From: Erik I. <run...@gm...> - 2025-10-20 20:27:45
|
Dear developers, This evening, I was working PJ6Y in SuperFox mode, but did not observe any OTP verification results. ------ 2025-10-20 - 20:11:00 UTC - 20m - FT8 ------ 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ SP9MOV PJ6Y RR73 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ TA2LG PJ6Y -01 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ SQ2HL PJ6Y -18 ------ 2025-10-20 - 20:11:30 UTC - 20m - FT8 ------ 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ SQ2HL PJ6Y RR73 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ TA2LG PJ6Y -01 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ ON4PB PJ6Y -04 Special operating activity is ticked, as well as SuperFox mode, Hound, OTP, Show OTP messages. Should there be a either a $Verify$ or verified or invalid OTP result line in the Band Activity ? 73's Erik ON4PB |
From: Erik I. <run...@gm...> - 2025-10-20 20:39:04
|
Some more info, I did a fallback to 2.7.0, and there as well, there is no OTP message. So the OM has a SF key (see ncdxf), but probably has not loaded his key by ticking OTP in the Advanced tab, and entering the key. What about a hint at the hound side (and the fox side ?), that the fox is running without OTP key ? 73's Erik ON4PB -----Original Message----- From: Erik Icket <run...@gm...> Sent: Monday, 20 October 2025 22:28 To: wsj...@li... Subject: SuperFox - OTP verification in rel 3.0.0-rc1 Dear developers, This evening, I was working PJ6Y in SuperFox mode, but did not observe any OTP verification results. ------ 2025-10-20 - 20:11:00 UTC - 20m - FT8 ------ 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ SP9MOV PJ6Y RR73 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ TA2LG PJ6Y -01 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ SQ2HL PJ6Y -18 ------ 2025-10-20 - 20:11:30 UTC - 20m - FT8 ------ 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ SQ2HL PJ6Y RR73 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ TA2LG PJ6Y -01 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ ON4PB PJ6Y -04 Special operating activity is ticked, as well as SuperFox mode, Hound, OTP, Show OTP messages. Should there be a either a $Verify$ or verified or invalid OTP result line in the Band Activity ? 73's Erik ON4PB |
From: Dan C. <hot...@ho...> - 2025-10-20 22:31:15
|
I’ve made a couple of handfuls of contacts with them, the ones that were made using SF all showed the verification with the exception of 1 17m contact on 10/18. Even though I got the RR73 from the station I worked, it never confirmed in Clublog. All others confirmed immediately. I can only assume that I worked a pirated call without having them do a log check. I have since reworked that band slot. Sent from my iPhone > On Oct 20, 2025, at 4:42 PM, Erik Icket via wsjt-devel <wsj...@li...> wrote: > > Some more info, > > I did a fallback to 2.7.0, and there as well, there is no OTP message. > So the OM has a SF key (see ncdxf), but probably has not loaded his key by > ticking OTP in the Advanced tab, and entering the key. > > What about a hint at the hound side (and the fox side ?), that the fox is > running without OTP key ? > > 73's Erik > ON4PB > > -----Original Message----- > From: Erik Icket <run...@gm...> > Sent: Monday, 20 October 2025 22:28 > To: wsj...@li... > Subject: SuperFox - OTP verification in rel 3.0.0-rc1 > > Dear developers, > > This evening, I was working PJ6Y in SuperFox mode, but did not observe any > OTP verification results. > > ------ 2025-10-20 - 20:11:00 UTC - 20m - FT8 ------ > 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ SP9MOV PJ6Y RR73 > 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ TA2LG PJ6Y -01 > 201100 -5 0.4 746 ~ SQ2HL PJ6Y -18 > ------ 2025-10-20 - 20:11:30 UTC - 20m - FT8 ------ > 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ SQ2HL PJ6Y RR73 > 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ TA2LG PJ6Y -01 > 201130 -7 0.5 746 ~ ON4PB PJ6Y -04 > > Special operating activity is ticked, as well as SuperFox mode, Hound, OTP, > Show OTP messages. > > Should there be a either a $Verify$ or verified or invalid OTP result line > in the Band Activity ? > > 73's Erik > ON4PB > > > > > > > _______________________________________________ > wsjt-devel mailing list > wsj...@li... > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/wsjt-devel |
From: Joseph T. <jo...@Pr...> - 2025-10-20 20:53:55
Attachments:
image.png
|
Hi Erik, Are you sure the station you're receiving is the legitimate SuperFox? We have seen other examples where the "PJ6Y verified" message appears as expected. Here's one from several days ago. [cid:1c518ba7-4742-42f7-8f5e-73b0e5c9f472] -- 73, Joe, K1JT |
From: Erik I. <run...@gm...> - 2025-10-20 21:46:14
Attachments:
image001.png
|
Dear Joe, I may well have been too naïve in believing so. The thing is that on the hound side, in the absence of an OTP, and all OTP checkboxes ticked, you cannot really tell if an OTP verification is done or not. I believe today, one can observe “$Verify$”, “K1ABC verified”, “K1ABC invalid” in the band activity pane. What if we add a hint at the fox side that the callsign is “not verified” if all OTP checkboxes (Superfox mode, Hound, OTP, Show OTP messages) are ticked ? 73’s Erik ON4PB From: Joseph Taylor <jo...@Pr...> Sent: Monday, 20 October 2025 22:54 To: wsj...@li... Cc: Erik Icket <run...@gm...> Subject: Re: [wsjt-devel] SuperFox - OTP verification in rel 3.0.0-rc1 Hi Erik, Are you sure the station you're receiving is the legitimate SuperFox? We have seen other examples where the "PJ6Y verified" message appears as expected. Here's one from several days ago. -- 73, Joe, K1JT |
From: Erik I. <run...@gm...> - 2025-10-20 21:49:06
Attachments:
image001.png
|
Please read “hound side” and not “fox side” in my last phrase. My apologies. From: Erik Icket <run...@gm...> Sent: Monday, 20 October 2025 23:46 To: 'Joseph Taylor' <jo...@Pr...>; wsj...@li... Subject: RE: [wsjt-devel] SuperFox - OTP verification in rel 3.0.0-rc1 Dear Joe, I may well have been too naïve in believing so. The thing is that on the hound side, in the absence of an OTP, and all OTP checkboxes ticked, you cannot really tell if an OTP verification is done or not. I believe today, one can observe “$Verify$”, “K1ABC verified”, “K1ABC invalid” in the band activity pane. What if we add a hint at the fox side that the callsign is “not verified” if all OTP checkboxes (Superfox mode, Hound, OTP, Show OTP messages) are ticked ? 73’s Erik ON4PB From: Joseph Taylor <jo...@Pr... <mailto:jo...@Pr...> > Sent: Monday, 20 October 2025 22:54 To: wsj...@li... <mailto:wsj...@li...> Cc: Erik Icket <run...@gm... <mailto:run...@gm...> > Subject: Re: [wsjt-devel] SuperFox - OTP verification in rel 3.0.0-rc1 Hi Erik, Are you sure the station you're receiving is the legitimate SuperFox? We have seen other examples where the "PJ6Y verified" message appears as expected. Here's one from several days ago. -- 73, Joe, K1JT |