[Numpy-discussion] Learning "strides"

[Sasha <nd...@ma...>]

I don't know if this came from numarray or not, but for me as someone
who transitions from Numeric, the "strides" attribute to an ndarray is
a a new feature.  I've spend some time playing with it and there are
some properties that I dislike. Some of these undesired  properties
are probably bugs and easy to fix, but others require some discussion.

1. Negative strides:

>>> x =3D zeros(5)
>>> x.strides=3D (-4,)
>>> x
array([         0,         25,          0, -136009696, -136009536])

Looks like a bug.  PyArray_CheckStrides only checks for one end of the
buffer.  It is easy to fix that by disallowing negative strides, but I
think that would be wrong. In my view. the right sollution is to pass
offset to PyArray_CheckStrides and check for both ends of the buffer.=20
The later will change C-API.

2. Zero strides:

>>> x =3D arange(5)
>>> x.strides =3D 0
>>> x
array([0, 0, 0, 0, 0])
>>> x +=3D 1
>>> x
array([5, 5, 5, 5, 5])

These are somewhat puzzling properties unless you know the internals.
I believe ndarray with 0s in strides are quite useful and will follow
up with the description of the properties I would expect from them.

3.  "Fractional" strides:
I call "fractional" strides that are not a multiple of "itemsize".

>>> x =3D arange(5)
>>> x.strides =3D 3
>>> x
array([       0,      256,   131072, 50331648,        3])

I think these should be disallowed. It is just too easy to forget that
strides are given in bytes, not in elements.  Ideally rather than
checking for strides[i] % itemsize, I would  just make strides[i] to
be expressed in number of elements, not in bytes.  This can be done
without changing the way strides are stored internally - just multiply
by itemsize in
set_strides and divide in get_strides.  If strides attribute was not
introduced before numpy, this change should not cause any
compatibility problems.  If it has some history
of use, it may be possible to depricate "strides" (with a deprecation
warning) and
introduce a different attribute, say "steps", that will be expressed
in number of elements.