Menu

#621 Negative which should be positive

Babbage
wont-fix
nobody
None
2Critical
2024-08-12
2024-08-11
Steve Keen
No

I'm compiling data on Germany for a video, and the Weimar inflation generated a negative number in the change operator. See Attached. CSV file to follow.

1 Attachments

Discussion

  • Steve Keen

    Steve Keen - 2024-08-11

    CSV file

     
  • Steve Keen

    Steve Keen - 2024-08-11

    Also some peculiarities in the associated sheet.

     
  • High Performance Coder

    The change operator is working correctly. The data has a bodgy value for 1923 - 1E13. It's there in the CSV file. A number that huge couldn't be explained by the hyperinflation going on at that time, I don't think, assuming GDP was being denominated in marks.

     
  • High Performance Coder

    Actually maybe hyperinflation is the explanation. In Nov 2023, there were 4.21 E 12 marks to the US dollar.

    In 1924, the Weimar republic introduced a new currency (the RentenMark - translates as Pensioner's mark), which would have rebased the GDP series at that point. So you'll just have to remove the 1924 figure from your series, as it is not meaningful to compare with 1923.

     
  • High Performance Coder

    • status: open --> wont-fix
     

Log in to post a comment.