[Geotools-devel] Filter spec and FeatureId

[Jesse E. <je...@re...>]

Hi,

I've been browsing through the filter spec and to my dismay have  
learned that the following is not legal:

<Filter>
	<Or>
		<BBox> some box </BBox>
		<FeatureId fid="fid" />
	</Or>
</Filter>

To be compliant with the spec it is supposed to be:

<Filter>
	<Or>
		<BBox> some box </BBox>
	</Or>
	<FeatureId fid="fid" />
</Filter>


We also can not do the following:

<Filter>
	<Not>
		<FeatureId fid="fid"/>
	</Not>
</Filter>


Our filter implementation allows both so we can't interoperate  
properly with others because we can make illegal documents....

Looking for comments on what should be done here.

Jesse