|
From: Doug C. <cu...@ap...> - 2008-02-29 23:54:43
|
Ning Li wrote: >> You've switched to counter-clockwise replication, but I think that's > > Oops, I always used clockwise replication. :) Just to be clear: when a new document D arrives, the question is what nodes on the ring do we send it to? The N clockwise (greater) or counterclockwise from (less than) D? The most recent messages assume counter-clockwise (less than). A document between C and D would be in the indexes on nodes A B and C. The Dynamo paper says "clockwise", but I think that direction makes things more confusing and that we should instead use counterclockwise. Note that the index at node C contains documents in range C-F, three nodes clockwise, but the Dynamo paper uses the term clockwise when talking about assigning instances to nodes, not the range that each node contains. Are we in agreement about this? Doug |