#2334 Qmail-Ldap does not add users

[Philip S. Hempel]

The attempt to add a user to a virtual domain results
in this error. The Ldap server does have the qmail-ldap
schema installed and checking is turned on in the server

Failed to save mailbox : no structural object class
provided

The results for the attempt to add to the server in
ldap are attached to this message.

Is there anything that prevents this from working as I
am able to configure users and get mail delivered
through the Qmail-Ldap?

[Philip S. Hempel]

syslog of slapd request from webmin to add domain user

[Jamie Cameron]

Logged In: YES
user_id=129364

Try clicking on the Module Config link, and adding 'person'
to the 'Other objectClasses to add to new users' field.

[Philip S. Hempel]

Logged In: YES
user_id=207958

Added the people object as you suggested..

I had before added all of the classess and attributes that
were in the qmail-ldap schema, with no luck.

I have attached the output of the slapd server

[Philip S. Hempel]

syslog of slapd request from webmin to add domain user with the object people added

[Jamie Cameron]

Logged In: YES
user_id=129364

You added 'person' rather than 'people' , right?
If that still doesn't work, try adding 'top' as well..

[Philip S. Hempel]

Logged In: YES
user_id=207958

Yes I had added person. I addes top as well and then I tried
for giggles to use inetOrgPerson

Same results

BTW what is the seperator character that is to be used?

[Jamie Cameron]

Logged In: YES
user_id=129364

The separator is a space .. is that what you were using?

[Philip S. Hempel]

Logged In: YES
user_id=207958

yes space is what I was using

[Jamie Cameron]

Logged In: YES
user_id=129364

Just to clarify, are you doing this in the LDAP Users and
Groups module, or the Virtualmin module .. and if the
latter, which version of Virtualmin are you using?

[Philip S. Hempel]

Logged In: YES
user_id=207958

I am doing it in Virtualmin and it is version 2.609

[Jamie Cameron]

Logged In: YES
user_id=129364

Ok .. and I presume that in Virtualmin, the 'Mail server to
configure' is set to 'Qmail+LDAP' ?
You should also leave the 'Store users and groups' set to
'Local files', as this will only apply to non-mail users..

[Philip S. Hempel]

Logged In: YES
user_id=207958

yes to all the above.. these have been the setting I have
used. I think store waa set to local files as default

[Philip S. Hempel]

Logged In: YES
user_id=207958

Here are errors I get when adding a domain with aliases

Adding default mail aliases ..
.. Mail for domain failed! : no structural object class
provided at ../web-lib-funcs.pl line 823

[Philip S. Hempel]

Logged In: YES
user_id=207958

I have turned off schema checking and the results are I can
add users accounts for qmail. The resulting account is void
of top person or any other object class save qmailUser.

I changed local in feature-mail.pl to look like this

local $attrs = [ "objectClass" => "top",
"objectClass" => "person",
"objectClass" => "qmailUser",
"sn" => "$box",
"cn" => "$user",
"uid" => "$box-$dom",
"deliveryMode" => "nolocal",
"mail" => $box."\@".$dom,
"mailForwardingAddress" =>
$_[0]->{'to'} ];

This allows additions.. but I know there may be other bugs

[Jamie Cameron]

Logged In: YES
user_id=129364

Thanks, I see the problem now .. it is caused by LDAP
aliases, not LDAP users. I will fix this in the next release
of Virtualmin.