Menu

#4 Muxing of AVI with sound gives crappy results

open
nobody
None
5
2003-06-16
2003-06-16
No

hi,

if you try to mux an avi contains video _and_ sound
with an additional audio-tracks, than the audio-stream
from the AVI get's copied to the ogm-file. that's not
what i expected.

the sound from avi also get's played back, so i'm not
sure if the audio-stream just get's copied, or really
muxed in the ogm-container.

i _must_ add an audio-track when using oggmux, so i
guess you should strip off the sound from the avi file.

if you get it manged to import the sound from the avi
file correctly, that would be coolest.

Discussion

  • Dirk Knop

    Dirk Knop - 2003-06-16

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=498334

    This behaviour is intentional as noone complained about it -
    even better, some people use this way to mux ac3 into OGM.

    This behaviour will stay that way I guess...
    Regards
    Koepi

     
  • Dirk Knop

    Dirk Knop - 2003-06-16
    • status: open --> closed
     
  • Sven Köhler

    Sven Köhler - 2003-06-16

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=98598

    which behaviour is intentional?

    why _must_ i add audio-tracks, although the avi itself
    contains audio which is also copied? is it correctly copied
    and muxed into the ogm?
    if not, why isn't it stripped?

    ogg-mux also supports adding an ac3-wav, so i don't see any
    reason, why the audio of the avi is copied.

     
  • Sven Köhler

    Sven Köhler - 2003-06-16
    • status: closed --> open
     
  • Chris Wagner

    Chris Wagner - 2003-10-17

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=664907

    Why not just have a selection box "Keep exisitng AVI audio
    streams" || "Discard AVI audio streams". That's how I would
    do it.

     
  • Sven Köhler

    Sven Köhler - 2003-10-17

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=98598

    i guess ogg-mux doesn't even split the avi into video and
    audio-stream. so it is neither able to keep or strip the
    audio-stream not abled to convert the avi-audio stream into
    a proper ogm-audio stream

     

Log in to post a comment.