Menu

#12 [0:52:40] "It is incredible how stupid these people are"

open
Statement (11)
5
2011-02-12
2011-02-12
No

Linus doesn't like SVN and thinks that its developers make the wrong architectural choices. So why is it still the standard software code management tool offered by SourceForge?

Discussion

  • Najate

    Najate - 2011-02-14

    This is an good question, it is true when we open Sourceforge we notice that the SCM tool is SVN, but here's a link that shows that Sourceforge supports Git and other SCM:
    https://sourceforge.net/apps/trac/sourceforge/wiki/What%20is%20Source%20Code%20Management
    but why ? i think it is a question of centralization... and more control
    what do you think?

     
  • laurian choain

    laurian choain - 2011-02-14

    good question, a quick search on google doesn't give any answer or hint... Any ideas guys?

     
  • johndoe983

    johndoe983 - 2011-02-14

    Maybe it's because SVN was developped in 2000 and Git in 2005. Also people prefer to develop with SVN because they know it well

     
  • Ruxandra Teodorescu

    This is a consumer behavior topic. I think the answer could be that people have habits. They are getting use to the things they use for a long time, and in this case if the system is successful they won't risk at doing something else.
    The change will be considered only if they would see a malfunction or loss.

     
  • Matthijs den Besten

    Paul David has written on the issue of getting stuck with a particular technology: "Clio and the economics of QWERTY - see http://www.jstor.org/pss/1805621 - but note that Linus also makes some comments on sourceforge himself at the end of his talk.

     
  • laurian choain

    laurian choain - 2011-02-15

    indeed he says that sourceforge missed the point when focusing on performance for branching, and adds that's not the thing they should be focusing on, but on merging however they certainly have other things they are proud of haven't they? it might be that SVN isn't that bad at all in the end, but I doubt we can discuss this point without using it...

     
  • Najate

    Najate - 2011-02-17

    j'ai trouvé des articles qui parlent de l'utilisation de Git en local, et SVN comme serveur central ce qui permet de passer vers Git pas à pas, sans perdre le control...
    Je trouve que c'est très intelligent d'essayer de profiter des points forts de Git dans la distribution et des points forts de SVN dans la centralisation...
    http://blog.courtine.org/2010/10/12/allons-un-peu-plus-loin-avec-git-svn/

     

Log in to post a comment.