain). Links also persist across Undo/Redo, page switches, and saved .opub files.

    • Bonus Fix (Ctrl+A / Cmd+A): Pressing Select All while inside a text box now highlights only the text in that box rather than selecting every element on the page.

    How to test:
    Please visit openpublisher.app and do a quick hard refresh (Ctrl+F5 on Windows/Linux or Cmd+Shift+R on Mac) to make sure your browser loads v5.21.0.

    Could you give it a try and let us know if it works the way you expect? We will leave this issue open for the next 48 hours so you have time to test it out. If we do not hear back within 48 hours, we will go ahead and close this issue as resolved, though you are always welcome to reopen it or drop a comment if you run into any edge cases!

    op-ContinuousRichTextFlowAndStoryChainsFix

     
  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 4 days ago

    Originally posted by: IcedQuinn

    This does work with a caveat: if text spills in to the linked box, then gets retracted, it is possible for the text box to lose its text control. This makes a future attempt to link it fail with an error that it must be linked to a text box. Double-clicking the box adds a new text field which makes it a text object again.

    Trying to link across pages also drops state. Clicking the box, then link, then clicking on page 2, will drop the tool so you cannot link to the next page.

     
  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 4 days ago

    Originally posted by: rmellis

    Hi @IcedQuinn, thank you for testing that so quickly and catching those two edge cases! It's helpful feedback:

    1. When spilled text retracted completely out of a linked frame, our cleanup check was mistakenly treating the newly emptied frame as a plain decorative box and stripping its text control, which caused subsequent link attempts to fail.

    2. Switching pages in the sidebar triggered a canvas deselect, which was prematurely cancelling the active linking tool before you could pick a target box on the next page.

    We have just pushed v5.21.2 live on openpublisher.app to fix both of these issues and make multi-page text flow seamless.

    What's fixed in v5.21.2:

    • Persistent Text Controls on Empty Boxes: Linked text boxes now keep their editable text control (contenteditable="true") even when all spilled text retracts back upstream, eliminating the false "Please select a text box to link to." error when re-linking or editing. Any existing frames that lost their text control will also self-heal automatically.

    • Cross-Page Linking & Live Multi-Page Reflow: Clicking Link on Page 1 and switching to another page in the sidebar (or clicking + Add Page) now preserves your active linking session so you can link frames across Page 1 -> Page 2 -> Page 3 without dropping the tool. Text now flows and retracts dynamically across pages even when target frames are off-screen.

    • Clickable Cross-Page Navigation Badges: Linked boxes that connect to another page now display clickable <- P# and #N -> P# badges on the selection overlay so you can jump directly between connected frames across pages with a single click.

    • Floating Delete Fix & Smart Deletion Dialog: We fixed a bug where the floating trash button on the selection toolbar could ignore clicks on linked frames, and added a Delete Linked Text Box prompt that lets you choose whether to Delete Selected Text Box (healing the remaining chain), Delete All Linked across all pages, or Leave Them Alone.

    How to test:
    Please do a quick hard refresh (Ctrl+F5 on Windows/Linux or Cmd+Shift+R on Mac) on

    https://openpublisher.app to make sure your browser pulls v5.21.2.

    Whenever you have a moment, please give cross-page linking and text retraction another try and let us know how it feels! As before, we will keep this issue open for the next 48 hours while you test things out, and if everything looks good (or if we do not hear back within 48 hours), we will close this out as resolved. Please let us know if you spot anything else!

    Page 1 Page 2
    Page 1 Page 2
     
  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 4 days ago

    Originally posted by: rmellis

    Hi @IcedQuinn, thanks for recording and sharing that clip!
    Seeing it happen in real time makes it much easier for us to pinpoint what is going on.

    From your video, we spotted two UI bugs that we are actively looking into right now:

    • Ribbon Tab Snapping Back: When a text box is active on the canvas and you click over to the Insert tab, an asynchronous selection/reflow UI update is firing right after and forcing the Ribbon to snap back to Text Box Tools.

    • <- P1 Navigation Badge & Off-Page Ghost Overlays: Clicking the <- P1 cross-page badge on Page 2 is being intercepted before the page switch can fire, which causes the badge to disappear and mistakenly renders the dashed outlines and connector arrows from Page 1's boxes (#1 -> #2) onto Page 2.

    A fix for both of these is currently in the works and on the way! We will keep this issue open and drop another update here as soon as the patch is live for you to test.

     
  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 4 days ago

    Originally posted by: rmellis

    Hi @IcedQuinn, thanks again for your patience and for sharing that video earlier! We have just pushed v5.21.5 live on openpublisher.app, which fixes both of the UI issues from your recording.

    What's fixed in v5.21.5:

    • Contextual Ribbon Tab Persistence: When a text box or other object is selected and you manually switch to a standard Ribbon tab like Insert or Home, your active tab choice is now preserved. Background selection syncs and canvas interactions will no longer snap the Ribbon back to Text Box Tools mid-workflow, while still automatically opening Text Box Tools whenever you select or insert a new element.

    • Clickable Cross-Page Navigation Badges: We elevated the cross-page navigation pills (<- P1, #N -> P#) and updated their pointer handlers so clicking them reliably jumps straight to the connected page without being intercepted by the canvas.

    • Eliminated Ghost Overlays: Multi-page text flow measurements are now isolated so off-page boxes from Page 1 no longer bleed through or draw ghost outlines and connector arrows onto Page 2.

    How to test:
    Please visit openpublisher.app and do a quick hard refresh (Ctrl+F5 on Windows/Linux or Cmd+Shift+R on Mac) so your browser loads v5.21.5.

    Whenever you get a chance, please give it another test and let us know if everything is working smoothly now! As usual, we will leave this issue open for the next 48 hours so you have time to try it out, and if we do not hear back within 48 hours, we will go ahead and close this out as resolved. Please let us know if you run into anything else!

     
  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 3 days ago

    Originally posted by: rmellis

    Hi @IcedQuinn, thanks again for recording that follow-up video! Seeing the exact cursor behavior and text notes helped us review both the story-packing behavior and the two UI quirks in the clip.

    First, to clarify what is happening with the text flow at 0:50 and 1:14:

    • Typing in Box #3 on Page 2 sending letters to Page 1 (1:14): Because a linked chain (#1 -> #2 -> #3) acts as a single continuous story, text always fills upstream frames first before spilling downstream. When Box #1 on Page 1 was resized larger at 1:03, all text retracted into Box #1 with empty room left at the bottom. Because Box #1 was no longer full, typing new characters into the chain (even when clicking inside Box #3 on Page 2) automatically packs those letters into the available space in Box #1 on Page 1 until #1 and #2 fill up again.

    • Pasting continuously inside a full box (0:50): When Box #1 is already full and you hold paste directly inside Box #1, the engine splits and flows the newly pasted text downstream into Box #2 and Page 2 on each paste event while keeping your active cursor inside Box #1.

    Second, we have just pushed v5.21.8 to https://openpublisher.app to fix the two UI issues shown in your recording:

    • External <- P1 Navigation Badge Placement (0:39): Previously, the top-left <- P1 badge sat just inside the editable text boundary, allowing the text cursor to intercept clicks. We have moved the <- P1 badge cleanly outside the top border of the text box with explicit pointer handling so clicking it reliably jumps straight back to Page 1.

    • Subtle Frame Guide on Empty Linked Boxes (1:08): When all text retracted out of Page 2 back into Page 1, the empty Box #3 had no visible border when deselected, making it hard to find on a blank page. Linked text boxes now display a subtle dashed teal outline on the canvas (hidden when printing) so empty frames remain easy to spot and click.

    How to test & next steps:
    Please do a quick hard refresh (Ctrl+F5 on Windows/Linux or Cmd+Shift+R on Mac) on https://openpublisher.app so your browser loads v5.21.8.

    We will leave this issue open for 48 hours so you can verify the badge navigation and frame guides. If everything looks good (or if we do not hear back within 48 hours), we will close Issue [#11] out as completed.

    If you run into any other bugs or have feature requests down the road, please open a new issue for each topic and include a brief written summary of the steps to reproduce alongside any recordings so we can track each item cleanly!

     

    Related

    Tickets: #11

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 3 days ago

    Originally posted by: IcedQuinn

    Text box linking seems to be working now.

    https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/90368fc8-4032-49fd-a28b-498c88bc845f

    • There's still a bit of click cycling to add text boxes; ex. having to click the ribbon back to insert, or click off on to nowhere.
    • Adding a text field still spits out a fixed position/size (DesignCraft and Scribus do a drag-to-size when placing, not sure what Publisher does)
    • Typing in to a text field and the input being eaten and sent somewhere else isn't great; Scribus has a "story editor" to show the whole text in a pop-up without dealing with the linking, but DesignCraft has the same behavior as Open Publisher now does.
    • I would kind of expect the screen to be moved to where the text is actually being input, as is how word processing et all works, but I'm not sure if that's standard in DTP, so I can't really flag that as a bug
     
  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 3 days ago

    Originally posted by: rmellis

    Hi @IcedQuinn,

    Since you mentioned not being sure how Microsoft Publisher handles these interactions, here is a quick rundown of how Publisher works compared to Scribus and DesignCraft:

    • Contextual Ribbon Placement: In Microsoft Publisher, when you select a text box and the Ribbon switches to the contextual Text Box Tools (Format) tab, Publisher actually keeps a Draw Text Box button right inside that contextual tab (next to the text linking controls) specifically so you do not have to keep switching back to the Insert tab when setting up a multi-box chain.
    • Typing in an Empty Downstream Box & Story Editing: Unlike Scribus, Microsoft Publisher does not use a separate pop-up Story Editor window; all editing happens live on the page canvas. Because a linked chain is a single continuous story thread, Publisher will not let text sit in Box 2 or Box 3 while Box 1 still has empty space. Instead, if you try to input text into an empty downstream box while an upstream box still has room, Publisher moves your active cursor and page view back to the end of the text in the upstream box where the characters are actually being placed.
    • Creating Boxes: Publisher uses a crosshair cursor where you can drag a box size (or click once to drop a default box), whereas Open Publisher uses instant one-click insertion on the canvas.

    Inspired by your feedback (and how Microsoft Publisher handles the contextual Ribbon and upstream cursor jumping), we just shipped v5.22.1 on https://openpublisher.app with two quality-of-life upgrades:

    • New Text Box Button in Text Box Tools & Cascaded Offset: We added a New Text Box button directly inside the contextual Text Box Tools Ribbon tab right next to Link and Unlink. You can now add and link multiple text boxes in a row without ever clicking back to the Insert tab or deselecting on the canvas. Even better, if you insert a new text box while an existing text box is selected on the current page, the new box automatically cascades by +24px horizontally and vertically within the page margins so consecutive boxes never stack directly on top of one another.

    • Automatic Upstream Page & Cursor Follow: If you click into an empty downstream linked box (such as Box #3 on Page 2) and start typing or pasting while an upstream box still has empty space available, Open Publisher now automatically switches your view to that upstream box's page, selects the box receiving the text, and places your active cursor right at the end of the story so the screen follows your input.

    How to test & next steps:
    Please do a quick hard refresh (Ctrl+F5 on Windows/Linux or Cmd+Shift+R on Mac) on https://openpublisher.app so your browser loads v5.22.1.

    We have added optional drag-to-size placement to our longer-term feature backlog for future evaluation, and with the new contextual New Text Box button, cascaded placement, and upstream auto-follow now live in v5.22.1, we will leave this issue open for 48 hours so you can give those workflow improvements a spin. If everything feels good (or if we do not hear back within 48 hours), we will go ahead and close this issue out as completed!

     

Log in to post a comment.