Menu

#5240 Allow adjacent analysis brackets

New
nobody
None
Enhancement
2018-04-19
2017-11-15
Amir Czwink
No

There is currently no way to have an analysis bracket end on a note and have another bracket begin from exactly that same note. To me thats actually a defect but I guess that wasn't planned in the first place.
Something like "c\stopGroup\startGroup" will not cause the bracket to actually end and another to begin but rather will combine both groups into one. Using voices does also not solve the problem because either the note will appear twice or, when a ghost note is used, the bracket will not span over it.

I've attached my unanswered email to the lilypond mailing list (with examples) and also here is a link to a question on stackoverflow concerning that topic https://stackoverflow.com/questions/45572579/lilypond-adjacent-analysis-brackets

1 Attachments

Related

Issues: #5543

Discussion

  • Malte Meyn

    Malte Meyn - 2018-04-01

    Not only adjacent but also overlapping analysis brackets would be nice:

    c\=1\startGroup d\=2\startGroup e\=1\stopGroup f\=2\stopGroup
    
     
    • Amir Czwink

      Amir Czwink - 2018-04-02

      Overlapping ones are acutally possible by utilizing multiple voices.
      Check for instance this example: http://lilypond.1069038.n5.nabble.com/Analysis-brackets-td45330.html

      However, your syntax proposal would of course be a neat solution to this issue and to writing arbitrarily nested analysis brackets

       
MongoDB Logo MongoDB