Menu

#67 drop toolkit name from binary name (change it to xdvi.bin)

open
None
5
2005-09-26
2005-09-26
Anonymous
No

may it be considered to drop the toolkit name from
binary name, i.e. have xdvi.bin instead of
xdvi-motif.bin or xdvi-xaw.bin? that way the names of
xdvi binaries will be the same across unix builds.

Discussion

  • Stefan Ulrich

    Stefan Ulrich - 2005-09-26

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=177175

    The main reasons for having the toolkits included in the binary
    name were:

    - makes it easier to have the two toolkit versions coexist
    on one
    installation (also makes development/testing easier)

    - makes it possible to have different sets of X defaults for
    different toolkit versions

    - makes it more obvious which toolkit was used e.g. in
    bug reports when people forget to add output of -version

    - there are potentially more than 2 toolkits, even if they're
    exotic/obsolete (xaw3d, neXtaw etc.)

    In my view, these reasons still outweight the possible problems
    caused by different names (at least I don't see any real
    problems
    there, but maybe you do?)

     
  • Stefan Ulrich

    Stefan Ulrich - 2005-09-26
    • milestone: 117589 -->
    • assigned_to: nobody --> stefanulrich
     

Log in to post a comment.