Hello,
Thanks for your answer, but because it was not.
gmx no longer seems to work, I have switched to web.de and it works.
simulation with the presence of 1 week recording, I've now created with LUA.
Kind regards,
Hans Dehne
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
I use linknx on my synology ds207+.
I've tried several smtp servers, but I can not send email using "send-email" linknx action.
An idea ?
Here is a part of linknx log :
2010-02-06 13:40:54 Action: Execute SendEmailAction: to=XXXXX subject=TEST
2010-02-06 13:40:54 EmailGateway: EmailGateway: Done 0 =>
Kind regards,
Ben
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
in the past it worked without any problems with my strato.de account. I use the Email function only for alarm messages an today I had an alarm that was not send. When I changed to web.de its working only sometimes!
in the meantime i found out, why the Email function worked sometimes with web.de and sometimes not. I logged the communication with smtp.web.de with the tool "tcpdump":
thanks for your reply. Web.de uses SMTP-Authentication OR "POP before SMTP". But on my installation the SMTP-Authentication of linknx don't function at web.de and strato.de either. I have the actual versions of linknx (0.0.1.27-2) and libsmtp (1.0.4-2). Can you give me a hint, where I can search for this problem?
Chris
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
What libEsmtp are you using. Did you compile it yourself (with what options)? Do you use a precompiled binary? Where does-it come from?
I looked at your tcpdump and at the libEsmtp source code and it looks like if libEsmtp was compiled without the authentication support.
Regards,
Jean-François
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
Its running on a WRT54GS with White Russian 0.9 and X-Wrt Webinterface. Its possible, that the email function didn't work at all with this combiation, I don't know. Maybe its a problem with this combiation.
Best regards,
Chris
If you would like to refer to this comment somewhere else in this project, copy and paste the following link:
Hello Jeff,
I observe that the email is not sent.
I have tested it in debian and ubuntu.
Is it possible to install a presence simulation?
Regards,
Hans
Hallo Hans,
I had the same problem with the mail. Just put in the ip adress of the smtp server, port 25 (in linknx.xml). It worked for me.
Kind regards,
Rene Jansen
Hello,
Thanks for your answer, but because it was not.
gmx no longer seems to work, I have switched to web.de and it works.
simulation with the presence of 1 week recording, I've now created with LUA.
Kind regards,
Hans Dehne
Hi all,
I use linknx on my synology ds207+.
I've tried several smtp servers, but I can not send email using "send-email" linknx action.
An idea ?
Here is a part of linknx log :
2010-02-06 13:40:54 Action: Execute SendEmailAction: to=XXXXX subject=TEST
2010-02-06 13:40:54 EmailGateway: EmailGateway: Done 0 =>
Kind regards,
Ben
Hello,
I did the same on debian. I have the email account from at gmx web.de
changed and it works.
Hans
Hello,
in the past it worked without any problems with my strato.de account. I use the Email function only for alarm messages an today I had an alarm that was not send. When I changed to web.de its working only sometimes!
Any ideas?
Hello,
in the meantime i found out, why the Email function worked sometimes with web.de and sometimes not. I logged the communication with smtp.web.de with the tool "tcpdump":
root@knxweb:~$ tcpdump host smtp.web.de -s 255 -X tcpdump: verbose output suppressed, use -v or -vv for full protocol decode listening on br0, link-type EN10MB (Ethernet), capture size 255 bytes 20:48:55.767050 IP 192.168.178.220.1035 > smtp-ha.web.de.25: S 749925158:749925158(0) win 5840 <mss 1460,nop,nop,sackOK,nop,ws 0x0000: 4500 0034 c513 4000 4006 6845 c0a8 b2dc E..4..@.@.hE.... 0x0010: d948 c09d 040b 0019 2cb2 f326 0000 0000 .H......,..&.... 0x0020: 8002 16d0 26e0 0000 0204 05b4 0101 0402 ....&........... 0x0030: 0103 0300 .... 20:48:55.798410 IP smtp-ha.web.de.25 > 192.168.178.220.1035: S 4234356474:4234356474(0) ack 749925159 win 5840 <mss 1380,nop,n 0x0000: 4500 0034 0000 4000 3706 3659 d948 c09d E..4..@.7.6Y.H.. 0x0010: c0a8 b2dc 0019 040b fc63 26fa 2cb2 f327 .........c&.,..' 0x0020: 8012 16d0 03c1 0000 0204 0564 0101 0402 ...........d.... 0x0030: 0103 0300 .... 20:48:55.799029 IP 192.168.178.220.1035 > smtp-ha.web.de.25: . ack 1 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 0028 c514 4000 4006 6850 c0a8 b2dc E..(..@.@.hP.... 0x0010: d948 c09d 040b 0019 2cb2 f327 fc63 26fb .H......,..'.c&. 0x0020: 5010 16d0 443c 0000 P...D<.. 20:48:55.835557 IP smtp-ha.web.de.25 > 192.168.178.220.1035: P 1:76(75) ack 1 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 0073 3656 4000 3706 ffc3 d948 c09d E..s6V@.7....H.. 0x0010: c0a8 b2dc 0019 040b fc63 26fb 2cb2 f327 .........c&.,..' 0x0020: 5018 16d0 f950 0000 3232 3020 736d 7470 P....P..220.smtp 0x0030: 3037 2e77 6562 2e64 6520 4553 4d54 5020 07.web.de.ESMTP. 0x0040: 5745 422e 4445 2056 342e 3131 3023 3331 WEB.DE.V4.110#31 0x0050: 3420 5361 742c 2030 3620 4d61 7220 3230 4.Sat,.06.Mar.20 0x0060: 3130 2032 303a 3438 3a35 3520 2b30 3130 10.20:48:55.+010 0x0070: 300d 0a 0.. 20:48:55.836056 IP 192.168.178.220.1035 > smtp-ha.web.de.25: . ack 76 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 0028 c515 4000 4006 684f c0a8 b2dc E..(..@.@.hO.... 0x0010: d948 c09d 040b 0019 2cb2 f327 fc63 2746 .H......,..'.c'F 0x0020: 5010 16d0 43f1 0000 P...C... 20:48:55.836935 IP 192.168.178.220.1035 > smtp-ha.web.de.25: P 1:14(13) ack 76 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 0035 c516 4000 4006 6841 c0a8 b2dc E..5..@.@.hA.... 0x0010: d948 c09d 040b 0019 2cb2 f327 fc63 2746 .H......,..'.c'F 0x0020: 5018 16d0 3fee 0000 4548 4c4f 206b 6e78 P...?...EHLO.knx 0x0030: 7765 620d 0a web.. 20:48:55.868505 IP smtp-ha.web.de.25 > 192.168.178.220.1035: . ack 14 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 0028 3657 4000 3706 000e d948 c09d E..(6W@.7....H.. 0x0010: c0a8 b2dc 0019 040b fc63 2746 2cb2 f334 .........c'F,..4 0x0020: 5010 16d0 43e4 0000 ff60 0000 0046 P...C....`...F 20:48:55.869786 IP smtp-ha.web.de.25 > 192.168.178.220.1035: P 76:205(129) ack 14 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 00a9 3658 4000 3706 ff8b d948 c09d E...6X@.7....H.. 0x0010: c0a8 b2dc 0019 040b fc63 2746 2cb2 f334 .........c'F,..4 0x0020: 5018 16d0 497b 0000 3235 302d 736d 7470 P...I{..250-smtp 0x0030: 3037 2e77 6562 2e64 6520 4865 6c6c 6f20 07.web.de.Hello. 0x0040: 6b6e 7877 6562 205b 3933 2e31 3331 2e33 knxweb.[93.131.3 0x0050: 312e 3231 305d 0d0a 3235 302d 5349 5a45 1.210]..250-SIZE 0x0060: 2036 3939 3230 3432 370d 0a32 3530 2d50 .69920427..250-P 0x0070: 4950 454c 494e 494e 470d 0a32 3530 2d41 IPELINING..250-A 0x0080: 5554 4820 504c 4149 4e20 4c4f 4749 4e0d UTH.PLAIN.LOGIN. 0x0090: 0a32 3530 2d53 5441 5254 544c 530d 0a32 .250-STARTTLS..2 0x00a0: 3530 2048 454c 500d 0a 50.HELP.. 20:48:55.871638 IP 192.168.178.220.1035 > smtp-ha.web.de.25: P 14:42(28) ack 205 win 6432 0x0000: 4500 0044 c517 4000 4006 6831 c0a8 b2dc E..D..@.@.h1.... 0x0010: d948 c09d 040b 0019 2cb2 f334 fc63 27c7 .H......,..4.c'. 0x0020: 5018 1920 6a6a 0000 4d41 494c 2046 524f P...jj..MAIL.FRO 0x0030: 4d3a 3cxx xxxx xxxx xxxx 4077 6562 2e64 M:<xxxxxxx@web.d 0x0040: 653e 0d0a e>.. 20:48:55.912909 IP smtp-ha.web.de.25 > 192.168.178.220.1035: P 205:337(132) ack 42 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 00ac 3659 4000 3706 ff87 d948 c09d E...6Y@.7....H.. 0x0010: c0a8 b2dc 0019 040b fc63 27c7 2cb2 f350 .........c'.,..P 0x0020: 5018 16d0 782b 0000 3530 3120 4b65 696e P...x+..501.Kein 0x0030: 6520 4175 7468 656e 7469 6669 7a69 6572 e.Authentifizier 0x0040: 756e 672c 206f 6465 7220 504f 5033 2d41 ung,.oder.POP3-A 0x0050: 6e6d 656c 6475 6e67 207a 7520 7765 6974 nmeldung.zu.weit 0x0060: 2069 6e20 6465 7220 5665 7267 616e 6765 .in.der.Vergange 0x0070: 6e68 6569 7420 2e20 2f20 4175 7468 656e nheit.../.Authen 0x0080: 7469 6669 6361 7469 6f6e 2066 6169 6c65 tification.faile 0x0090: 642c 206f 7220 504f 5033 206c 6f67 6f6e d,.or.POP3.logon 0x00a0: 2074 6f6f 206f 6c64 2e20 0d0a .too.old.... 20:48:55.913907 IP 192.168.178.220.1035 > smtp-ha.web.de.25: P 42:48(6) ack 337 win 7504 0x0000: 4500 002e c518 4000 4006 6846 c0a8 b2dc E.....@.@.hF.... 0x0010: d948 c09d 040b 0019 2cb2 f350 fc63 284b .H......,..P.c(K 0x0020: 5018 1d50 9481 0000 5155 4954 0d0a P..P....QUIT.. 20:48:55.944418 IP smtp-ha.web.de.25 > 192.168.178.220.1035: P 337:375(38) ack 48 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 004e 365a 4000 3706 ffe4 d948 c09d E..N6Z@.7....H.. 0x0010: c0a8 b2dc 0019 040b fc63 284b 2cb2 f356 .........c(K,..V 0x0020: 5018 16d0 d437 0000 3232 3120 736d 7470 P....7..221.smtp 0x0030: 3037 2e77 6562 2e64 6520 636c 6f73 696e 07.web.de.closin 0x0040: 6720 636f 6e6e 6563 7469 6f6e 0d0a g.connection.. 20:48:55.945273 IP 192.168.178.220.1035 > smtp-ha.web.de.25: F 48:48(0) ack 375 win 7504 0x0000: 4500 0028 c519 4000 4006 684b c0a8 b2dc E..(..@.@.hK.... 0x0010: d948 c09d 040b 0019 2cb2 f356 fc63 2871 .H......,..V.c(q 0x0020: 5011 1d50 3c16 0000 P..P<... 20:48:55.947828 IP smtp-ha.web.de.25 > 192.168.178.220.1035: F 375:375(0) ack 48 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 0028 365b 4000 3706 000a d948 c09d E..(6[@.7....H.. 0x0010: c0a8 b2dc 0019 040b fc63 2871 2cb2 f356 .........c(q,..V 0x0020: 5011 16d0 4296 0000 4b24 0000 0046 P...B...K$...F 20:48:55.948285 IP 192.168.178.220.1035 > smtp-ha.web.de.25: . ack 376 win 7504 0x0000: 4500 0028 c51a 4000 4006 684a c0a8 b2dc E..(..@.@.hJ.... 0x0010: d948 c09d 040b 0019 2cb2 f357 fc63 2872 .H......,..W.c(r 0x0020: 5010 1d50 3c15 0000 P..P<... 20:48:55.975454 IP smtp-ha.web.de.25 > 192.168.178.220.1035: . ack 49 win 5840 0x0000: 4500 0028 365c 4000 3706 0009 d948 c09d E..(6\@.7....H.. 0x0010: c0a8 b2dc 0019 040b fc63 2872 2cb2 f357 .........c(r,..W 0x0020: 5010 16d0 4295 0000 b45d 0000 0046 P...B....]...FThere is a message "no autorisation", but under <services> I have the line:
It works, if I have logged in my web.de account.
The question is, why does the authentification not work with the Email function.
Chris
Hi,
The email function in linknx uses SMTP-AUTH for authentication:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SMTP_AUTH#SMTP-AUTH
Web.de probably uses "POP before SMTP"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/POP_before_SMTP
Jean-François
Hi Jean-François,
thanks for your reply. Web.de uses SMTP-Authentication OR "POP before SMTP". But on my installation the SMTP-Authentication of linknx don't function at web.de and strato.de either. I have the actual versions of linknx (0.0.1.27-2) and libsmtp (1.0.4-2). Can you give me a hint, where I can search for this problem?
Chris
Hi,
What libEsmtp are you using. Did you compile it yourself (with what options)? Do you use a precompiled binary? Where does-it come from?
I looked at your tcpdump and at the libEsmtp source code and it looks like if libEsmtp was compiled without the authentication support.
Regards,
Jean-François
Hi,
I am using the version from your site http://ouaye.net/linknx/OpenWRT-WhiteRussian-RC6.
Its running on a WRT54GS with White Russian 0.9 and X-Wrt Webinterface. Its possible, that the email function didn't work at all with this combiation, I don't know. Maybe its a problem with this combiation.
Best regards,
Chris
Hi,
I think I've found the problem. The authentication plugins were not included in the ipk. I made a new one:
http://ouaye.net/linknx/OpenWRT-WhiteRussian-RC6/libesmtp_1.0.4-3_mipsel.ipk
After installing it, you should have a /usr/lib/esmtp-plugins/ directory on your router containing the sasl plugins.
Regards,
Jean-François
Hi Jean-François,
thank you for this package! With this package the email-function works correctly at strato.de, but not at web.de.
Strato sends this:
Web.de sends this:
.250-AUTH.PLAIN.LOGIN...250-STARTTLS...Maybe Web.de uses an other authentication.
I will switch back to strato.de as smtp host.
As an interim solution I tried an other way to send my emails: SSMTP works good, too.
Thanks again for fixing the libesmtp package.
Best regards,
Chris