Avisynth rev. 2 / Bugs / #158 Resizers crash Avisynth on certain sizes and clip formats

gzarkadas - 2005-09-06

Logged In: YES
user_id=1301375

# Several resize statements below (all commented out) crash
Avisynth
# The message box "Unrecognised exception" appears for a
fraction of a second
# (just enough to read this message or less; in the later
case only a part of the dialog borders may show
# but this is probably an eye impression due to the very
small times involved)
# and then the video rendering application (VirtualDub
1.5.10 (build 18289 / release) in our case) silently dies.

# YV12 clip (mpeg4) 360 x 288 pixels [(90x4) x (72x4)],
progressive, 24fps
ci_v = DirectShowSource("c:\shared\cvs\docs\media\circle.avi")
# YUY2 clip
ci_y = ci_v.ConvertToYUY2()
# RGB clip
ci_r = ci_v.ConvertToRGB()

# RGB

bl1 = ci_r.BilinearResize(359, 287) # ok
bl1a = ci_r.BilinearResize(358, 287) # ok
bl1b = ci_r.BilinearResize(359, 286) # ok
bl2 = ci_r.BilinearResize(358, 286) # ok

bc1 = ci_r.BicubicResize(359, 287) # ok
bc1a = ci_r.BicubicResize(358, 287) # ok
bc1b = ci_r.BicubicResize(359, 286) # ok
bc2 = ci_r.BicubicResize(358, 286) # ok

lz1 = ci_r.LanczosResize(359, 287) # ok
lz1a = ci_r.LanczosResize(358, 287) # ok
lz1b = ci_r.LanczosResize(359, 286) # ok
lz2 = ci_r.LanczosResize(358, 286) # ok

l41 = ci_r.Lanczos4Resize(359, 287) # ok
l41a = ci_r.Lanczos4Resize(358, 287) # ok
l41b = ci_r.Lanczos4Resize(359, 286) # ok
l42 = ci_r.Lanczos4Resize(358, 286) # ok

# YUY2

# bl3 = ci_y.BilinearResize(359, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (w odd)
bl3a = ci_y.BilinearResize(358, 287) # ok: w a multiple of 2
# bl3b = ci_y.BilinearResize(359, 286) # this crashes
Avisynth (w odd)
bl4 = ci_y.BilinearResize(358, 286) # ok: w a multiple of 2

# bc3 = ci_y.BicubicResize(359, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (w odd)
bc3a = ci_y.BicubicResize(358, 287) # ok: w a multiple of 2
# bc3b = ci_y.BicubicResize(359, 286) # this crashes
Avisynth (w odd)
bc4 = ci_y.BicubicResize(358, 286) # ok: w a multiple of 2

# lz3 = ci_y.LanczosResize(359, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (w odd)
lz3a = ci_y.LanczosResize(358, 287) # ok: w a multiple of 2
# lz3b = ci_y.LanczosResize(359, 286) # this crashes
Avisynth (w odd)
lz4 = ci_y.LanczosResize(358, 286) # ok: w a multiple of 2

# l43 = ci_y.Lanczos4Resize(359, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (w odd)
l43a = ci_y.Lanczos4Resize(358, 287) # ok: w a multiple of 2
# l43b = ci_y.Lanczos4Resize(359, 286) # this crashes
Avisynth (w odd)
l44 = ci_y.Lanczos4Resize(358, 286) # ok: w a multiple of 2

# YV12

# bl5 = ci_v.BilinearResize(359, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (w,h odd)
# bl5a = ci_v.BilinearResize(356, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (h odd)
# bl6 = ci_v.BilinearResize(358, 286) # this crashes
Avisynth (w not a multiple of 4)
bl6a = ci_v.BilinearResize(356, 286) # ok: w a multiple of 4
# bl6b = ci_v.BilinearResize(358, 284) # this crashes
Avisynth (w not a multiple of 4)
bl7 = ci_v.BilinearResize(356, 284) # ok: w a multiple of 4

# bc5 = ci_v.BicubicResize(359, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (w,h odd)
# bc6 = ci_v.BicubicResize(358, 286) # this crashes
Avisynth (w not a multiple of 4)
bc6a = ci_v.BicubicResize(356, 286) # ok: w a multiple of 4
# bc6b = ci_v.BicubicResize(358, 284) # this crashes
Avisynth (w not a multiple of 4)
bc7 = ci_v.BicubicResize(356, 284) # ok: w a multiple of 4

# lz5 = ci_v.LanczosResize(359, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (w,h odd)
# lz6 = ci_v.LanczosResize(358, 286) # this crashes
Avisynth (w not a multiple of 4)
lz6a = ci_v.LanczosResize(356, 286) # ok: w a multiple of 4
# lz6b = ci_v.LanczosResize(358, 284) # this crashes
Avisynth (w not a multiple of 4)
lz7 = ci_v.LanczosResize(356, 284) # ok: w a multiple of 4

# l45 = ci_v.Lanczos4Resize(359, 287) # this crashes
Avisynth (w,h odd)
# l46 = ci_v.Lanczos4Resize(358, 286) # this crashes
Avisynth (w not a multiple of 4)
l46a = ci_v.Lanczos4Resize(356, 286) # ok: w a multiple of 4
# l46b = ci_v.Lanczos4Resize(358, 284) # this crashes
Avisynth (w not a multiple of 4)
l47 = ci_v.Lanczos4Resize(356, 284) # ok: w a multiple of 4

return BlankClip.SubTitle("All went well")

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

gzarkadas - 2005-09-06

priority: 5 --> 7
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Wilbert Dijkhof - 2005-09-07

Logged In: YES
user_id=591008

Which avs version did you use? Btw, i know that also v2.56
rc1 has such problems (ie not giving the right error
exceptions), but VDub/VDubMod shouldn't close itself.

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Ian Brabham - 2005-09-07

Logged In: YES
user_id=673887

message box "Unrecognised exception"

Implies 2.5.5 or an early 2.5.6. All recent 2.5.6 now
explicitly decodes what was Unrecognised exceptions.

My copy of the current 256RC1 handles this correctly.

IanB

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Ian Brabham - 2005-09-07

Logged In: YES
user_id=673887

message box "Unrecognised exception"

Implies 2.5.5 or an early 2.5.6. All recent 2.5.6 now
explicitly decodes what was Unrecognised exceptions.

My copy of the current 256RC1 handles this correctly.

IanB

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

gzarkadas - 2005-09-07

Logged In: YES
user_id=1301375

Version 2.55
File version of avisynth.dll is 2,5,5,0

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Ian Brabham - 2005-09-07

priority: 7 --> 5

status: open --> closed
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Ian Brabham - 2005-09-07

assigned_to: nobody --> ianb1957
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Ian Brabham - 2005-09-07

Logged In: YES
user_id=673887

Known bug in 2.55. Compiler bug cause Error Report code to
GPF

Try 2.5.6 RC1

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

gzarkadas - 2005-09-08

Logged In: YES
user_id=1301375

Still though, I have the feeling that instead of throwing an
"Unrecognised exception" it would be better to explicitly
check input size and clip colorspace and inform the user
that it passed incompatible parameters to the resize function.
Note: I haven't checked 2.5.6 RC1 (I prefer to work with
production versions only), so if it does check the
parameters simply ignore this comment.

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Ian Brabham - 2005-09-13

Logged In: YES
user_id=673887

This is exactly what the code is written to do, unfortunatly
due to compiler bugs while trying to report the script error a
GPF happens and while trying to report the GPF another
GPF happens hence only the last generic handler survives
and you get the "Unrecognised exception".

Please check the changelist for the latest CVS version for
any bug you find having been already fixed. Report them only
if they still occur in the newest version.

2.5.6 is about to be the production version, I suggest you test
all your favourite bugs NOW! and report them so the final
release has them fixed.

If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:

Resizers crash Avisynth on certain sizes and clip formats

Group

Searches

Help

#158 Resizers crash Avisynth on certain sizes and clip formats

Discussion