Re: [Xsltforms-support] xf:select without @incremental="true" not working as specified in the recommendation

[Eric v. d. V. <vd...@dy...>]

Alain,

You're 100% right, how can I have understood the opposite when that's so
clearly written? I need more sleep (or more coffee), sorry for the
noise...

Thanks,

Eric

PS: Now I need to fill a bug for betterFORM!

Le dimanche 08 septembre 2013 à 21:26 +0200, Alain Couthures a écrit :
> Eric, 
> > > From my point of view, the incremental mode is the default one for 
> > > select/select1 controls and, as a consequence, a rebuild can occur 
> > > before the focus being lost.
> > Yes, that's also the default for Orbeon Forms and it seems much more
> > natural that way. Unfortunately, my understanding of the recommendation
> > is that this should not be the case...
> > 
> > > I have checked the event sequence with test 4.6.3.a and it is passed (I 
> > > had first to fix an issue about inserting a non relevant node resulting 
> > > in a new relevant node... I have committed another build for this fix).
> > > 
> > > What do you think?
> > IMHO, that boils down to decide if you prefer to be conformant to the
> > recommendation or do what seems natural ;) ...
> > 
> > I tend to think that being conformant to the recommendation should win
> > but that's a hard decision to take!
> Sorry, could you please be more explicit about for which part of the
> recommendation Orbeon Forms and XSLTForms are not compliant?
> 
> From my point of view, incremental="true" "is the default for the
> select or select1 elements" as mentioned at:
> 
> 4.6.3 For select or select1 Controls
>       * When a selection is interactively changed, and the form
>         control has the incremental="true" setting (which is the
>         default for the select or select1 elements), the event
>         sequence is described at 4.6.6 Sequence: Selection Without
>         Value Change, which may be followed immediately by the
>         sequence described at 4.6.7 Sequence: Value Change.
>         
> Thanks!
> 
> -Alain