From: Uwe B. <uwe...@gm...> - 2007-09-25 14:58:43
|
Hello Darren, hello everybody, I am using xine-lib 1.1.8-1 within latest Debian Sid. There is one bug I already mentioned which is not fixed yet. Using xine-ui 0.99.5+cvs20070914-1 and gxine 0.5.11-3 for watching DVB-S television I get only the french audio audio stream watching Arte on Astra-19.2 E with frequency 11836. Trying to switch to german audio stream within latest xine-ui results in no audio at all. Using gxine 0.5.11-3 for the same the default language is French too. Should be German instead, at least for frequency 11836. Reinhard Tartler concluded that the bug must be in xine-lib, NOT in both the GUIs. Question: Can someone reading that please reproduce that error? Can someone please fix that? Thank you :) Uwe |
From: Christophe T. <hf...@fr...> - 2007-09-25 15:14:19
|
Le mardi 25 septembre 2007 16:58, Uwe Bugla a =E9crit=A0: > Hello Darren, hello everybody, > > I am using xine-lib 1.1.8-1 within latest Debian Sid. > > There is one bug I already mentioned which is not fixed yet. > > Using xine-ui 0.99.5+cvs20070914-1 and gxine 0.5.11-3 for watching DVB-S > television I get only the french audio audio stream watching Arte on > Astra-19.2 E with frequency 11836. > > Trying to switch to german audio stream within latest xine-ui > results in no audio at all. > > Using gxine 0.5.11-3 for the same the default language is French too. > Should be German instead, at least for frequency 11836. > > Reinhard Tartler concluded that the bug must be in xine-lib, NOT in > both the GUIs. > > Question: > > Can someone reading that please reproduce that error? > > Can someone please fix that? > > Thank you :) > > Uwe demux-ts picks the first audio pid it finds. To get multiple audio channels, demux-ts requires a PMT section. You can either use an app that generates such a PMT or edit your channels.c= onf=20 to remove the unwanted audio pids. =2D-=20 Christophe Thommeret |
From: Uwe B. <uwe...@gm...> - 2007-09-25 16:28:24
|
Am Dienstag, 25. September 2007 17:14:15 schrieb Christophe Thommeret: > Le mardi 25 septembre 2007 16:58, Uwe Bugla a =E9crit=A0: > > Hello Darren, hello everybody, > > > > I am using xine-lib 1.1.8-1 within latest Debian Sid. > > > > There is one bug I already mentioned which is not fixed yet. > > > > Using xine-ui 0.99.5+cvs20070914-1 and gxine 0.5.11-3 for watching DVB-S > > television I get only the french audio audio stream watching Arte on > > Astra-19.2 E with frequency 11836. > > > > Trying to switch to german audio stream within latest xine-ui > > results in no audio at all. > > > > Using gxine 0.5.11-3 for the same the default language is French too. > > Should be German instead, at least for frequency 11836. > > > > Reinhard Tartler concluded that the bug must be in xine-lib, NOT in > > both the GUIs. > > > > Question: > > > > Can someone reading that please reproduce that error? > > > > Can someone please fix that? > > > > Thank you :) > > > > Uwe > > demux-ts picks the first audio pid it finds. Sorry, but this sounds quite confusing and misleading :( The audio PID for arte on 11836, Astra 19.2, is 402. Normal behaviour for that channel on that frequency is GERMAN as default au= dio=20 stream, not FRENCH!! Normal behaviour for arte on frequency 11567, Astra 19.2 is FRENCH, audio P= ID=20 is 136. > To get multiple audio channels, demux-ts requires a PMT section. > You can either use an app that generates such a PMT or edit your > channels.conf to remove the unwanted audio pids. Thank you for the hint, Christophe :) I can use kaffeine, and I can use mplayer. Within them the problem does not appear. Using xine-ui, the problem appears as follows: Starting frequency 11836 (audio PID 402) for the first time, I do not get a= ny=20 sound at all. The default sound stream should be German. Switching to the french frequency (11567) I get french audio stream. Switching back to the German frequency (11836) I get french audio stream=20 instead of the German one. Trying to change the audio stream on frequency 11567 (i. e. the French one)= to=20 German I do not get any sound at all. As this problem does not appear neither with mplayer nor with kaffeine, the bug MUST result in xine-ui and nowhere else! A. On whatever frequency f. ex. arte appears there must be the chance to=20 change the audio stream within the GUI (f. ex. xine-ui) if the channel is=20 bilingual or even trilingual (f. ex. the Luxembourg TV channels). B. This change ought to be set graphically in xine-ui, as it is set=20 graphically in gmplayer also. Now, as I am very convinced that someone poking around in xine-ui fucked it= =20 all up: Second try: Can someone please try to reproduce the problem with xine-ui, gxine and=20 frequencies 11836 and 11567, audio PID 402, video PID 401 on Astra-19.2 E? Thanks Uwe P. S.: My channels.conf was produced with latest dvb-apps. In so far I cann= ot=20 and will not simply wipe out inappropriate audio PIDs. |
From: Darren S. <li...@yo...> - 2007-09-25 16:54:37
|
I demand that Uwe Bugla may or may not have written... > Am Dienstag, 25. September 2007 17:14:15 schrieb Christophe Thommeret: >> Le mardi 25 septembre 2007 16:58, Uwe Bugla a =E9crit=A0: >>> I am using xine-lib 1.1.8-1 within latest Debian Sid. >>> There is one bug I already mentioned which is not fixed yet. >>> Using xine-ui 0.99.5+cvs20070914-1 and gxine 0.5.11-3 for watching DV= B-S >>> television I get only the french audio audio stream watching Arte on >>> Astra-19.2 E with frequency 11836. >>> Trying to switch to german audio stream within latest xine-ui >>> results in no audio at all. >>> Using gxine 0.5.11-3 for the same the default language is French too.= >>> Should be German instead, at least for frequency 11836. [snip] >> demux-ts picks the first audio pid it finds. > Sorry, but this sounds quite confusing and misleading :( There's nothing confusing or misleading about it (that I can see). > The audio PID for arte on 11836, Astra 19.2, is 402. Normal behaviour f= or > that channel on that frequency is GERMAN as default audio stream, not > FRENCH!! One audio PID for this channel =3D> one audio stream =3D> not a bug. > Normal behaviour for arte on frequency 11567, Astra 19.2 is FRENCH, aud= io > PID is 136. One audio PID for this channel =3D> one audio stream =3D> not a bug. [snip] > As this problem does not appear neither with mplayer nor with kaffeine,= the > bug MUST result in xine-ui and nowhere else! Do you *really* mean that xine-ui is a consequence of this bug? :-) > A. On whatever frequency f. ex. arte appears there must be the chance t= o > change the audio stream within the GUI (f. ex. xine-ui) if the channel = is > bilingual or even trilingual (f. ex. the Luxembourg TV channels). There is. It's called "changing channel". > B. This change ought to be set graphically in xine-ui, as it is set=20 > graphically in gmplayer also. See the playlist :-) ISTM that (unless these two channels have at any time different video content) both instances of 'arte' should be broadcast as one channel with= one video stream and *two* audio streams. [snip] --=20 | Darren Salt | linux or ds at | nr. Ashington, | Toon | RISC OS, Linux | youmustbejoking,demon,co,uk | Northumberland | Army | + Use more efficient products. Use less. BE MORE ENERGY EFFICI= ENT. Overload - core meltdown sequence initiated. |
From: Uwe B. <uwe...@gm...> - 2007-09-25 18:17:58
|
Am Dienstag, 25. September 2007 18:40:07 schrieb Darren Salt: > I demand that Uwe Bugla may or may not have written... > > > Am Dienstag, 25. September 2007 17:14:15 schrieb Christophe Thommeret: > >> Le mardi 25 septembre 2007 16:58, Uwe Bugla a =E9crit=A0: > >>> I am using xine-lib 1.1.8-1 within latest Debian Sid. > >>> > >>> There is one bug I already mentioned which is not fixed yet. > >>> > >>> Using xine-ui 0.99.5+cvs20070914-1 and gxine 0.5.11-3 for watching > >>> DVB-S television I get only the french audio audio stream watching Ar= te > >>> on Astra-19.2 E with frequency 11836. > >>> > >>> Trying to switch to german audio stream within latest xine-ui > >>> results in no audio at all. > >>> > >>> Using gxine 0.5.11-3 for the same the default language is French too. > >>> Should be German instead, at least for frequency 11836. > > [snip] > > >> demux-ts picks the first audio pid it finds. > > > > Sorry, but this sounds quite confusing and misleading :( > > There's nothing confusing or misleading about it (that I can see). > > > The audio PID for arte on 11836, Astra 19.2, is 402. Normal behaviour f= or > > that channel on that frequency is GERMAN as default audio stream, not > > FRENCH!! > > One audio PID for this channel =3D> one audio stream =3D> not a bug. > > > Normal behaviour for arte on frequency 11567, Astra 19.2 is FRENCH, aud= io > > PID is 136. > > One audio PID for this channel =3D> one audio stream =3D> not a bug. > > [snip] > > > As this problem does not appear neither with mplayer nor with kaffeine, > > the bug MUST result in xine-ui and nowhere else! > > Do you *really* mean that xine-ui is a consequence of this bug? :-) Yes, I do! Out of two reasons: A. The problem did not appear at all in earlier versions (the weaker argume= nt) B. kaffeine 0.8.5 depends on the same kind of xine-lib (i. e. 1.1.8) and,=20 additionally, the problem DOES NOT appear with kaffeine!! - thus xine-lib a= s=20 the reason for the error can safely be excluded (the stronger argument) > > > A. On whatever frequency f. ex. arte appears there must be the chance to > > change the audio stream within the GUI (f. ex. xine-ui) if the channel = is > > bilingual or even trilingual (f. ex. the Luxembourg TV channels). > > There is. It's called "changing channel". > > > B. This change ought to be set graphically in xine-ui, as it is set > > graphically in gmplayer also. > > See the playlist :-) > > ISTM that (unless these two channels have at any time different video > content) both instances of 'arte' should be broadcast as one channel with > one video stream and *two* audio streams. > > [snip] ISTM is chinese for me! Rest sounds correct! Third approach: Who please can reproduce the problem? Who the fuck can please fix it? CU Uwe |