Menu

#40 Trailing punctuation shouldn't be included on URLs

FlexWiki
open
nobody
3
2004-10-03
2004-10-03
No

(This bug has been transcribed from FlexWiki.BugReport.
It was originally reported by Mike Schinkel on 7/3/2004)

When entering urls, you can't use any punctuation at
the end of a url because it gets included inside the <a
href>. Either it should sense invalid chars at the end of
the url or there should be a way to explicitly end the url.

It seems safe that if there is any of [.,;?!]... heck, any
single non-alphaNumeric followed by a space, that
character should not be included in the link created (if
you really need it in your link, you can %20 the space). -
- YarkoT

Discussion

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous - 2004-10-03
    • priority: 5 --> 3
     
  • Jonathan Tappan

    Jonathan Tappan - 2005-02-18

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=26196

    That may make sense for http:, but what about other
    protocols? The wiki engine can't reasonably be expected to
    know the correct syntax for file: (OS-specific) or gopher: or
    foo:

     
  • Bart Fibrich

    Bart Fibrich - 2005-10-27

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=1124145

    Tested on build 1.8.0.1695
    Bugs still present.

    Test :
    Create a topic.
    Add a url

    http://www.flexwiki.com;

    The link will contain the comma and fail to get the page.

     
  • Bart Fibrich

    Bart Fibrich - 2005-10-27

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=1124145

    Tested on build 1.8.0.1695
    Bugs still present.

    Test :
    Create a topic.
    Add a url

    http://www.flexwiki.com;

    The link will contain the comma and fail to get the page.

     

Log in to post a comment.