Menu

#49 Suggestion for ID3 problems

closed
nobody
None
5
2005-07-12
2004-11-26
Anonymous
No

Also read
http://www.gadgetguy.de/index.php/2004/11#Podcasting__ID3_tag_incosistency

I'm using iPodder to fetch my podcasts, and it works
nicely with iTunes. One thing that's missing though is
the ability to tell which podcasts are new. iPodder
puts everything into separate playlists, and I have
written about the problems with ID3 tags recently.

So, here is a suggestions: why can't iPodder create one
more playlist that serves as a kind of log for
retrieved files? Name it "iPodder downloads", and link
the files in there, too.

It would also be nice to have iPodder set the ID3 tags
in the process - define a naming scheme in each feed
properties tab, and there are your perfect tags.
Variables could include the original date and time,
retrieval date and time, feed title, file name etc..
The text variables could be trimmed down to a certain
number of chars, so you could do stuff like "20041126
ITC Human Nature" for one of the latest IT
Conversations, for example.

If the feed creators can't come up with decent tagging
schemes (and it's unlikely that they'll all subdue to
the same scheme, about as unlikely that this scheme
would appeal to all listeners), the aggregator is
probably the best way to fix this.

So, what's the first aggregator to come up with a
flexible way to re-write and re-map ID3 tags in podcasts?

Discussion

  • Frank Koehntopp

    Frank Koehntopp - 2004-11-26

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=603158

    Sorry - forgot to login - frank@koehntopp.com

     
  • Venrooy

    Venrooy - 2005-02-10

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=1120007

    This is still not handled that great in iPodder. Marked it
    as a feature request.

     
  • Venrooy

    Venrooy - 2005-02-10
    • labels: 685528 -->
    • milestone: 445533 -->
     
  • Venrooy

    Venrooy - 2005-07-12
    • status: open --> closed
     
  • Venrooy

    Venrooy - 2005-07-12

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=1120007

    Redefining the ID tag is possible in the latest version (v2.1)
    - Ticket closed.

     

Log in to post a comment.