|
From: Gunter K. <gu...@pe...> - 2014-09-03 21:53:33
|
I'm no expert in these matters so I could be completely wrong but... ... Have you tried the integrate function instead of the combination of Laplace and ilt? I assume that this function knows about additional magic. It will return an ilt, though, if it cannot get farther than that. Kind regards, Gunter. On 3. September 2014 20:23:19 MESZ, Henry Baker <hb...@pi...> wrote: >Since I'm so dense, what would be the probability when the group has >size _one_; >i.e., choose a from the top 1% of A and choose b from the top 1% of B; >what is >the probability that a beats b ? > >BTW, I tried "laplace" and "ilt", but they didn't work. More >precisely, "laplace" >seemed to work ok, but "ilt" failed miserably. > >I also noticed that integrate(foo(x)*unit_step(x),x,minf,inf) isn't >smart enough >to simplify to integrate(foo(x),x,0,inf). > >At 11:00 AM 9/3/2014, Robert Dodier wrote: >>On 2014-09-03, Henry Baker <hb...@pi...> wrote: >> >>> On a particular Olympic sport, the abilities of any individual >>> in a population is normally distributed. >>> >>> Thus, for country A, with population Ap, mean Am, variance Av, >>> the abilities of the individuals follow a normal distribution. >>> >>> Clearly, each country will choose from the upper tail of the >>> distribution -- its highest 1%, for example. >>> >>> What is the probability that a 1% athlete from A will beat a 1% >>> athlete from B, given the population, mean and variance of each >country ? >> >>We are looking for P(ability(A) - ability(B) > 0) where ability(A) >>and ability(B) are Gaussian tail distributions. That is, not the >>entire bump (i.e. national population) but just the 1% who >>are sent to the games. I think Maxima can figure out the density of >>ability(A) - ability(B) exactly, but one must be careful with the >>limits of integration in the convolution since we are working with >>just the tails. Note sure if Maxima can then compute P(diff > 0) >>since that requires another integration. >> >>I worked on a related problem recently. For the record: >>http://maxima-solved.blogspot.com/2014/06/probability-density-of-sum-of-gamma-and.html >> >>> Now, suppose that we have a _group sport_ which requires a small >>> number (k) athletes, and that the performance of each country is >>> additive -- e.g., the gymnastics "team" medal, where the team is >>> of size k. >>> >>> Now, what is the probability that country A will beat country B ? >> >>Well, for k larger than a few, the group ability is nearly Gaussian >>even though the individual abilities are very non-Gaussian (via >>central limit theorem). So one can come up with an approximation >>more easily in the group case. >> >>Sounds like fun -- good luck. >> >>Robert Dodier > > >------------------------------------------------------------------------------ >Slashdot TV. >Video for Nerds. Stuff that matters. >http://tv.slashdot.org/ >_______________________________________________ >Maxima-discuss mailing list >Max...@li... >https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/maxima-discuss -- Diese Nachricht wurde von meinem Mobiltelefon mit Kaiten Mail gesendet. |