Re: [myhdl-list] MEP : Signal Containers

[G. A. S. <g.a...@gm...>]

I resonate with you because we both come from SW backgrounds.  Try to twist
your brain into resonance with the HW guys here, then from THAT perspective
you can effectively argue your points.

I feel that your posts present as seeming to think OO is the one true way;
and you're trying to jam it down their throats -- but without the
accomplishments to back it up.

I respect the methods of these guys who are really building large and
extremely complex designs -- and hope to start a discussion with them about
the value of OO techniques.  If they don't want to delve into these
techniques or if my ideas fall flat then I'm going to conclude that there
is something wrong with the approach... I may not reject the fundamental
OO->HW ideas but I'll realize I need to better understand the problems
before proceeding.


Cheers!
Andrew


On Sat, Jun 2, 2012 at 9:01 PM, Christopher Lozinski <
loz...@fr...> wrote:

> On 6/2/12 4:57 PM, G. Andrew Stone wrote:
> > I mean if there's no spark of interest in the community I do not
> > have the time to create the "mind-share"
> Everything you say totally resonates with me.  Every time I see your
> name, I read the posting carefully.  I cannot say that for all of the
> posters.   There really are different world views in this world.  No
> point arguing them.
>
> I also have little interest in evangelizing this stuff.   I just get too
> much crap for speaking my mind.  Actually I think it is really good to
> have different points of view.  And one needs not only software
> developers on a project but also marketing people who try to figure out
> how to simplify the technologies, not make them more complex.
> But others disagree.
>
> I am just grateful I have not been kicked off the mailing list.  I am
> pleased if I have stirred some discussion.
>
> Anyhow I have spoken my mind at
>
> http://wiki.myhdlclass.com:8080/
>
> I think you have a lot of good ideas to add.  I would love to see you
> edit that wiki.   Some day I may read through all your  email postings.
> May I copy them, at least this one, to the wiki under creative commons
> license?
>
> I will come back to implementing the code one day.  My belief is that if
> you get the right abstractions implementing the code is quite easy.  In
> fact complex code, is a sign of bad abstractions,
>
> FLAME SHIELD ON.
>
> never mind, not worth saying what I was about to say.
>
> We get so many transistors nowadays.  Let us use them to simplify the
> engineering cycle.
>
> --
> Regards
> Christopher Lozinski
>
> Check out my iPhone apps TextFaster and EmailFaster
> http://textfaster.com
>
> Expect a paradigm shift.
> http://MyHDLClass.com:8080
>
>