RentMy vs. Rentshelf Comparison


RentMy	Rentshelf Skytech Services	+	+
Learn More Update Features	Learn More Update Features	Add To Compare	Add To Compare


		Related Products TurboTenant TurboTenant is an all-in-one property management software built for independent landlords. More than 1 million landlords use it to market rentals, screen tenants, create leases, collect rent, and manage maintenance, with optional full-service management through TurboTenant Autopilot for a flat fee. Founded in 2015 and headquartered in Fort Collins, Colorado, TurboTenant also owns TenantCloud and REI Hub. 874 Ratings Visit Website Smoobu Smoobu is a vacation rental management software designed to streamline short-term rental operations. It features a Property Management System (PMS) for managing rentals centrally. The Channel Manager syncs calendars across booking sites, preventing double bookings and ensuring up-to-date availability. Smoobu's Booking Engine focuses on attracting and retaining guests by enabling users to design their own booking system, boosting direct bookings and revenue. The Guest Communication module personalizes and schedules messages to enhance guest experiences. The Website Builder creates personalized sites to reach more guests, while the Guest Guide provides detailed information. Smoobu Dynamic Pricing adjusts rates to attract bookings. With Statistics and Account Access, users can manage teams and view rental operations. Smoobu supports various property types, from apartments to boutique hotels, offering centralized bookings and performance tracking for properties of all sizes. 209 Ratings Visit Website wp2print wp2print is an e-commerce web-to-print system built specifically to help print providers sell products online. wp2print can sell digital, wide-format, book products, blueprints and more. wp2print has proofing and production management built right in. wp2print, based on WordPress, has a number of strong advantages: 1. Powerful pricing calculators for very accurate price calculations 2. File uploader that can handle any file format and unlimited file sizes 3. Award-winning Design Online tool 4. Public and Private stores 5. Open-source code allows for customization if required 6. Available for monthly rental and 1-time purchase 7,748 Ratings Visit Website Hostaway Trusted by 20,000+ property managers worldwide, Hostaway is the industry leading, AI-powered vacation rental management platform designed for professional short-term rental operators. WHAT YOU CAN DO WITH HOSTAWAY Real-time sync on calendars, pricing, and messages across all major channels (Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Google) Automate 93% of repetitive guest communication with AI Replies Increase earnings by 25%+ with Dynamic Pricing Track performance with advanced reporting and insights Self-serve Owner Portals and automated statements for professional, transparent owner reporting Create or connect your own direct booking website WHY HOSTS CHOOSE HOSTAWAY For property managers scaling from 5 to 500+ properties, Hostaway grows with you. And, for when you need assistance: Award winning 24/7 phone support, with help always a call away A comprehensive Help Center for self-service A 97%+ customer satisfaction rating Global team for multi-language coverage 2,110 Ratings Visit Website Convesio Convesio is a next-generation hosting and payment platform built to help commerce businesses grow faster, smarter, and more securely. Designed for WordPress and WooCommerce, Convesio combines high-performance hosting with an integrated payment ecosystem — ConvesioPay — that streamlines how merchants accept, process, and manage transactions online. With ConvesioPay, businesses get access to fast, secure payment processing that’s deeply connected to their hosting environment. This means lower latency, fewer plugin conflicts, and real-time visibility into revenue performance — all from a single dashboard. Combined with Convesio’s scalable container-based hosting, built-in caching, and advanced uptime management, the result is an optimized foundation for conversion, reliability, and growth. From startups to enterprise-level ecommerce operations, Convesio empowers merchants to focus on selling — not managing servers or chasing integrations. 63 Ratings Visit Website Retreat Guru Retreat Guru is the ONLY all-in-one retreat management software. It was built specifically for retreat centers with all of their needs, complexities, and concern in mind. Retreat Guru was designed to help all kinds of retreat centers like christian and faith-based, health & wellness, spiritual, buddhist, yoga, mediation, etc. to easily set up programs, manage them efficiently, and save more time by: - Accepting bookings directly from your website. - Allowing guests to book their rooms with programs at the same time. - Automatically generating guest statements. - Accessing detailed meal, housekeeping, accounting, and other reports. - Automatically sending pre-arrival and post-departure emails to guests. - Collecting space rental inquiries from other retreat leaders. - Offering special discounts and flexible payment options for guests. - Offering dynamic room set-up based on who books it first. - Keeping your entire team in sync by storing all retreat data in one place. 134 Ratings Visit Website MarkMagic MarkMagic barcode label software is the easiest way to design and print the barcode labels, electronic forms, reports, and RFID tags you need to communicate with your customers and suppliers. MarkMagic is the barcoding software engine inside the most popular warehouse and retail inventory management software in the industry such as Manhattan Associates, Oracle, Infor, United Rentals, Honeywell Intelligrated, Apparel Business Systems, Varsity Logistics, and VAI. Powerful and easy to use, once you try MarkMagic, you’ll see why thousands of software vendors and customers worldwide rely on the software to create their business-critical documents. 48 Ratings Visit Website Park With Us Managing your campground has never been this simple. Park With Us is the world’s most user-friendly campground management software, and it’s always free for you. ✅ Effortless Reservation Management – Our intuitive drag-and-drop interface makes handling short-term and seasonal bookings a breeze, including invoicing and utility tracking. ✅ Seamless Online Bookings – Let guests reserve directly from your website with a branded booking flow—in 60 seconds or less! ✅ Total Business Automation – From RV sites and tent spots to cabins, kayak rentals, boat slips, and more—Park With Us streamlines it all. Book a demo today, and we'll set up your park for you—completely free! Once you're ready, we’ll have you live within a week, bringing in more campers and giving you more time to focus on what matters. 35 Ratings Visit Website Odoo Odoo is a fully integrated, customizable, open-source software packed with hundreds of expertly designed business applications. Odoo’s intuitive database is able to meet a majority of business needs, such as: CRM, Sales, Project, Manufacturing, Inventory, and Accounting, just to name a few. Odoo is an all-in-one software solution designed to meet the needs of companies, regardless of their size (or budget). The unbeatable, seamless nature of Odoo helps businesses become more efficient by reducing redundant manual processes, which helps companies save countless hours of labor. Every module is interconnected to provide a fully-integrated experience from app to app, and users can automate many processes that would’ve otherwise required manual inputs into multiple applications. Odoo keeps all business functions in one place, allowing teams to collaborate with other departments from one unified platform in the most efficient way possible. 1,729 Ratings Visit Website PayKings PayKings is a merchant account provider that helps businesses secure payment processing services in industries often rejected by traditional payment processors. The platform offers merchant accounts, payment gateways, and payment processing solutions designed to support businesses with specialized risk profiles. What is a high risk merchant account? A high risk merchant account is a payment processing account for merchants that are classified in a high risk category. They require high risk credit card processing solutions. The PayKings Team can get you approved today for a low to high risk merchant account for B2B, eCommerce, or Retail at reduced rates and fees. Credit repair merchant accounts are essential for companies in the credit repair space. You provide credit solutions to your customers and we’ll take care of the payment processing. Selling any type of merchandise through an ecommerce store has its risks. 105 Ratings Visit Website
About Powerful rental platform with WordPress plugin to add real-time rentals to your website for e-commerce payment processing, shipping and inventory tracking and too many features to list. Set up an easy-to-use online booking system, synced with your inventory for up-to-the-second availability. Perfect for rental companies with a storefront, and works great for pop-ups, too. SSL-protected, reliable and secure way to capture Customer payments (without the commissions) Want to offer real-time, secure rentals to Customers? Sell and rent products. Need dynamic shipping and/or delivery fee calculation. Want to use their merchant processor to handle online payments? Want to take control of their rentals on their terms. Save time & money using the RentMy integrated card-present payments option. Works like a traditional POS, but with powerful options to run your rental business.	About Rentshelf is a Shopify app for merchants renting physical products through an online store. It adds date-based booking to product pages, checks stock availability for every rental date, and prevents overlapping bookings for the same item. Customers choose dates and add-ons, then pay through Shopify checkout. Merchants configure daily, tiered, weekend, seasonal, or fixed-package pricing; refundable deposits; paid extras; and buffer days between bookings. An admin calendar supports booking, pickup, return, and late-rental workflows, with reminder emails, Shopify POS check-in and check-out, and Shopify Flow automation. Use cases include bikes, outdoor and sports equipment, cameras, apparel and dress hire, baby gear, furniture, tools, and event rentals. Rentshelf helps Shopify merchants manage rental inventory and operations alongside their ecommerce storefront.
Platforms Supported Windows Not Supported Mac Not Supported Linux Not Supported Cloud Supported On-Premises Not Supported iPhone Supported iPad Supported Android Supported Chromebook Not Supported	Platforms Supported Windows Not Supported Mac Not Supported Linux Not Supported Cloud Supported On-Premises Not Supported iPhone Not Supported iPad Not Supported Android Not Supported Chromebook Not Supported
Audience Rental companies searching for a solution to manage and improve their operations	Audience Shopify merchants that rent physical products, including equipment, bicycles, skis, cameras, apparel, baby products, furniture, tools, and event supplies.
Support Phone Support Not Supported 24/7 Live Support Not Supported Online Supported	Support Phone Support Not Supported 24/7 Live Support Not Supported Online Supported
API Offers API Not Supported	API Offers API Not Supported
Screenshots and Videos View more images or videos	Screenshots and Videos View more images or videos
Pricing No information available. Free Version Supported Free Trial Not Supported	Pricing $9.99/month Free plan for up to 3 rental products. Starter is $9.99/month and Growth is $19.99/month. Paid plans include a 7-day free trial. No per-booking commission. Free Version Supported Free Trial Supported
Reviews/Ratings Overall 2.0 / 5 ease 3.0 / 5 features 4.0 / 5 design 3.0 / 5 support 3.0 / 5 Read all reviews	Reviews/Ratings Overall 0.0 / 5 ease 0.0 / 5 features 0.0 / 5 design 0.0 / 5 support 0.0 / 5 This software hasn't been reviewed yet. Be the first to provide a review: Review this Software
Pros & Cons from Real Users Pros After setting up my yard sign rental business, I was eager to find a rental website platform. I checked out quite a few and found that Rentmy seemed to have all of the features I was looking for. In hindsight, there are much better and cheaper ones out there. More of that later. Please read the entire review to see why I would not recommend using RentMy for your business. USING THE PROGRAM: RentMy offered a free, but limited, plan which I thought would be perfect while I was figuring things out. While there are a nice selection of features, locating the right place to make changes to inventory and other items is not very intuitive. You may find yourself searching all over the menus to find what you are looking for. Secondly, navigating the screens is absolutely infuriating. Tapping on a menu item usually brings up a second, half screen of items and selections. The problem is finding just the right place on the screen to place your curser so that you can scroll up or down. Even after 2 months of using the software, I was still struggling every time. Another major issue is that the website does not load the first time. I had several customers tell me that the website was not working. Only after a person refreshes the page, will the site load (although extremely slowly). I made quite a few requests for computer chats to ask for help, and to their credit, they were quite helpful and responsive. They were almost always available when I requested a chat. Most of the questions I had were either trying to figure out how to achieve a particular function or asking to make something work that wasn’t working properly. Everything was fine until I received a message that read something to the effect of, “You have exhausted your amount of time for assistance. Please purchase a paid plan”. That was all fine except for the fact that I still needed help fixing things that weren’t working correctly before I felt comfortable paying $60 a month. Since I really needed their assistance to fix the problems, I went ahead and signed up for a paid plan. I was extremely disappointed to find out that even after paying for a plan, the website was still directing to Rentmy as the main site and referring to their website when I sent a customer a link to my website. I was told that I would have to pay another $100 to have their name removed from the web address. As it turned out, there was absolutely no benefit to upgrading to the paid plan. There was an option to downgrade back to the free site so I immediately did that. ETHICS AND BUSINESS PRACTICES: Here’s where it gets ugly. I remained on the free plan, even though they kept “adding” limiting features. For example, just a few days ago, they added a large watermark with the RentMy logo on top of all of my product images. I get it! They want people to purchase the paid plan. I understood this and chose to keep it like this until I decided if I was going to stay with them or find another rental platform. I didn’t have to wait long as RentMy made that decision for me. Remember when I said I had paid for a one month paid plan? I downgraded to the free, limited, version and expected that to be that. I got an email today, saying “Your subscription will renew soon”. “ This is a friendly reminder that your Renterval LLC subscription will automatically renew on September 30, 2020. Wait! What? I cancelled that subscription. This must be a mistake, right? So I emailed them, telling them that I did not want to renew the subscription. I received a reply a few minutes later saying they were cancelling my account per my request. I replied that I would like to keep the account active until the end of the month. They replied back that they were keeping my data on file until the end of the month (6 more days) but that they deactivated my account because I wasn’t paying. There is so much wrong with this. Where to start. It seems to me that they had some regrets after they set up a free plan and decided that they wanted to do away with that option. But what about the customers that are already on that plan? Perhaps they could send them an email telling them that they are sorry but we are no longer offering the free plan and as of x date, you will either need to choose a paid plan or the account will be closed. That sounds like a reasonable approach, right? Instead, they chose to deactivate my account, immediately, after I let them know I had no intention of letting them charge my card next month without authorization. The consequences? I have lost all of my client information and have no website. Thankfully, I have just found another rental website platform called Reservety. They are responsive, polite, reasonably priced, and most importantly, act with professionalism. Check them out! Cons No communication. Unprofessional. They should learn how to deal with customers to make things better and not charge without authorization.
Training Documentation Supported Webinars Supported Live Online Supported In Person Not Supported	Training Documentation Supported Webinars Not Supported Live Online Not Supported In Person Not Supported
Company Information RentMy Founded: 2008 United States rentmy.co	Company Information Skytech Services United Kingdom rentshelf.app
Alternatives Rent Rabbit	Alternatives No Alternatives
Booqable
Rentware Betterware Software
Rides Rental Software
VEVSoftware View All	View All
Categories Boat Rental Supported Rental Supported	Categories Equipment Rental Supported
Show More Features Rental Features Auto / Boat Rental Supported Contract Management Supported Inspection Management Supported Inventory Management Supported Late Fee Calculation Supported Maintenance Management Supported Medical Equipment Rental Supported Multi-Location Supported Online Booking Supported Rate Management Supported Recurring Rentals Supported Reservations Management Supported Scheduling Supported Short / Long Term Rental Supported
Integrations Google Calendar Not Supported Klaviyo Not Supported Microsoft Outlook Not Supported PayPal Supported Shopify Not Supported Shopify Flow Not Supported Shopify POS Not Supported Stripe Supported WordPress Supported Zoom Not Supported View All 3 Integrations	Integrations Google Calendar Supported Klaviyo Supported Microsoft Outlook Supported PayPal Not Supported Shopify Supported Shopify Flow Supported Shopify POS Supported Stripe Not Supported WordPress Not Supported Zoom Supported View All 7 Integrations
Claim RentMy and update features and information Claim RentMy and update features and information	Claim Rentshelf and update features and information Claim Rentshelf and update features and information