Menu

#401 Replace MD5 file digest with modern hash function

open
nobody
2017-05-18
2015-04-20
No

Use MD5 as download digest checksum should come to end. Perhaps replacing MD5 digest with SHA2-512 check sum (openssl sha512 command for example produce those). If changing this takes long time perhaps SHA3 should be consider as it should be ready for "production" soon.

Discussion

  • Zangune

    Zangune - 2015-04-20

    Greetings, SHA1 checksum is provided in addiction, yet.
    My opinion is most of the times using checksums is paranoid.

     
    • Starikov Sergey

      Starikov Sergey - 2015-05-06

      My opinion is most of the times using checksums is paranoid.

      But sometimes checking sum practice for example helps to discover, that upstream re-released distribution whithout changing version.

      And one more from my practice: SF mirroring is not always ehough reliable.
      Once I've missed much time trying to debug corrupted image of System Rescue CD.

       
  • TPS

    TPS - 2017-05-15

    It'd be great to deprecate SHA1 outright, as well, for @ least SHA256, but SHA512 & SHA3, as well.

     
  • Tom Spettigue

    Tom Spettigue - 2017-05-18

    I think SHA256 should be the standard that gets centered around, as the industry has generally moved in that direction. I don't think I've ever seen a SHA3 hash out in the wild by anyone, and as far as I can tell, there may be no practical advantage over SHA2 algorithms.

     

    Last edit: Tom Spettigue 2017-05-18

Log in to post a comment.

MongoDB Logo MongoDB