From: E.L. W. <eg...@sc...> - 2004-07-23 20:05:41
|
On IRC I saw an interesting commit related to an SSSR finding algorithm... I've got some remarks and a question. To start with the question: what's the difference between the old (current) SSSR algorithm, and the new code added to CVS by zzzgggrrr (=uli?)? Is it faster, or more correct, or? Ok, here are the remarks... - The build.xml is not updated in CVS to include the new jar. - The new source files don't have the a license statement, Copyritht CDK etc - They also do not have JavaDoc - It seems that the old code moved to a new class (FiguerasSSSRFinder), which should be mentioned in the ChangeLog under "API Change". This is very important! - There should be an entry in the ChangeLog anyway - The source files should state that they @cdk.builddepend and @cdk.depend on the new ja - The new classes do not state to be in the standard module, but are compiled with the compile-standard task... this indicates some dependency on the new code... where does that come from? I do not have time to look at all these things, but I hope they can be solved soon... Egon |