Menu

#204 "E-mail this user" errors not labeled well

Moved_to_Bugzilla
closed
5
2004-09-03
2002-08-25
Mike Brown
No

When viewing a User:Foo entry, there is a link
labeled "E-mail this user", leading to
http://www.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?
title=Special:Emailuser&target=Foo.

The page at that URL insists that you are not logged in,
even if you really are.

Discussion

  • Toby Bartels

    Toby Bartels - 2002-08-26

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=573955

    This seems to be a bug in the documentation. Do you have an email
    address of your own listed in your user preferences? If not, then you
    can't email other users.

     
  • Mike Brown

    Mike Brown - 2002-08-26

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=371366

    Ah, that would be it. I thought it was talking about the email
    address that I provided when I created my Wikipedia account.

    However, if you have no address in your preferences, there is
    still a big bold heading on the page in question that says Not
    Logged In .. which is incorrect. The page should probably
    have a more accurate heading, and should include a link to
    the user's preferences page with a note that that is where
    they need to go to set their email address.

     
  • Mike Brown

    Mike Brown - 2002-08-26
    • summary: "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional --> "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional
     
  • Brion Vibber

    Brion Vibber - 2002-08-27
    • summary: "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional --> "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional
     
  • Brion Vibber

    Brion Vibber - 2002-08-27

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=446709

    There's definitely something odd going on -- I tried going
    to my own user page (user:Brion_VIBBER) and clicked on
    "E-mail this user"... and I also got the "Not logged in"
    message.

    This rather confused me, as I was both logged in and had a
    valid e-mail address in my preferences... or so I thought.
    When I go to Preferences, the e-mail address field is blank!

    Now I *know* I had it filled in previously, as I was testing
    the "mail password" function last week or so. But now it's
    blank; checking the database confirms that my user_email
    field is empty.

    So, two problems:
    1) My e-mail address vanished from the database!
    2) There's still an 'e-mail this user' link for a user with
    no e-mail address.

     
  • Lee Daniel Crocker

    • summary: "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional --> "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional
     
  • Lee Daniel Crocker

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=3076

    I noticed my e-mail address vanishing unexpectedly once as
    well. I also found a browser bug in Galeon that /shows/ it
    as blank in the preferences form even though it's being sent
    correctly in the form's source. So it might be something
    like going to your preferences to set some other flag causes
    it to present that field as empty even though it's been
    filled in, then saving the form empties it.

     
  • Brion Vibber

    Brion Vibber - 2002-08-28
    • summary: "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional --> "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional
     
  • Brion Vibber

    Brion Vibber - 2002-08-28

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=446709

    Yeah, looks like it may be a Gecko or related bug; I'm
    running Mozilla 1.1b. After filling in the e-mail field in
    my prefs and submitting, the prefs form comes up anew. The
    field is now displayed blank, but the source is correct:

    Your e-mail: <input type=text name="wpEmail"
    value="blablablabla" size=20><br>

    Saving of course saves the blank password.

    It also displays properly in MSIE... saving the HTML to a
    file and loading it again, the address does display in Moz.

    Ahhhh, wait. If I clear the Wikipedia login out of my
    "stored passwords", everything works fine. Tell it to save
    the password on the login form, and *poof* empty e-mail
    field in my prefs again. Definitely related to the form
    management; I guess it's somehow confusing the two forms?

    Workaround: don't trust Mozilla's password management; use
    the "remember password across sessions" checkbox instead.

     
  • Brion Vibber

    Brion Vibber - 2003-03-09
    • summary: "E-mail this user" page nonfunctional --> "E-mail this user" errors not labeled well
    • assigned_to: lcrocker --> nobody
     
  • Lee Daniel Crocker

    • summary: "E-mail this user" errors not labeled well --> "E-mail this user" errors not labeled well
    • assigned_to: nobody --> lcrocker
     
  • Timwi

    Timwi - 2004-09-03
    • milestone: --> Moved_to_Bugzilla
    • summary: "E-mail this user" errors not labeled well --> "E-mail this user" errors not labeled well
    • status: open --> closed
     
  • Timwi

    Timwi - 2004-09-03

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=734240

    This bug has been migrated to MediaZilla:
    http://bugzilla.wikipedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=356
    Please leave additional comments or attachments there.

     

Log in to post a comment.