Menu

#174 chassis identify

version-1.8.13
closed-fixed
None
5
2013-07-06
2013-01-15
No

the chassis identify defaults without any arguments are undefined
identify_data.force_on may be undefined

question not answered: the default of interval 15 with no argument in description. is it standard remote behaviour when zero interval is specified?

Discussion

  • Ales Ledvinka

    Ales Ledvinka - 2013-01-15
     
  • Zdenek Styblik

    Zdenek Styblik - 2013-01-16

    NACK. Notice, identify_data isn't used in request if no input is given by user. I say this can be closed as 'Invalid', because there is no bug/problem to be fixed.

    To answer your question about default 15s interval; this is given by IPMI specification. Yes, it should be standard remote behaviour.

     
  • Zdenek Styblik

    Zdenek Styblik - 2013-01-16
    • assigned_to: nobody --> stybla
    • milestone: --> version-1.8.12
     
  • Zdenek Styblik

    Zdenek Styblik - 2013-01-16
    • status: open --> open-accepted
     
  • Ales Ledvinka

    Ales Ledvinka - 2013-01-16

    except the arg == NULL, rsp != NULL, ccode>0 to hit the

    if ahead of lprintf(LOG_WARNING, "Chassis may not support Force Identify On\n")

     
  • Zdenek Styblik

    Zdenek Styblik - 2013-01-16

    Right indeed. Suggested fix below. btw I don't think it will be undefined, but rather some random value.

    struct \{
    uint8\_t interval = 0;
    uint8\_t force\_on = 0;
    \} identify\_data;
    
     
  • Ales Ledvinka

    Ales Ledvinka - 2013-01-16

    the proposed fix + removal of the assignment past the initialization.

     
  • Ales Ledvinka

    Ales Ledvinka - 2013-01-16

    committed to cvs

     
  • Ales Ledvinka

    Ales Ledvinka - 2013-01-16
    • status: open-accepted --> closed-fixed
     

Log in to post a comment.

MongoDB Logo MongoDB