From: Jonathan W. <jw...@ph...> - 2008-11-24 23:33:07
|
Hi Francois > > > SVN r1451: Jack doesn't start any more. The port cash probably has to be > > > implemented in the motu code. > > > > But the port cache was only added in r1452. r1451 contained only an FCP > > fixup for the FA-101 and this shouldn't affect MOTUs because we don't use > > FCPs. > > It was r1451 of course. Sorry for this typo mistake. ??? So what is it: 1) r1451 is the first revision which broke in this way? 2) r1452 is the first revision to break in this way? If (1) it means the port cache code has nothing to do with the problem because it was only added in r1452 (meaning the "typo" was the mention of the port cache feature). If instead it was option 2 (ie: the "typo" was the mention of r1451 rather than r1452) then the port cache code might be implicated, even though at present I cannot really see how. Sorry for the misunderstanding with this. Maybe it's completely obvious and I'm too tired to see it right now. :-) > > One thought: what jackd revision are you using at present? There have > > been some broken jack1 releases recently. Similarly for jack2 from what > > I hear. > > I use r1448 with last (corrected) jack1 and jack2. Ok, thanks - it was worth checking. > Note I didn't experience the RT bug before updating to the last jack1 with > the corrected backend. Which RT bug was that? > > > Anyway, ffado (r1448 at last) is in very good shape, better than it always > > > was. > > > > This is good news - we must be on the right track. > > Hmm, I probably spoke too quickly. Sometimes, my system completely hang > without reason, except a unusual amount of xrun on Transport jump just > before. It's hard to say much based on the above, but it sounds like this is more related to the generic ffado/jack layer than the MOTU-specific code. Regards jonathan |