Menu

#8 No version conflict warning for binary files

open
None
8
2007-06-23
2007-05-10
No

CURE does not provide any hint if conflicting versions of binary files are uploaded.

- A uploads V1
- B downloads V1
- A makes changes and uploads V2a
- B makes changes and uploads V2b (counted as V3 in CURE)

There is no warning for B that A's changes have been lost.

In fact, I think that CURE in some cases won't be able to detect if there are version conflicts as access to a document might not always be through CURE, but rather by email, USB stick etc.

Solution idea (from Till):
How about including a note in the save page dialogue that informs the user when he tries to upload a document that he has not yet seen in the newest version?
--> yes, this is a must, I think

I also thought about having warnings whenever a user updates a page (e.g., turning the title of the page red for all users who are currently viewing the page).
--> synchronous information is always very useful. Should not be too disturbing, e.g. do not change the page layout

Discussion

  • Peter Tandler

    Peter Tandler - 2007-05-10
    • priority: 5 --> 8
    • summary: Now version conflict warning for binary files --> No version conflict warning for binary files
     
  • Groovy Turtle

    Groovy Turtle - 2007-06-23
    • assigned_to: nobody --> schuemm
     

Log in to post a comment.