Menu

#5142 partcombine can't handle simultaneous hairpins

New
nobody
None
Defect
2017-10-07
2017-06-09
No

Rutger Hofman wrote :

I stumble into a partcombine bug. At times, \partcombine extends hairpins over (possibly long) stretches to the wrong terminating dynamic. In the top staff of the attached MWE, the erroneous behaviour is shown. The bottom staff group shows the intended behaviour. If I specify any of \partcombineApart or \partcombineChords, the bug disappears, second and third staves.

2 Attachments

Discussion

  • Malte Meyn

    Malte Meyn - 2017-10-07

    This is a duplicate of [#5143], isn’t it?

     

    Related

    Issues: #5143

    • Simon Albrecht

      Simon Albrecht - 2017-10-07

      I agree.

       
  • Simon Albrecht

    Simon Albrecht - 2017-10-07

    A more condensed example by Kieren MacMillan:

    \version "2.19.61"
    
    musicA = {
      g'1\> R1\!
    }
    musicB = {
      b'1\> R1\!
    }
    
    \new Staff \partcombine \musicA \musicB